Confessions of an investigative reporter.It's almost two years now since I could have broken the BCCI BCCI Board of Control for Cricket in India BCCI Bank of Credit and Commerce International BCCI Bulgarian Chamber of Commerce and Industry BCCI Bank of Crooks & Criminals International BCCI Barnsley Chamber of Commerce & Industry story. But, as you can tell from the chart to the left, I didn't. In fact, I didn't even come close. A reporter for CNN's investigative unit, I had been dispatched to Tampa, Florida “Tampa” redirects here. For other uses, see Tampa (disambiguation). Tampa is a United States city in Hillsborough County, on the west coast of Florida. It serves as the county seat for Hillsborough County.GR6. , in early 1990 to help unravel the riddle of Manuel Noriega's money laundering The process of taking the proceeds of criminal activity and making them appear legal. Laundering allows criminals to transform illegally obtained gain into seemingly legitimate funds. emprie. Surrounded by the competition--in this case a courtroom of emptry pews--I took frantic notes as five BCCI officials, one of whom had been Noriega's personal banker, stood trial for a ledger of bank-related crimes. Buried in the mound of documents we gathered, as it turned out, were the inklings of the scandal: Huge chunks of Noriega's laundered millions had been funneled through Washington-based First American Bank First American Bank is the name of numerous banks operating separately in each state of the United States. Please refer to the individual articles for more information on each bank. , cryptically labeled in files as "BCCI-Washington." As we worked on the story, the writing was literally on our walls: more than 40 feet of homemade flow charts mapping the wash-cycle of Noriega's millions. But focused as I was on Noriega--that is, the story that everyone from George Bush on down heralded as the story to get--I regarded BCCI as little more than a complex conduit to get me there. Too bad for me, not to mention Ted Turner For other persons named Ted Turner, see Ted Turner (disambiguation). Robert Edward Turner III (born November 19 1938 , who no doubt would have relished picking up the Emmy. I take some consolation in knowing I wasn't alone. After all, some of the nation's top investigative reporters, such as the Los Angeles Los Angeles (lôs ăn`jələs, lŏs, ăn`jəlēz'), city (1990 pop. 3,485,398), seat of Los Angeles co., S Calif.; inc. 1850. Times's Douglas Frantz and CNN's Brian Barger, also ran across bits and pieces of the BCCI puzzle while trailing Noriega but missed the banking scandal all the same. While others, such as Larry Gurwin of Regardie's and Jim McGee of The Washington Post, helped break parts of the story, the real sleuths were government investigators, who not only uncovered most of the story but plugged away for years until the media woke up. It was--as measured by the great yardstick of investigative reporting--Watergate in reverse, with the government hammering away until the media took notice. A rare oversight by the dogged investigators of the Fourth Estate? Hardly. While there is much worthy of praise in the national media's investigative reporting, in one area--perhaps the most important one--we (and I use "we" because, as a CNN CNN or Cable News Network Subsidiary company of Turner Broadcasting Systems. It was created by Ted Turner in 1980 to present 24-hour live news broadcasts, using satellites to transmit reports from news bureaus around the world. investigative reporter until this year, I'm as guilty as the next guy) are woefully woe·ful also wo·ful adj. 1. Affected by or full of woe; mournful. 2. Causing or involving woe. 3. Deplorably bad or wretched: lacking. A close examination of major institutional scandals within government and business in recent years--HUD, the S&Ls, Wedtech, Salomon Brothers
Salomon Brothers was a Wall Street investment bank. , BCCI, corruption at the Chicago commodities exchange, the Ill Wind defense contractor Noun 1. defense contractor - a contractor concerned with the development and manufacture of systems of defense armed forces, armed services, military, military machine, war machine - the military forces of a nation; "their military is the largest in the region"; scandal, and so on--reveals that it wasn't the national press that exposed wrongdoing wrong·do·er n. One who does wrong, especially morally or ethically. wrong do , but the government itself or, in a few cases, the regional or trade press. How could this be? After all, as NBC's award-winning investigator Brian Ross
Brian Ross (born September 4, 1944 in Ballston Spa, New York) is a racecar driver. He won Rookie of the Year honors in the Auto Racing Club of America in 2000. recently told The New York New York, state, United States New York, Middle Atlantic state of the United States. It is bordered by Vermont, Massachusetts, Connecticut, and the Atlantic Ocean (E), New Jersey and Pennsylvania (S), Lakes Erie and Ontario and the Canadian province of Times, we've finally entered the "golden age of investigative reporting." ABC News
ABC News is a division of American television and radio network ABC, owned by The Walt Disney Company. Its current president is David Westin. has not one, but four, investigative teams: one each at "World News Tonight," "PrimeTime," "Nightline," and "20/20." CNN made its debut two years ago with a high-profile team of 30 journalistic sleuths, and CBS's "60 Minutes," long king of TV's investigative hill, still draws tens of millions of viewers. It's the age of the pin-sized camera, the Freedom of Information Act, and unprecedented investment in investigative teams: The combined annual investigative budget for the three networks and CNN tops $150 million. The New York Times, Washington Post, Wall Street Journal, and Los Angeles Times Los Angeles Times Morning daily newspaper. Established in 1881, it was purchased and incorporated in 1884 by Harrison Gray Otis (1837–1917) under The Times-Mirror Co. (the hyphen was later dropped from the name). all have investigative reporters, as do nearly 98 percent of the nation's 500 largest newspapers. The good news in all this is that investigative reporting in the regional and local press is truly in its heyday. And at the national level, investigators at papers like The Washington Post and The New York Times have in recent years made an important commitment to explaining the news rather than breaking it. But while the national media advanced many of the major stories of recent years, in only the rarest of cases did they uncover the scandal. For example, while investigative reporters at The New York Times, Washington Post, and Los Angeles Times have filed approximately 800 stories since 1989, nearly 85 percent of them have been follow-ups or advances of leaked or published government reports. "Most of what we call investigative journalism investigative journalism n → periodismo de investigación these days," explains former Atlanta Journal and Constitution editor Bill Kovach Bill Kovach is an American journalist, former Washington bureau chief of The New York Times, former editor of the Atlanta Journal-Constitution, and co-author of the popular book, , "is really reporting on investigations." While the print press may not be breaking the big stories, they are at least turning over some of the mossy moss·y adj. moss·i·er, moss·i·est 1. Covered with moss or something like moss: mossy banks. 2. Resembling moss. 3. Old-fashioned; antiquated. stones. The problems lie msot glaringly with the source from which most Americans get their news--TV--whose standard method of investigative reporting is dressing up leaked government investigations and running them as their own. ABC's investigative unit, for example, has produced nearly 150 stories since 1988. While these included important efforts like a two-part series in 1989 explaining the international proliferation of biological weapons, more than 85 percent were follow-ups to government investigations. For example, the team produced 10 stories on S&Ls--a worthy topic--but six were simply reports on the latest government advance on the Neil Bush Neil Mallon Bush (born January 22, 1955 in Midland, Texas) is the fourth of six children of former President George Herbert Walker Bush and Barbara Bush (Barbara Lane Pierce). investigation; one was a follow-up to congressional hearings involving Charles Keatings's Lincoln Savings and Loan savings and loan n. a banking and lending institution, chartered either by a state or the Federal government. Savings and loans only make loans secured by real property from deposits, upon which they pay interest slightly higher than that paid by most banks. ; one was a pickup from the trade publication Thrift News disclosing the Keating Five This article or section needs sources or references that appear in reliable, third-party publications. Alone, primary sources and sources affiliated with the subject of this article are not sufficient for an accurate encyclopedia article. ; one told of the federal government seizing property from Michael Milken's junk bond junk bond, a bond that involves greater than usual risk as an investment and pays a relatively high rate of interest, typically issued by a company lacking an established earnings history or having a questionable credit history. customers; and, in probably ABC's best effort on the subject, one disclosed financial connections between Keating and Senator Alan Cranston Alan MacGregor Cranston (19 June 1914 – 31 December 2000) was an American journalist and Democratic Party politician and United States Senator from California. Education Cranston earned his high school diploma from Mountain View High School. . Likewise, the unit produced eight pieces on BCCI, only one of which was based substantially on ABC's own digging. Not only are the original stories few and far between, but when they do appear, they generally have an instinct toward the capillaries. We only rarely step back to examine the most significant problems of governmental, financial, or scientific institutions--why our schools don't educate; how our banking system has failed; where the space program has gone wrong--reports that not only uncover the dirt, but analyze why the system's not working, giving us insight into how to fix it. For more important than uncovering, say, that military employees were pilfering pil·fer v. pil·fered, pil·fer·ing, pil·fers v.tr. To steal (a small amount or item). See Synonyms at steal. v.intr. To steal or filch. millions of dollars worth of government equipment--as was revealed in 1990--is explaining how the system allowed it to happen in the first place. To be sure, such investigations appear occasionally--remember the series of 1990 stories by The Washington Post's Steve Coll Steve Coll (born October 8, 1958 in Washington, DC) is a Pulitzer Prize-winning American journalist and writer. Coll is currently president and CEO of the New America Foundation. and David Vise scrutinizing the Securities and Exchange Commission, or the 1986 series by Arthur Howe of The Philadelphia Inquirer on massive internal deficienciies at the IRS An abbreviation for the Internal Revenue Service, a federal agency charged with the responsibility of administering and enforcing internal revenue laws. ? But these are the exceptions. Yet worse than a lack of ambition and originality is what the networks' multimillion-dollar budgets do produce. Perhaps we can excuse the majority of the fare simply as audience-bait--stories such as a September 1991 "Prime Time" segment, "Brian's Song" (promo blurb blurb n. A brief publicity notice, as on a book jacket. [Coined by Gelett Burgess (1866-1951), American humorist.] blurb v. : "Beach Boy Brian Wilson is said by his family to be under the sway of a Svengali-like psychotherapist psy·cho·ther·a·pist n. An individual, such as a psychiatrist, psychologist, psychiatric nurse, or psychiatric social worker, who practices psychotherapy. who is draining his finances"), or the fact that ABC's "20/20" did more in-depth segments in 1990 on domestic pets (four, including "Who Will Love My Pet: problems/solutions to pest surviving their owner's death or incapacity The absence of legal ability, competence, or qualifications. An individual incapacitated by infancy, for example, does not have the legal ability to enter into certain types of agreements, such as marriage or contracts. ") than on any other topic. But even so, the few stories we are left with that are labeled serious investigations only fit that billing in the most superficial sense. Consider--and only because it was hyped with an almost unprecedented double segment--the December 1990 piece by "60 Minutes" titled "Is There Poison in Your Mouth?" Conducting its own "investigation" of a story that had been percolating for years, the newsmagazine sought to show that ordinary mercury-based dental fillings are, and have been for decades, the cause of a wide range of debilitating de·bil·i·tat·ing adj. Causing a loss of strength or energy. Debilitating Weakening, or reducing the strength of. Mentioned in: Stress Reduction illnesses from multiple sclerosis to kidney failure kidney failure or renal failure Partial or complete loss of kidney function. Acute failure causes reduced urine output and blood chemical imbalance, including uremia. Most patients recover within six weeks. . Although no scientific study had ever linked the dental use of mercury to any illness, "60 Minutes" seized primarily on one 1990 study by a long-time anti-mercury crusader showing that six sheep fitted with mercury fillings had a drop in kidney function. The rest of the reporting was anecdotal. While science reporters at Newsweek and elsewhere had reported the story, stressing that the jury would remain out until the results of two comprehensive studies by the NIH "Not invented here." See digispeak. NIH - The United States National Institutes of Health. and the FDA FDA abbr. Food and Drug Administration FDA, n.pr See Food and Drug Administration. FDA, n.pr the abbreviation for the Food and Drug Administration. were reported, "60 Minutes" refused to wait. There will always remain some measure of doubt, but the studies, released a few months later, both concluded overwhelmingly that the use of mercury-based fillings is safe. At least people closest to the TV news industry are honest with themselves. "It's a lot of PR" explains Av Westin, whose resume includes founding ABC's first investigative effort, "Close-Up," as well as stints as executive producer of "World News Tonight" and "20/20." Everyone wants the cosmetic lure of having an I-team, but by and large what we do is amplify what's already been done elsewhere." Echoing Westin is the former executive producer of CBS's evening news and current CNN Special Assignment producer, Richard Cohen: "[Investigative reporting on TV] is a myth. In fact, the whole concept of reporting isn't held in very high value in television." That should make us nervous. When we in the media rely on others to tell us where to probe, when to look, and even how to look, we entrust to the very people we should be scrutinizing the media's most precious heirloom: the right to set the investigative agenda. And at the same time, we create the mostly false impression that the press is probing our instituions and poking for malfeasance The commission of an act that is unequivocally illegal or completely wrongful. Malfeasance is a comprehensive term used in both civil and Criminal Law to describe any act that is wrongful. instead of selling commercial time to the highest bidder HIGHEST BIDDER, contracts. He who, at an auction, offers the greatest price for the property sold. 2. The highest bidder is entitled to have the article sold at his bid, provided there has been no unfairness on his part. . The easy excuse for all this is the high cost of doing business. Newspapers are facing cutbacks, and time-intensive investigative reports tend to be the first to go. In TV newsrooms, where network investigative pieces cost nearly $5,000 a minute, there appears to be little wiggle room for long-term investigations that can often turn up dry holes. But it didn't take $40,000 a story for a former reporter for a Washington, D.C., television station, Mark Feldstein, to advance--and at times lead--the investigation into Marion Barry. It tends not to be the team of high-priced technicians and video artists that gets the stories, but rather the lone reporter plugging away. Pooped poop 1 n. 1. An enclosed superstructure at the stern of a ship. 2. A poop deck. tr.v. pooped, poop·ing, poops 1. To break over the stern of (a ship). 2. scoopers Blasphemous blas·phe·mous adj. Impiously irreverent. [Middle English blasfemous, from Late Latin blasph as it may sound, we can, in part, blame Woodward and Bernstein for our troubles. The effects of Watergate, the Pentagon Papers, and the Vietnam war--the very forces that helped create the modern investigative frenzy in the first place--have conspired to change the climate of government. But in many ways, we have been slow to change with it. "The results tonight of an ABC News investigation," said Peter Jennings, introducing a May 1991 spot on corruption in the U.S. Customs Service. But the allegations reported, made by Customs insiders two years earlier, had already been investigated by the FBI, DEA DEA - Data Encryption Algorithm , and a U.S. attorney, found to be valied, and been reported in the local print press. The story went on to disclose that the Customs agents who reported the corruption had been punished by their superiors for doing so. Interesting, but the retaliation had also been fully investigated -- and verified -- by both the Customs Service and the federal Merit Systems Protection Board The Merit Systems Protection Board (MSPB) ensures that federal civil servants are hired and retained based on merit. In overseeing the personnel practices of the federal government, the board conducts special studies of the merit systems; hears and decides charges of wrongdoing and . The published results of the board's public hearings, moreover, had long before been reported by the print press. Part of Watergate's well-scrutinized legacy has been an increased ability by the government to monitor itself. Congressional staffs have tripled in size since the early seventies, and legislative initiatives and constituent mail can only occupy so many hands. As a result, more young, eager staffers, led by the much-improved cadre at the GAO, have the time and resources to hunt down fraud and mismanagement mis·man·age tr.v. mis·man·aged, mis·man·ag·ing, mis·man·ag·es To manage badly or carelessly. mis·man age·ment n. . Results of congressional investigations are too numerous to list, but some of the recent headline-grabbers have included universities' misuse of federal funds Federal FundsFunds deposited to regional Federal Reserve Banks by commercial banks, including funds in excess of reserve requirements. Notes: These non-interest bearing deposits are lent out at the Fed funds rate to other banks unable to meet overnight reserve and a legion of problems with the Stealth bomber. Not to be out-investigated, the executive branch boasts inspectors general and other internal watchdogs who now police dozens of federal agencies from Defense to the Postal Service. Endowed with subpoena subpoena (səpē`nə) [Lat.,=under penalty], in law, an order to a witness to appear before a court. A subpoena ad testificandum [Lat. power and with the full weight of the federal government behind them, these federal and congressional investigators have a leg up on the press. Beat the press One result of all this self-policing is that internal investigators often beat the press to the story -- and that's fine: It doesn't matter who blows the whistle on official corruption or wasted taxpayer dollars, as long as somebody does. But as thorough as government investigators might be, there are plenty of stories they miss -- like Iran-contra. Investigative journalists might be going out in search of those elusive stories. Instead, most take the easier path -- becoming increasingly dependent on the inmates' notion of what's wrong with the asylum. An example from my own experience illustrates how it works. In the fall of 1990, while I was at CNN, I followed up a "tip" from a "friend" to a government "source," a Senate staffer who had spent well over a year gathering information showing that a new generation of radar jammers, at $3 million a piece, had repeatedly failed tests under combat situations. Yet the contractor was building the jammers anyway, with the Navy's blessing. Of course, said the Senate staffer, The New York Times was interested, but if CNN could get his boss on camera and get it done within a couple of weeks, the story was ours. I spent the next three weeks on the "scoop," shooting interviews and tracking down sources who had already been tracked down. Finally, dutifully du·ti·ful adj. 1. Careful to fulfill obligations. 2. Expressing or filled with a sense of obligation. du , we shot a half-hour one-on-one with the senator. As it turned out, we never ran the story, but only because of logistical problems. No matter. It was done a few weeks later by the ABC News I-team, running on the evening broadcast under the heading "ABC News Investigation." Should this story have made the national press? Of course, and so should most of the government investigations that uncover fraud, waste, and corruption. But is it the type of story investigative reporters should be doing? Hardly. Hitching ourselves to government investigators' bandwagons does more than make us lazy; it leaves us--and the rest of America--thinking falsely that we are looking where the government isn't. And while we gladly carry the water for the federal investigators who have already chased down the story, how often does it work in reverse? "Almost never," says congressional investigator Peter Stockton. "In fact, I can't think of a lead I've gotten from the national press in recent years." Of course, there's something lazier than tagging along on government investigations: our occasional failure to even go that far, as GAO and inspector general reports that might point reporters in the right direction pile up untouched in newsroom libraries. The massive proportion of the HUD Hud (h d), a pre-Qur'anic prophet of Islam. Hud unsuccessfully exhorted his South Arabian people, the Ad, to worship the One God. scandal, for example, was laid out in IG reports years before the Bush administration turned it into an issue. Likewise, between the inception of the space shuttle program and the Challenger disaster, NASA's inspector generail issued hundreds of audit reports concerning safety problems and defective materials, but the media never noticed. "One of our great failings," says CNN investigative reporter Brooks Jackson, "is that we don't read and synthesize the enormous amount of muckraking muck·rake intr.v. muck·raked, muck·rak·ing, muck·rakes To search for and expose misconduct in public life. [From the man with the muckrake, material these people put out." The cost of laziness isn't just a few unrealized Pulitzers for reporters. By launching our own independent investigations of large institutions, we have the opportunity not just to reveal problems within the system, but to helf fix them before the bailout bill reaches $500 billion or the Challenger explodes. This proactiveness is all the more crucial today, since the legacy of the seventies has rendered the government and other institutions smarter in dealing with the press when they have something to hide. Damage control is now professionally swift and persuasive, as seen in the way the Reagan White House handled Iran-contra immediately after the scandal started to unravel. An even craftier display of press management was the White House's reaction to a February 1989 investigation by The New York Time's top sleuth, Jeff Gerth, into ethical and financial conflicts by Bush's ethics officer, C. Boyden Gray Clayland Boyden Gray, born February 6, 1943, is the United States Ambassador to the European Union. He took that post on January 17, 2006, when President George W. Bush granted him a recess appointment to the post. . Just days before Gerth's piece ran, with the administration aware of the imminent story, the White House leaked its version to The Washington Post. The Post hurried to get out the piece, which, couched in the administration's version of events, raised a much milder set of problems. As expected, the story that ran first received the lion's share of attention, effectively defusing Gerth's tougher analysis. Watergate also enforced the long-held that investigative reportering means the bigger the fish you catch the better the story you've got: From Spiro Agnew to Gary Hart, the stories that center around powerful people dray the biggest crowds. The savings and loans crisis, for example, didn't merit a minute on any investigative broadcast until the Keating Five and Neil Bush were unearthed Unearthed is the name of a Triple J project to find and "dig up" (hence the name) hidden talent in regional Australia. Unearthed has had three incarnations - they first visited each region of Australia where Triple J had a transmitter - 41 regions in all. . The result: While reporters have dutifully "investigated" a slew of allegations of misconduct against people such as New Gingrich, Floyd Flake, Julian Dixon, Donald "Buz" Lukens, William Gray, Gus Savage, Barney Frank, and now Bill Clinton, we missed HUD, Iran-contra, and so on. By scurrying scur·ry intr.v. scur·ried, scur·ry·ing, scur·ries 1. To go with light running steps; scamper. 2. To flurry or swirl about. n. pl. scur·ries 1. The act of scurrying. after the tip of the day, says Los Angeles Times investigator Frantz, "we give short shrift to the really enterprising stuff." The irony is that it's this 'enterprising stuff' --examinations of institutions and systems--that leads most often to catching the big fish. Honest Graft, a book by Brooks Jackson examining Congress's money culture, combined with Washington Post reporter Charles Babcock's long-term reporting on topics such as congressional honoraria, had more to do with the resignations of both Tony Coelho and Jim Wright than any story aimed directly at probing these officials' affairs. Spun and games Watergate may have made the job tougher, but so have obstacles of our own making, starting with the notion of the I-team itself. In theory, the idea's an ingenious one. Beat reporters and editors, in order to keep the tips coming their way, can easily become captives of the agencies they cover. Fearful of losing access, they hold back from revealing the grimy grim·y adj. grim·i·er, grim·i·est Covered or smudged with grime. See Synonyms at dirty. grim i·ly adv. underside of their beats. To the rescue is the I-team, which, unwed to sources or agencies and unencumbered by daily deadlines, can scurry from hit to hit fearless of losing future access. And, as planned, we are detached--so detached, in fact, that we often lack a true understanding of the areas we aer expected to scrutinize. It takes months, sometimes years, to develop reliable, knowledgeable sources, not to mention a true feel for how, say, HUD or Wall Street works. My ineptitude Ineptitude See also Awkwardness. Brown, Charlie meek hero unable to kick a football, fly a kite, or win a baseball game. [Comics: “Peanuts” in Horn, 543] Capt. Queeg incompetent commander of the minesweeper Caine. is picking up BCCI when I practically tripped over it is but one minor illutration. "The problem with the unit idea," explains Steve Luxenberg, editor of The Washington Post's investigative team, "is that your reporters don't have their ears to the ground." It's little wonder then, that much of the S&L scandal was uncovered not by an I-team searching for a story but by reporters from Thrift News who had been poking around the industry for years. Or that some of the national media's most impressive investigative work has come from beat reporters like Washington Post Pentagon correspondent Barton Gellman, who exposed the U.s. military's coverup of friendly fire casualties in the Gulf War. Yet the greatest consequence of the I-teams' lack of depth isn't simply that they miss a few stories. It's that they're particularly vulnerable to manipulation--to being "spun" to report whatever the aggressive insider itches to present. "60 Minutes," for example, ran a story in 1989 stating that the chemical Alar, sprayed on apples to regulate growth, was "the most potent cancer-causing agent in the food supply today." Despite clear pronouncements from the EPA EPA eicosapentaenoic acid. EPA abbr. eicosapentaenoic acid EPA, n.pr See acid, eicosapentaenoic. EPA, n. to the contray, "60 Minutes" instead seized upon a report by an environmental group, the Natural Resources Defense Council The Natural Resources Defense Council (NRDC) is a New York City-based, non-profit non-partisan international environmental advocacy group, with offices in Washington, D.C., San Francisco, Los Angeles, Chicago, and Beijing. Founded in 1970, NRDC today has 1. (NRDC NRDC Natural Resources Defense Council NRDC National Research and Development Centre (Institute of Education, London) NRDC National Realty & Development Corp. ), which, although conducting no new or independent research, concluded that Alar could cause cancer in thousands of children. Turning to NRDC was far from crack reporting. The environmental group, in an attempt to get its story out, had hired a public relations public relations, activities and policies used to create public interest in a person, idea, product, institution, or business establishment. By its nature, public relations is devoted to serving particular interests by presenting them to the public in the most firm that approached "60 Minutes" with the exclusive. "60 Minutes" took the bait and ran the hyped story. The day after the piece ran, the PR firm dispatched a cast of celebrities like Meryl Streep to hold press conferences and get the message out. It took several months to sort out the mess created by the televised report, but it eventually became clear that the risk reported was greatly overblown o·ver·blown v. Past participle of overblow. adj. 1. a. Done to excess; overdone: overblown decorations. b. . In the meantime Adv. 1. in the meantime - during the intervening time; "meanwhile I will not think about the problem"; "meantime he was attentive to his other interests"; "in the meantime the police were notified" meantime, meanwhile , the price of apples fell to its lowest in years and Washington state apple growers lost nearly $125 million. Safety networks Investigative reporters have, of course, come in with some groundbreaking, in-depth stories. At The Washington Post in 1989 Elsa Walsh and Benjamin Weiser uncovered how secret court settlements keep critical consumer-safety information under wraps. And in the same year, former U.S. News and World Report investigator Steven Emerson uncovered millions of dollars in waste and mismanagement at the supersecret Defense Mobilization Planning System Agency and presented a detailed explanation of why the agency didn't work. But occasionally reporters' best efforts never see the light of day, or if they do, they're buried deep in the paper. "There is an institutional reluctance to take on some of these storeis," said an investigative reporter for a national newspaper who asked to remain unidentified. The editors "don't want to get too far ahead of the curve. It's the hardest battle I have." The national media nurtures its reputation for accuracy, preferring to kill or delay a story rather than risk getting it wrong. And that's good. But at the same time, important stories often sit on the shelf until the government blesses them with an official investigation. "As news organizations become bigger and bigger corporations," says Bill Kovach, who now heads Harvard's Nieman Foundation, "they behave more and more like the people they cover"--that is, less and less willing to take risks. A close reading of The New York Times reveals a selection of what should have been front-page stories by Gerth that ran where only the most ardent of news junkies was sure to to see them. In November 1987, his original reporting on a sweetheart deal Sweetheart Deal A merger or company sale where one company involved in the deal gives the other very attractive terms and conditions. Notes: In other words, a sweetheart deal is a transaction that a firm simply cannot pass-up. This is usually considered to be unethical. between then-presidential candidate Bob Dole and a political contributor appeared 68 paragraphs into a 78-paragraph New York Times Magazine profile of the senator. And his August 1986 piece showing that Dan Rostenkowski, who at the time was a leading candidate to replace Tip O'Neill as House Speaker, had lied to the House ethics committee ethics committee A multidisciplinary hospital body composed of a broad spectrum of personnel–eg, physicians, nurses, social workers, priests, and others, which addresses the moral and ethical issues within the hospital. See DNR, Institutional review board. about a blind trust, was placed innocuously on page 30. News takers But as the truly great investigative reporting of recent years suggests, the big improvement we need involves not how we report our stories, but what we report on in the first place. The courts, the pension plans, the military, and other unsexy monoliths are far more crucial to the public interest than Chuck Robb's love life. And only by scrutinizing our institutions--by stepping back and reflecting upon the broader picture--can be live up to the moniker (1) A name, title or alias. See alias. (2) A COM object that is used to create instances of other objects. Monikers save programmers time when coding various types of COM-based functions such as linking one document to another (OLE). See COM and OLE. "investigative." But with each episode of "60 Minutes" and "20/20," it seems we are moving further and further from the ideal. That's unfortunate, since the stories that have the most lasting impact are long-term investigations like those by Philadelphia Inquirer reporters Donald Barlett and James Steele into America's tax inequities in the eighties--stories that played no small part in the tax refrom act of 1986. Wall Street Journal reporter Walt Bogdanich's 1988 look at faulty testing in America's medical labs has spawned hundreds of investigations--and grim exposes--of local labs. Yet equally important are those reports that pick apart our institutions, find that theya re working--and tell us why. For instance, a 1991 New York Times feature by Susan Chira probed inner-city Catholic schools, analyzing why one such school in Detroit sends nearly 85 percent of its students on to post-secondary education, compared to a 55 percent dropout (1) On magnetic media, a bit that has lost its strength due to a surface defect or recording malfunction. If the bit is in an audio or video file, it might be detected by the error correction circuitry and either corrected or not, but if not, it is often not noticed by the human rate at a nearby public school. Certainly, investigative reporters can't be expected to examine institutions all of the time--there are the Nielsens to think about--but we do have the resources to zero in on several each year. By the very nature of our "surprise audits," we might keep the people we cover on their toes, and even break a few big stories in the process. But even if we only get to a handful of such audits each year, we'll succeed in keeping the rest of America's powerwul institutions warily glancing over their shoulders. To cover institutions well, though, we're going to have to rethink how units are organzied and reporters deployed. Each of the major dailies, wire services, and networks have at least one top-notch reporter covering the White House, the Defense department, and so on. Unfortunately they're all taking virtually the same notes on the same press conferences and then filing similar stories. More forward-thinking editors might consider relying on the wire services and CNN to handle the daily flow of briefings and photoops, freeing beat reporters to probe for institutional problems or systemic waste. This team of investigative beat reporters, moreover, would possess the wisdom of experience that prevents them from being spun. But in the real world, the status NBC NBC in full National Broadcasting Co. Major U.S. commercial broadcasting company. It was formed in 1926 by RCA Corp., General Electric Co. (GE), and Westinghouse and was the first U.S. company to operate a broadcast network. thinks it accrues by having a Fred Francis report live from the Defense department on the daily briefing somehow outweights cutting him loose to dig out to depart; to leave, esp. hastily; decamp. See also: Dig the bigger, better story. Given that, we can do the next best thing: Tap into the knowledge and accumulated wisdom of the beat reporters. It happens occasionally, and when it does, the results are impressive. At The Washington Post, investigative reporters Charles Babcock recently broke the story of John Sununu's frequent-flying bonanza. But it was Post White House reporter Ann Devroy who, after learing that Sununu was having financial troubles, turned to Babcock to figure out how the chief of staff could afford to jet around the country. It took Babcock three months to locate and decipher Sununu's travel records, and when he did, the story was there. Unfortunately, as investigative reporters freely admit, they only rarely cross paths with beat reporters. "We've flirted with the idea" of matching beat reporters with investigative reporters, says the Journal's Bogdanich, "but we've never really made it happen." More than simply sharing tips and story ideas, beat reporters should be moved in and out of investigative teams, an approach that would benefit the beat walkers as well as the investigators. The beat reporters might better understand what the investigator looks for whn tackling a story, and possibly even break one himself. At The Philadelphia Inquirer, which has collected an unparalleled nine Pulitzer prizes for investigative work since 1975, there is no investigative unit, explains reporter James Steele. "It's always been a very informal system with people coming and going." In addition, we might reconsider who is doing the reporting. Journalism has become "the last refuge of the vaguely talented," explains The Washington Post's ombudsman, Richard Harwood. "We rarely hire people like accountants and lawyers." Yet some of the most creative examples of in-depth reporting have come from people who don't just know the system, but who were part of the system. Consider, for example, former investment banker Investment Banker A person representing a financial institution that is in the business of raising capital for corporations and municipalities. Notes: An investment banker may not accept deposits or make commercial loans. Michael Lewis, who left Wall Street to become a full-time journalist and relied on his inside view to write Liar's Poker, a rich expose of the power of greed on Wall Street. The book of another banker-turned-journalist, S.C. Gwynne, Selling Money, took the reader on a tour of his working experiences at Chase Bank, revealing how the international debt crisis really developed. At the core, he explained, were 23-year-old international bankers like himself lending millions of dollars to dangerously overleveraged foreign nations and companies. (It was this insider's perspective that also allowed Gwynne, now with Time, to uncover parts of the BCCI scandal.) And then there's John Dean and Taylor Branch's Blind Ambition, which combined the knowledge of an insider with the skills of journalist to reveal more about the culture of the Nixon White House than all of the other Watergate books combined. The vast pressure aides felt to expand their sphere of power combined with Nixon's control-freak nature to set the stage for Watergate. For example, Bob Haldeman's unrelenting internal check-up system, known as the "tickler A manual or automatic system for reminding users of scheduled events or tasks. It is used in PIMs, contact management systems and scheduling and calendar systems. list," kept the pressure on Jeb Stuart Magruder
Jeb Stuart Magruder (born November 5, 1934, New York City) was the second official in the administration of President Richard Nixon (the first was Fred LaRue) to plead guilty to charges of to carry out Haldeman's request to learn more about the Democrats' strategy. Desperate to keep the "tickler" off his back, Magruder turned to an ill-conceived plan to bug the DNC DNC Democratic National Committee DNC Democratic National Convention DNC Do Not Call DNC Delaware North Companies DNC Domain Name Commissioner DNC Direct Numerical Control DNC Do Not Change DNC Does Not Compute DNC Digital Nautical Chart headquarters, and the rest is history. The value of an insider's knowledge is illustrated by the success of football commentator John Madden. When CBS (Cell Broadcast Service) See cell broadcast. lured him into the booth, it brought in one of the best analysts in the business. (Of course, you don't want dumb jocks; you want the guys with enough smarts to put that valuable experience to work.) As the first step toward the Madden standard in media, news organizations could give preference to reporters with real-life experience in areas they are expected to cover. For those reporters without that experience, the next best training is academic; the best business reporters often have studied economics or business. But with or without the background knowledge, reporters and their new organizations should be willing to take the time to fully understand a story--not unlike a trial lawyer who prepares for a malpractice case by attempting to become as much of an expert as possible in the area of medicine in question. It was this kind of commitment by Bob Woodward and Scott Armstrong in The Brethren that allowed them to see that the justices' lowly sounding clerks are some of the most influential people in the nation's justice system, researching and even writing the court's opinions. Finally, we should reconsider the tools we use in our reporting. The national media has long ignored the gold mine of computer-based data that most agencies are now required to make available. From the EPA to the IRS, nearly all government agencies have loaded warehouses of data onto publicly available computer disks. Alone among the nation's major news organizations, the Los Angeles Times has consistently put these large data bases to use, producing a string of standout stories in the last two years--pieces showing how big political donors violate campaign contribution limit laws and how the federal government lost 40 cents on every dollar in the sale of S&L properties. More than simply allowing reporters to poke into new areas, the use of these large data bases frees them from relying on government leakers to tell them what the numbers say. "The average government worker today has a computer on his desk with a lot of information in it," says the Los Angeles Times's investigative editor, Dwight Morris. "If you want to get into the system, you have to think like the system." Scud bluster It was about three weeks after the end of the Gulf war--and about 18 months after I botched botch tr.v. botched, botch·ing, botch·es 1. To ruin through clumsiness. 2. To make or perform clumsily; bungle. 3. To repair or mend clumsily. n. 1. the BCCI story--that I won my first, and only, award as an investigative journalist for a segment I helped produce on Raytheon's Patriot missile. Unfortunately, the award came from Raytheon itself, thanking me for what was, kindly put, a first-rate piece of journalistic puffery puff·er·y n. Flattering, often exaggerated praise and publicity, especially when used for promotional purposes. Noun 1. puffery - a flattering commendation (especially when used for promotional purposes) . From the idea behind the assignment--a reaction to a fleeting development--to the way I reported it--by relying on congressional sources and a mix of Washington-based policy types--I came up with exactly what I should have expected: yet another piece marveling at the space-age technology. Predictably, it has since come to light that the Patriot is beset with a multitude of technical problems. My reward, a bronze "Scudbuster" lapel pin and accompanying certificate, now hang above my desk, where they serve as a reminder of what we can accomplish when we really aren't trying. |
|
||||||||||||||||||

do
d)
Printer friendly
Cite/link
Email
Feedback
Reader Opinion