Printer Friendly
The Free Library
23,416,916 articles and books


Causes of youth unemployment in Pakistan.

Youth unemployment is increasing in less developed as well as developed nations. The disruption caused as a result has some serious repercussion for the less developed countries, which seriously lack initiatives to invest in human capital. This paper focuses on causes of increasing youth unemployment in Pakistan. Data collected from Labour Force Survey 2003-2004, for the age group 15-29, has been made. Various trends are extracted regarding youth unemployment on account of categorical assessment (demographic, educational, and personal). The results are in stark contrast to the general perception for the educated youth, particularly the intensity of unemployment among educated youth in Pakistan and the severity of unemployment in its urban areas, while the provincial governments are apathetic ap·a·thet·ic
adj.
Lacking interest or concern; indifferent.



apa·thet
 about combating unemployment.

JEL classification: C25, E24, J64

Keywords: Youth Unemployment+ Pakistan, Educational Levels, Structural Mismatch of Skills, Discrimination

1. INTRODUCTION

Over the years, many less developed nations and the developing nations have tried to wipe-out the intensity of unemployment, which seems quite prevalent and widespread among these countries. The reasons and causes for this have remained subject to different interpretations depending upon the specifications, demographics, and regional profiles of different countries, thus the perceptions regarding having a plausible solution lacks concurrency Operations that are performed simultaneously within the computer. For example, dual-core CPUs provide complete overlapping of two independent processes. See dual core, hyperthreading, multiprocessing, multitasking, multithreading, SMP and MPP.

concurrency - multitasking
. Not surprisingly among these unemployed a vast majority and victims belongs to young age group. According to according to
prep.
1. As stated or indicated by; on the authority of: according to historians.

2. In keeping with: according to instructions.

3.
 ILO ILO
abbr.
International Labor Organization

Noun 1. ILO - the United Nations agency concerned with the interests of labor
International Labor Organization, International Labour Organization
, there are 160 million unemployed people Noun 1. unemployed people - people who are involuntarily out of work (considered as a group); "the long-term unemployed need assistance"
unemployed

plural, plural form - the form of a word that is used to denote more than one
 in the world and 40 percent of those out of work are young people (World youth report 2003). Pakistan is no exception to this, not only unemployment rates have been beyond reasonable limits but also a vast majority who fall prey to this belongs to youth category (Labour Force Survey 2003-04, 2005-06).

As observed in various countries the unemployment graph accounted for age specification reveals a U shaped pattern high unemployment-in the initial phases or among youth category, a moderate trend for the middle age group people and again highly intensive among old. Pakistan's trend is not far apart from this general trend. Moreover distribution of unemployed according to gender figures out high unemployment rates on the part of females. The recent government programmes have contributed to a high degree in confiscating the child labour by launching the educational campaigns rigorously and by increasing the enrolments at primary levels especially in urban areas. This policy of promoting the education has confined the variance of unemployment rate to reasonable extent on the part of males but on part of females the conventional and traditional norms are still strong enough to impede the way of females from coming out of this hall. Table 1 has fortified fortified (fôrt´fīd),
adj containing additives more potent than the principal ingredient.
 these distributional impacts for the economy of Pakistan Pakistan, a rapidly developing nation, although still a substantially impoverished and underdeveloped country, has suffered from decades of internal political disputes, low levels of foreign investment, and a costly, ongoing confrontation with neighboring India.  which clearly testifies that among the young age group unemployment rate has been higher and also among old, furthermore the data also figures out the intensity of unemployment among females.

High unemployment rates as recorded by 8.3 percent in FY02, 7.7 percent in FY04, 6.2 percent in FY06 and 7.8 percent in FY07 reveals some serious weaknesses in making policies in line with the requirements of combating unemployment appropriately and renders this problem subject to serious monitoring and check. The adverse fact is that not only unemployment rates have been high but also youth unemployment transcended the adult unemployment rates. The causes of this high youth unemployment are manifold: lack of education, lack of skills, structural mismatch, divergence between the demographics of urban and rural areas, lack of experience, regional or province wise discrimination in the provision of job opportunities, sectored imbalance etc. The aim of this research is to scrutinise all those elements which cause unemployment with specifically focusing on youth unemployment because the fate of a nation is ultimately laid down by youth. If initially talents of this delicate group of society are sabotaged because of unfavourable job opportunities, then there would be a great chaos in the economy. The objective of the research is to sort out the reasons of unemployment and thus examining these reasons to make the prevailing situation in Pakistan in compliance with the ground facts and to trace out divergence (if any) to adopt the policies in simulation with the other nations who have successfully combated it. For a comprehensive and detailed perspective of the issue an attempt has been rendered to capture all those variables which could play a momentous role in determining the levels of unemployment and with respect to which we can make a variant analysis effectively.

2. LITERATURE REVIEW

Considerable amount of literature is available in this respect which helps us to scrutinise the different aspects of unemployment as observed throughout the world. The literature helps us to understand its determinants, causes, degree of its spread in different historical phases, the reasons of failures in different societies to outwit out·wit  
tr.v. out·wit·ted, out·wit·ting, out·wits
1. To surpass in cleverness or cunning; outsmart.

2. Archaic To surpass in intelligence.
 this curse and the policy implication as promulgated by different economies to chalk it out. One perception is that the young people are more probable of quitting their jobs voluntarily. The young people are more likely to quit off their jobs in the initial phases of their professional carriers because of their aspirations to seek the best, Flower and Freemen (1996) tested it empirically for the US economy. But this image of the young workers of deliberately not accepting jobs and quitting off is not supported by the study conducted by Lynch (1983) for the United kingdom he found in a survey that only 15 percent young men were those who had multitude job offers at their disposal the rest were scarcely able to be offered only once. The intensity of youth unemployment in comparison to adult has been proved empirically Higgin's (1997), same was proved for the South Asian countries Shehzad (2004). A research conducted by Khan and Ali (1986) explored a bulk of educated unemployed falling below the age of 30 in Pakistan. A research conducted by Gayur (1989) on the repercussions repercussions nplrépercussions fpl

repercussions nplAuswirkungen pl 
 of the unemployment of educated youth attributed the unemployment to the malfunctioning of the educational and training system, which merely neglects demands of the labour markets. Chaudhry and Hamid (1998) divulged the low quality of human resource culpable Blameworthy; involving the commission of a fault or the breach of a duty imposed by law.

Culpability generally implies that an act performed is wrong but does not involve any evil intent by the wrongdoer.
 for unemployment. A study by Lynch (1983) on the spells of youth unemployment declared ethnicity as a significant variable for the long spells of unemployment in Great Britain Great Britain, officially United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland, constitutional monarchy (2005 est. pop. 60,441,000), 94,226 sq mi (244,044 sq km), on the British Isles, off W Europe. The country is often referred to simply as Britain. . A study by Cartmel and Furlong (2000) on the urban and rural youth unemployment revealed long term unemployment to be less common in rural areas than urban areas. A study by Andrews and Nickel (1982) on the after world war phase translated the increment in real wages in lengthening of unemployment spells, a 1 percent rise in real wage resulted in 2 to 5 percent increase in duration of unemployment.

3. DATA AND METHODOLOGY

For the purpose of this research the data has been taken from secondary source of labour force survey (2003-2004). Although according to United Nation's definition, the youth comprises of the age limit 15-24 but to focus primarily on the young people residing in Pakistan the age constraint of 15-29 has been inculcated. Some exceptions of excluding the category of widowers and the data of FATA and Azad Jammu and Kashmir Jammu and Kashmir: see Kashmir.
Jammu and Kashmir

State (pop., 2001: 10,143,700), northern India. With an area of 39,146 sq mi (101,387 sq km), it occupies the southern portion of the Kashmir region of the northwestern Indian subcontinent and is
 have been made to avoid any discrepancy. The labour force survey renders an opportunity to comprehensively study the important characteristics of households by encompassing the demographic, cultural, educational features; this momentous feature distinctly plays a pivotal role for research prospects and provides a healthy opportunity for a meticulous and detailed analysis of the different household categories. A sample of 14515 households has been taken for this research, out of these 1151 are found to be unemployed and 13364 are employed.

Certain variables are included by distributing them in different categories or profiles. Demographic profile [including four provinces, region (rural and urbane), household size and migration], personal profile [including age, sex] and educational profiles (including primary, matric n. 1. admission to a group (especially a college or university).

Noun 1. matric - admission to a group (especially a college or university)
matriculation
, college and higher levels of education and training). The youth unemployment itself is taken as dependent variable and all other categories in different profiles are taken as independent variables. The dependent variable youth unemployment is dichotomous di·chot·o·mous  
adj.
1. Divided or dividing into two parts or classifications.

2. Characterized by dichotomy.



di·chot
 because of its quantitative and qualitative nature. All the independent variables are discrete in nature except age and household size which are continuous variables. The provinces are included to figure out how each province is contributing towards generating youth unemployment. Educational categories are incorporated to translate the variation in youth unemployment for every level of education. Age groups specification scrutinises the age limits in which the young people are most likely to be out of the work force. Region elucidates the share of urban and rural areas in the variance of youth unemployment by encompassing structural flaws of urban areas and skill promoting deficiencies of rural areas. The training variable could be helpful in defining how the training and skill development techniques consequent upon the confiscation confiscation

In law, the act of seizing property without compensation and submitting it to the public treasury. Illegal items such as narcotics or firearms, or profits from the sale of illegal items, may be confiscated by the police. Additionally, government action (e.g.
 of variance of youth unemployment.

In order to deal with the dichotomous dependent variable we have used the normal probability model that emerges from a normal cumulative distribution function. Suppose [yi.sup.*] is the ability to be a part of labour force and be potentially active in the work field it actually depends upon some actively provoking elements or factors denoted by "Xi". The designed equation is as follows:

[yi.sup.*] = [beta]Xi + [epsilon]i Where [beta] represents a row vector In linear algebra, a row vector is a 1 × n matrix, that is, a matrix consisting of a single row:



The transpose of a row vector is a column vector.
 of parameters, and Xi is the column vector In linear algebra, a column vector is an m × 1 matrix, i.e. a matrix consisting of a single column of elements.

 of the variables that affect [yi.sup.*] and [epsilon]i is normally distributed with 0 mean. The observable binary variable is depicted as [yi.sup.*] in a following sense.

Y = 1 if [yi.sup.*] > 0 (if a person is unemployed)

= 0 otherwise

Given the normality assumption, the probability that [yi.sup.*] is less than or equal to Yi can be obtained from standardised normal cumulative distribution function as

[MATHEMATICAL EXPRESSION NOT REPRODUCIBLE IN ASCII ASCII or American Standard Code for Information Interchange, a set of codes used to represent letters, numbers, a few symbols, and control characters. Originally designed for teletype operations, it has found wide application in computers. ]

[MATHEMATICAL EXPRESSION NOT REPRODUCIBLE IN ASCII]

Where f(z) represents the density function, Z is the standard normal variable with 0 mean and unit variance and its value is

Z= Xi - [mu]/[sigma]

[P.sub.i] is the probability of person being unemployed.

4. ESTIMATION, RESULTS, AND INTERPRETATION

To estimate the various categories of variables, we have used the probit model In statistics, a probit model is a popular specification of a generalized linear model, using the probit link function. Probit models were introduced by Chester Ittner Bliss in 1935.  to deal with the dummy variables. For interpretation of the results marginal effects for each variable have been calculated to see how the assignment of an additional unit from each variable consequent upon unemployment for three different profiles personal, demographic and educational. The results estimated are given in Table 2. The results shown in the Table 2 depicts the marginal effects of each of the independent variable associated with casting its impact on unemployment. Within demographic boundaries the results show that if an additional individual is from Punjab this will have an impact of decreasing the probability of being unemployed by 1.07 percent, if additional individual is from NWFP NWFP North-West Frontier Province (northwest Pakistan)
NWFP Northwest Forest Plan
NWFP Non-Wood Forest Product
 this will likely to increase the unemployment by 4.7 percent and if he belongs to Sindh, this will caste a slight incremental effect on the likely outcome of unemployment by a factor of 0.1 percent. Thus the data suggests that there is well provided evidence of difference in unemployment between Balochistan (taken as base) and NWFP. The unemployment status of Sindh and Balochistan is more or less the same or there is only a scant difference. The results are highly significant for NWFP and insignificant for Punjab and Sindh. The intuition behind this trend implies that unemployment is accounted more, or it holds more weight age for NWFP in the sample. Thus if the individual is selected from NWFP a province suffering from high unemployment he will be more probable of being unemployed than any one selected from the rest of provinces.

Despite of the fact that the NWFP accounts for a small proportion in the data but this could not have taken away the culpability culpability (See: culpable)  on government in its negligence towards this province. NWFP, on basis of low educational opportunities and flaws in the system of allocation of resources allocation of resources

Apportionment of productive assets among different uses. The issue of resource allocation arises as societies seek to balance limited resources (capital, labour, land) against the various and often unlimited wants of their members.
 is subject to serious backwardness. For reaping potentially maximum output, the labour force within this province has been in wretched state which is still observable even today. This wretched state can also be attributed to the lack of investment in human capital which could have led this work force to cope up the new emerging technological advancement and update them. The fact that a lot of illegal businesses are carried out in NWFP, and insufficiency INSUFFICIENCY. What is not competent; not enough.  in provision of actual figures might have caused the figures to overstate unemployment and understate un·der·state  
v. un·der·stat·ed, un·der·stat·ing, un·der·states

v.tr.
1. To state with less completeness or truth than seems warranted by the facts.

2.
 employment. On the other hand job creation, work opportunities, training and educational standards, multiple investment schemes are far better and mobile in Sindh and Punjab that is why their capacity to accommodate more of workforce is evident from the data.

If urban areas are to be compared at the margin of rural areas, it is clear that an additional individual or household worker from urban areas is responsible for increasing the probability of unemployment by 1.3 percent. There is considerable difference between the employment status of rural and urban areas. Unemployment is high in urban areas as compared to rural areas as the highly significant result implies. The high unemployment in urban areas as compared to rural areas is due to the structural mismatch of skills provided and demanded. The point to ponder over these findings is that the urban areas are usually thought to hold high employment levels than rural areas but Table 2 delivers opposite result for the economy of Pakistan. The reason could be that Pakistan is an agricultural country and almost 70 percent of its population lives in rural areas and due to disguised unemployment most of the people seem to be actively participating in economic activities but actually not. In short because of overwhelming dependence of Pakistan on agriculture (specific to rural areas) and presence of disguised unemployment might have caused the figures to overstate the rural employment and understate unemployment. Furthermore the situation would have been caused because of excessive trend of urbanisation; the rate at which the labour force is moving towards urban areas must have contributed to the high unemployment levels of urban areas. This is because even big cities in Pakistan Largest Cities
''' Karachi
Karachi is the largest city in Pakistan with its population being the second largest in the world after Mumbai.The city is called "The City of Lights" for its beautiful lights display at night.
 are not efficient enough institutionally to facilitate the increasing number of upcoming labours from villages, furthermore the qualifications ranked by the employers of industries and manufacturers are not properly met by the village workforce. As rural employed people are more concentrated in small firms and small scale industries, the opportunity for young to undergo training and to enhance their skill is limited that is why these young people with low qualification cannot be absorbed in big industries in cities.

Considering the personal information, the results regarding age are also significant. For every additional increase in age responsibly reduces the probability of becoming unemployed by 0.2 percent, this also accompanies the theoretical intuition that the unemployment in adult ages is less as compared to young age group which has been substantiated and proven on solid grounds by many studies conducted all over the world. The results of the data are in harmony with the fact that youth unemployment is more severe as the significant results of the age variable suggest because the age limit taken for this research merely focuses the youth. Its causes are manifold lack of skills owed by the young labour class as they newly enter the market, incompetent youth because of absence of those institution which could offer proper counselling and training to make them compatible, lack of experience which at least in Pakistan surpasses every thing, reluctance of the employers to appoint young people on jobs because of their unawareness about the potentials of youth(initially), disregard of merit based selection, hiring of young cohorts on contract basis from where they can easily be fired as compared to the old workers (low opportunity cost faced by the firms for firing the young workers).

The state of significance is not very much different in relevance of sex, if an additional worker is male, the probability of being unemployed is found at a decline by a factor of 4.8 percent, not surprisingly more males are employed than females owing to owing to
prep.
Because of; on account of: I couldn't attend, owing to illness.

owing to prepdebido a, por causa de 
 their high labour force participation ratio and large share in the labour force statistics. Thus unemployment is less for males. Discrimination among sex is a dilemma which is generally practiced all over the world and manifold theories of labour force participation have fortified the truth of this reality. In conventional economies of Asia, females are restrained only to their typical household cores and tasks and the work they perform in the villages despite of being reflecting the image of employment is not taken into account and is seemed oblivious without any acknowledgment. Scrutinising the marital status marital status,
n the legal standing of a person in regard to his or her marriage state.
 implies that if an additional household is single, probability of unemployment increases by a factor of 4.2 percent. Thus unemployment among non married is considerably higher than among married because married people have more liabilities to meet and to cope up well with these liabilities they engage in more working activities. The reason for this trend might be the usual practice in the society which declares the choice of occupation and being an earning hand the first priority for a contended married life and as an obligation before a person is married. Employment for the married households is a constraint which they necessarily have to fulfil for leading a better standard of living. The inclusion of this variable of marital status is a provoking element for understanding the causes of unemployment in a sense that before marriage a sense of no compromise upon wages prevails among the young people. As they finally get into the bond of marriage they have to overlook their previous wage standards and sometimes revise it by accepting the even low paying jobs for the sake of meeting their liabilities.

Within educational profile the educational levels show a transitional increase in unemployment as compared to no formal education. If an additional individual gets primary education the probability of becoming unemployed is increased by 2.3 percent, for an additional individual passing out as matriculate ma·tric·u·late  
tr. & intr.v. ma·tric·u·lat·ed, ma·tric·u·lat·ing, ma·tric·u·lates
To admit or be admitted into a group, especially a college or university.

n.
, this probability is increased by 9.4 percent, similarly for an additional college pass out, the percentage is 18.3 percent and for tendency of an additional individual to become highly educated causes this probability to rise by 20.1 percent. For every additional level of education the difference in unemployment of non-formally educated individuals and individuals educated at different incremental levels is increasing, which suggests that individuals having no formal education accepts the jobs offering below subsistence level subsistence level nnivel m de subsistencia

subsistence level nniveau m de vie minimum

subsistence level subsistence
 wages. As soon as an individual is getting indulged in more and more years of education his opportunity cost rises and his willingness to compromise with low wages diminishes. These results of high unemployment among educated and low among those with no formal education is not worth stupor stupor /stu·por/ (stoo´per) [L.]
1. a lowered level of consciousness.

2. in psychiatry, a disorder marked by reduced responsiveness.stu´porous


stu·por
n.
 for the economies of Pakistan where people start participating in labour oriented tasks abortively a·bor·tive  
adj.
1. Failing to accomplish an intended objective; fruitless: an abortive attempt to conclude the negotiations.

2.
 even before admitted in schools. This provides an evidence for the authenticity of manifold theories which posit unemployment a dilemma for the educated people or which proves unemployment to be more common in educated individuals. For training (technical/vocational) the results are significant, revealing if an additional individual holds training skills it will decrease the probable chances of becoming unemployed by 1.8 percent. Surely job givers or the employers, while giving jobs account skills quite highly. The lack of training facilities and institutions providing them do serve as an obstacle for the attainment of high employment levels and certainly a provoking factor for high unemployment among young cohorts. The results regarding migration, household size were found insignificant upon estimation.

5. CONCLUSION

If the results are to be dissected, even a synopsis depicts that most of the finding are totally in compliance with the idea based on former studies for different countries (Phenomenon of unemployment). Subject to formulated model various independent variables gave strong significant results for their impact on youth unemployment. As anticipated age was negatively related with unemployment. The regional aspect expounded that NWFP was inflamed with high unemployment. This haphazard scenario of NWFP is attributed to extreme failure on the part of administrative management which has been retaining the policy measures to combat this adverse situation into oblivion neglect throughout the history. The inverse relation In mathematics, the inverse relation of a binary relation is the relation taken 'backwards', as in changing the relation 'child of' to 'parent of'. In formal terms, if

 of youth unemployment with training (technical\vocational) incites us to think over one provoking factor that training helps to diffuse the unemployment problem. The results also indicated that the "single" people are more unemployed than married because liabilities after marriage coerce them to condone condone v. 1) to forgive, support, and/or overlook moral or legal failures of another without protest, with the result that it appears that such breaches of moral or legal duties are acceptable.  their asking wages and accept even low paying jobs inevitably. Urban people are more unemployed than rural, which is attributable to the recent transitions in the manufacturing sectors and industries, the introduction of new technologies has brought a new consignment of machines and plants, which has reduced the demand for the manual work. The worse scenario among all is the high unemployment among the educated youth, with every level of education difference of educated unemployed from the people holding no formal education (taken as base) status increased. This testifies the existence of structural unemployment in Pakistan. Moreover the unemployment is lower for males than females, which is logically interpreted on grounds that in Pakistan in most families' males are the only breadwinners.

In nut shells youth unemployment in Pakistan is prevalent because there is improper counselling of future dimensions, there are no institutions which could guide the young students which field to adopt congenial to the requirements of the country, in foreign countries which have restricted the unemployment rate to a reasonable extent, young students are properly entertained, and are directed to those professions which are likely to open new avenues of success and prosperity for them in the upcoming future. This feature is seriously lacking in Pakistan. This structural unemployment is also the reason of high urban unemployment in Pakistan. Faulty administrative structure is no exception to this; it is also culpable because despite of encountering the proper figures of different provinces, emphasised policies are lagging far behind the actual levels which are desired to confiscate To expropriate private property for public use without compensating the owner under the authority of the Police Power of the government. To seize property.

When property is confiscated it is transferred from private to public use, usually for reasons such as
 the spread of vicious cycles in the backward areas like NWFP. Pakistan seriously lack those institutions which could provide compatible training skills, this is perhaps the most neglected sector of economy. Unemployment is an ordeal for our youth; Okun's law suggested that a 2 percent decrease in GDP GDP (guanosine diphosphate): see guanine.  is responsible for a 1 percent increase in unemployment. If our economy is tested under his criterion, certainly Pakistan's GDP remained subject to sporadic fluctuation all throughout the history, which reasons that resources in our country are not utilised properly and economy has never been in state of full employment.

In Pakistan a diminutive portion of the total population has excessive resources to lead a luxurious life, the rest are subjugated badly as their income are depressed because either they lack the opportunity to be employed or if at all they get it, it is far below the subsistence level, among these victims a large proportion comprised of passionate youth who steps in the market with the devotion to thrive and ends up mostly in despair and devoid potentials. Thus low incomes and below subsistence wages are responsible for the perpetuation of the vicious circle vi·cious circle
n.
A condition in which a disorder or disease gives rise to another that subsequently affects the first.
 of unemployment in Pakistan. The inflexible wage structure in Pakistan, minimum wage laws, poor monitoring of demand and supply of labour force all are contributing in aggravating ag·gra·vate  
tr.v. ag·gra·vat·ed, ag·gra·vat·ing, ag·gra·vates
1. To make worse or more troublesome.

2. To rouse to exasperation or anger; provoke. See Synonyms at annoy.
 the situation.

6. POLICY RECOMMENDATIONS

To safeguard and confiscate youth unemployment from soaring, it is necessary to take immediate corrective measures so that economy of Pakistan could withstand this reprehensible rep·re·hen·si·ble  
adj.
Deserving rebuke or censure; blameworthy. See Synonyms at blameworthy.



[Middle English, from Old French, from Late Latin repreh
 curse.

* Special focus should be placed on the issue of making students aware of the scope of education they acquire prior to the stage where they make themselves fully engaged towards their desired field of study.

* Special internship internship /in·tern·ship/ (in´tern-ship) the position or term of service of an intern in a hospital.
internship,
n the course work or practicum conducted in a professional dental clinic.
 programme be launched so that students could acquaint themselves with experience side by side their education, this will help to alleviate the hesitancy hes·i·tan·cy
n.
An involuntary delay or inability in starting the urinary stream.
 on the part of employers in hiring the fresh students.

* To cope up with the trend of urbanisation, more and more industries be established in urban areas which can accommodate the increasing number of labour force.

* As it is obvious that large proportion of labours holding skills are more likely to get job, training facilities should be made accessible within the reach of a common man also by making the establishment of training institutes a necessary part of development programmes.

* Small scales industries should be established so that those labours who remain unemployed despite of owing skills in hand made items and handicrafts can play their active role in society as an employed member.

* Corrective measures must be taken by the government to achieve a smooth flow of productivity and growth persistently. Balance should be maintained in focusing on the objectives and performance of various sectors. No sector should be made to thrive at the cost of other. Moreover an attempt should be made to uplift all the sectors simultaneously.

* An increment in GDP be made in line with those standards which directly results in increasing the investment prospects and productivity. This aspect is particularly important because some factors sometimes over express GDP (such as excessive foreign remittances); such type of increase in GDP is not necessarily accompanied by productivity and employment opportunities.

Comments

The main aim of this research is to scrutinise all those elements which cause unemployment, with special focus on Youth Unemployment. This is very important issue for a country like Pakistan--a labour abundant country. The author choice of this vital subject is therefore commendable. However, I have few points which may help to understand the issue more clearly and make the study more invaluable.

(a) It is not clear to me from the paper that which definition of female labour force participation is used in the paper. Labour force survey provides two types of data for female participation.

(b) The study states that unemployment is high due to mal functioning of education and training system. At another page it states that unemployment increase by education level. This need to be analyse in more detail with mismatch analysis.

(c) It will be very informative if youth unemployment by education level will be calculated on the basis of demand and supply. Demand can be projected using sectoral growth and employment. Labour force survey provides information on employment by occupation and by industry also.

(d) Author points out that employment among age group of 50-59 have increased and voluntary unemployment has increased among youth. It can be concluded from this that voluntary unemployment among youth has forced older persons to work more.

(e) The study states that rural unemployment is lower than urban unemployment that may be due to under employment in rural areas--In majority of households all member of a family engaged in agriculture activities.

(f) The results show that singles are most likely to be unemployed. But I think this result may differ by gender as employers are most likely to higher single women.

(g) Wage have not been included in the analysis, therefore it cannot be concluded from the paper that wages are responsible for unemployment.

(h) The author concludes with a cyclical trend which has not been analysed in the paper. The author can delete the statements about it from the paper.

Rizwana Siddiqui

Pakistan Institute of Development Economics Pakistan Institute of Development Economics (PIDE) is a think tank in Islamabad, Pakistan.

Pakistan Institute of Development Economics was established at Karachi in 1957 and in 1964 accorded the status of an autonomous research organisation by the Government of Pakistan.
, Islamabad.

REFERENCES

Andrew, M. and S. Nickell (1982) Unemployment in the United Kingdom since the War. Review of Economic Studies 49, 731-759.

Blanch blanch

to become pale.
 Flower, D. G. and R. B. Freemen (1996) Growing in Work. OECD OECD: see Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development.  Employment Outlook, July.

Blomqvist, A. G. (1985) Unemployment of the Educated and Emigration emigration: see immigration; migration.  of Post-secondary Graduates from the LDCs. The Pakistan Development Review 28:3&4, 643-654.

Cartmel and Furlong (2000) Youth Unemployment in Rural Areas. University of Glasgow The University of Glasgow (Scottish Gaelic: Oilthigh Ghlaschu, Latin: Universitas Glasguensis) was founded in 1451, in Glasgow, Scotland. . www.jrf.org.uk/knowledge/findings

Chaudry, M. A. and A. Hamid (1998) Unemployment in Pakistan. Pakistan Economic and Social Review 36: 2, 147-170.

Ghayur, S. (1989) Educated Unemployed in Pakistan: Estimates of Imbalances in Current Flows. The Pakistan Development Review 28:4, 603-613.

Haque, I. (1994) The Significant Variables of Full Employment and their Explanatory Values. The Pakistan Development Review 33:4, 1345-1356.

Higgin, N. O. (1997) The Challenge of Youth Unemployment. (Employment Working Papers working papers
pl.n.
Legal documents certifying the right to employment of a minor or alien.

Noun 1. working papers
.) www.ilo.org Jacobson, T. and H. Ohlsson (2000) Working Time, Employment and Work Sharing:

Evidence from Sweden. Empirical Economics 25, 169-187. Khan, I. A. (2003) Impact of Privatisation Noun 1. privatisation - changing something from state to private ownership or control
denationalisation, denationalization, privatization

social control - control exerted (actively or passively) by group action
 on Employment and Output in Pakistan. The Pakistan Development Review 42: 4, 513-536.

Khan, S. R. and S. Z. Ali (1989) Some Findings about the Unemployed Highly Educated Persons in Pakistan. The Pakistan Development Review 25:4, 731-737.

Lynch, L. M. (1983) Job Search and Youth Unemployment. Oxford Economic Papers 35, 271-282.

Malik, M. A. A. (2004) A Country Report for Symposium on Globalisation and Future of Youth in Asia. Ministry of Labour, Manpower and Overseas Pakistanis. www.ilo.org/pub

Malinvaud, E. (1989) Lessons to be Learned from European Unemployment

of 80s. The Pakistan Development Review 28: 4, 311-333.

Robinson, W. C. and N. Abbasi (1979) Unemployment in Pakistan. The Pakistan Development Review 28: 4, 313-331.

Shezad, M. (2003) The Challenge of Unemployment. India's National Magazine 21:4.

Waqqas Qayyum <wiqi33-flourish@yahoo.com> is a PhD student at the Federal Urdu University The Federal Urdu University of Arts, Sciences & Technology is a coeducational public university located in Gulshan Town, Karachi, Sindh, Pakistan.

Federal Urdu University was established on 12 November, 2002 by presidential order, the university is the first university in
 of Arts, Science, and Technology, lslamabad.
Table 1
Unemployment Rates Sex and Age (%)

                 2003-04                   2005-06
Age
Groups    Total    Male    Female   Total    Male    Female

15-19      13.2    12.8     14.9     9.98   10.02     9.82
20-24      10.3     9.3     15.0     7.37    6.87     9.43
25-29       7.1     6.1     12.5     4.88    4.30     7.34
30-34       4.5     3.8      7.4     2.85    2.45     4.33
35-39       2.9     2.0      7.2     2.37    1.67     4.87
40-44       2.9     2.5      4.8     2.68    2.00     5.45
45-49       3.5     2.3      9.5     2.87    2.08     6.04
50-54       5.1     3.5     12.2     6.32    4.52    14.48
55-59       7.1     4.5     20.7     8.35    5.89    19.50
60 and
  Above    12.8     8.9     36.1    11.62    7.18    34.12

Source: Labour Forty Survey 2003-04 and 2005-06.

Table 2

Variable                Coefficient    dy/dx      Z

Personal Profile
  Age                       -0.0231   -0.0027   -4.49
  Male *                    -0.3394   -0.0480   -7.64
  Single *                   0.3973    0.0422    8.58

Demographic Profile
  Punjab *                  -0.0908   -0.0107   -1.41
  NWFP *                     0.3380    0.0473    4.99
  Sindh *                    0.0111    0.0013    0.16
  Urban *                    0.1159    0.0138    3.36
  Hsize                     -0.0030   -0.0003   -0.70
  Mig *                      0.0607    0.0074    1.11

Educational Profile
  Prim *                     0.1825    0.0232    3.48
  Matric *                   0.6526    0.0946   14.37
  College *                  0.9282    0.1836   16.26
  Higher *                   0.9275    0.2013    7.61
  Training                  -0.1585   -0.0187   -2.12
  Cons                      -1.1219             -5.30

Probit Estimates               Number of Obs = 14515
LR [Chi.sup.2] (14) = 842.06   Pseudo [R.sup.2] = 0.1047
Log Likelihood = -3600.3463

(*) dy/dx is for discrete change of dummy
variable from 0 to l.

Marginal effects after Probit

y = Pr(unempl) (predict) = .05907343
COPYRIGHT 2007 Reproduced with permission of the Publications Division, Pakistan Institute of Development Economies, Islamabad, Pakistan.
No portion of this article can be reproduced without the express written permission from the copyright holder.
Copyright 2007 Gale, Cengage Learning. All rights reserved.

 Reader Opinion

Title:

Comment:



 

Article Details
Printer friendly Cite/link Email Feedback
Title Annotation:GROWTH EMPLOYMENT / POVERTY ISSUES
Author:Qayyum, Waqqas
Publication:Pakistan Development Review
Article Type:Report
Geographic Code:9PAKI
Date:Dec 22, 2007
Words:5207
Previous Article:An analysis of Pakistan's vulnerability to economic crisis.
Next Article:Understanding poverty through the eyes of low-salaried government employees: a case study of the NED University of Engineering and Technology.
Topics:

Terms of use | Copyright © 2014 Farlex, Inc. | Feedback | For webmasters