Cardium wins patent dispute with Boston Scientific and Arch Development Corporation,.Cardium Therapeutics, Inc. (San Diego, CA) announced winning patent decisions over Arch Development Corporation (Chicago, IL) and Arch's licensee, Boston Scientific Corporation, in proceedings conducted in the United States and in Europe. Cardium also distinguished its approach to the treatment of coronary heart disease coronary heart disease: see coronary artery disease. coronary heart disease or ischemic heart disease Progressive reduction of blood supply to the heart muscle due to narrowing or blocking of a coronary artery (see atherosclerosis). from competitive techniques such as those being utilized by Corautus Genetics, which has a collaboration agreement with Boston Scientific. Cardium Therapeutics is the exclusive licensee of a number of patents and patent applications of Dr. H. Kirk Hammond and colleagues at the University of California The University of California has a combined student body of more than 191,000 students, over 1,340,000 living alumni, and a combined systemwide and campus endowment of just over $7.3 billion (8th largest in the United States). (UC), which are generally directed to the intracoronary administration of adenovectors comprising angiogenic angiogenic /an·gio·gen·ic/ (-jen´ik) 1. pertaining to angiogenesis. 2. of vascular origin. angiogenic adjective Relating to angiogenesis genes for the treatment of coronary heart disease and related conditions such as myocardial ischemia and angina. Angina, which is frequently experienced as chest pain, can severely limit patients' daily activities and is a disorder that affects millions of adults in the United States, Europe and elsewhere. In the United States and in Europe, Arch Development Corporation (an affiliate of the University of Chicago) and its licensee Boston Scientific pursued patent claims similar to those licensed to Cardium based on a patent application of Dr. Jeffrey Leiden et al. Following reviews by examiners and administrative patent judges, the claims being pursued by Arch and Boston Scientific have been declared unpatentable in Europe, and also unpatentable in the United States. "These key decisions represent important tests and confirmations of the strength of our intellectual property position, and the value of our methods for treating coronary heart disease, which we plan to advance to late-stage human clinical trials," said Dr. Tyler M. Dylan, Chief Business Officer and General Counsel of Cardium Therapeutics. "We believe that our approach to treating angina by infusing angiogenic adenovectors to trigger the growth of new blood vessels in the heart represents a best-in-class technique -- and while we appreciate and respect other companies' interests in attempting to secure competing patent claims, we intend to continue to defend and to strengthen our IP portfolio for delivering angiogenic DNA sequences to the heart." Boston Scientific's collaborator for angiogenic gene therapy angiogenic gene therapy Cardiology An investigational therapy that delivers a growth factor gene to diseased coronary arteries evoking growth factor production and stimulating angiogenesis and formation of blood vessels that bypass occluded coronary arteries , Corautus Genetics, has been following an alternate approach for delivering genes to the heart using a "naked" plasmid DNA vector in which the plasmid is mechanically injected from inside the heart chamber(s) outward into the surrounding muscle using multiple injections. The Corautus approach has relied upon a needle-deploying device referred to as a Stiletto "endocardial endocardial /en·do·car·di·al/ (-kahr´de-al) 1. situated or occurring within the heart. 2. pertaining to the endocardium. endocardial 1. situated or occurring within the heart. 2. direct injection system," which is supplied by Boston Scientific, and an angiogenic gene (VEGF-2), which was licensed to Corautus by Human Genome Sciences Human Genome Sciences NASDAQ: HGSI is a biopharmaceutical corporation founded in 1992. Its stated purpose is to "discover, develop, manufacture and market innovative drugs that serve patients with unmet medical needs, with a primary focus on protein and antibody drugs. , Inc. Corautus recently reported that its corresponding GENASIS GENASIS Generalized Avionics Simulation/Integration System Phase IIb clinical trial appeared to be powered sufficiently to demonstrate statistical significance on its primary endpoint. However, on March 14, 2006, Corautus announced that Boston Scientific had requested a voluntary suspension of the trial as a result of several serious adverse events ("SAEs") of pericardial effusion (excess fluid in the pericardial sac), which did not appear to be related to the angiogenic gene (VEGF-2). Following the voluntary suspension, Corautus reported on March 20th that the FDA FDA abbr. Food and Drug Administration FDA, n.pr See Food and Drug Administration. FDA, n.pr the abbreviation for the Food and Drug Administration. had placed the GENASIS trial on clinical hold. Cardium's approach to the treatment of heart disease (which is claimed in the above-referenced UC patents and patent applications) uses a standard cardiac catheter to gradually infuse an angiogenic adenovector into the coronary circulation. The intracoronary route of delivery is not only readily accessible from outside of the heart but it directly supplies the underlying heart muscle as well as the coronary endothelium endothelium /en·do·the·li·um/ (-the´le-um) pl. endothe´lia the layer of epithelial cells that lines the cavities of the heart, the serous cavities, and the lumina of the blood and lymph vessels. , to which adenovectors can bind and from which blood vessels grow in the process of angiogenesis angiogenesis /an·gio·gen·e·sis/ (-jen´e-sis) vasculogenesis; development of blood vessels either in the embryo or in the form of neovascularization or revascularization. an·gi·o·gen·e·sis n. . Cardiac infusion catheters and the intracoronary delivery route are also beneficial because they are routinely used by cardiologists for performing standard diagnostic procedures such as angiography angiography or arteriography X-ray examination of arteries and veins with a contrast medium to differentiate them from surrounding organs. The contrast medium is introduced through a catheter to show the blood vessels and the structures they supply, including . Adenovectors are the most widely-studied DNA DNA: see nucleic acid. DNA or deoxyribonucleic acid One of two types of nucleic acid (the other is RNA); a complex organic compound found in all living cells and many viruses. It is the chemical substance of genes. delivery vehicles in human clinical trials; and, in the context of heart disease, angiogenic adenovectors are believed to be particularly useful as biologics in that they do not integrate into the human genome but can bind to and remain in the heart for a sufficient period of time to promote the development of new blood vessels. Adenovectors are also considered to be significantly more efficient than naked plasmid DNA for gene transfer; and naturally-occurring biological receptors for adenovectors are believed to facilitate its binding to a broad area of heart muscle supplied by the infused coronary circulation. Employing this readily-accessible coronary delivery route to the myocardium myocardium /myo·car·di·um/ (-kahr´de-um) the middle and thickest layer of the heart wall, composed of cardiac muscle. hibernating myocardium see myocardial hibernation, under avoids the need for any mechanical devices or approaches that require entry into the heart chambers or piercing of the surrounding heart muscle, or that result in delivery and gene expression concentrated along needle tracks in the injected myocardium. Cardium's licensed patent claims are applicable to multiple angiogenic DNAs including VEGFs, FGFs and other DNA sequences capable of promoting angiogenesis. Of these, the FGF-4 angiogenic DNA employed in Cardium's Generx product candidate (which is separately licensed to Cardium by New York University New York University, mainly in New York City; coeducational; chartered 1831, opened 1832 as the Univ. of the City of New York, renamed 1896. It comprises 13 schools and colleges, maintaining 4 main centers (including the Medical Center) in the city, as well as the ), was selected as being advantageous for promoting blood vessel growth in the heart. In particular, FGFs are believed to activate a number of downstream angiogenic factors, including VEGFs and related proteins that can contribute to the process of forming stable blood vessel growth in ischemic Ischemic An inadequate supply of blood to a part of the body, caused by partial or total blockage of an artery. Mentioned in: Antiangiogenic Therapy, Subarachnoid Hemorrhage, Ventricular Fibrillation ischemic areas of need such as oxygen-deprived tissue downstream of narrow or blocked coronary arteries and/or smaller blood vessels located within the heart muscle. While angioplasty and stenting as well as coronary artery bypass graft coronary artery bypass graft n. Abbr. CABG A surgical procedure in which a section of vein or other conduit is grafted between the aorta and a coronary artery below the region of an obstruction in that artery. (CABG CABG coronary artery bypass graft. CABG abbr. coronary artery bypass graft CABG Coronary artery bypass graft, see there ) surgeries can be performed for mechanically opening or surgically bypassing blockages of the large epicardial epicardial pertaining to the visceral pericardium (epicardium) or to the epicardia. epicardial receptors receptors in the left ventricle adapted to respond to stretch and chemical stimulants. blood vessels that surround the myocardium, neither angioplasty nor CABG are believed to be capable of also addressing blockages or limitations affecting the mid-sized to smaller blood vessels which are located deeper within the heart muscle. These deeper blood vessels, which form the underlying coronary "microcirculation microcirculation /mi·cro·cir·cu·la·tion/ (-sir?ku-la´shun) the flow of blood through the fine vessels (arterioles, capillaries, and venules).microcirculato´ry mi·cro·cir·cu·la·tion n. ," are directly responsible for conveying oxygenated blood into close proximity with the adjacent heart tissue. In addition, microcirculatory impedance or resistance to flow at the downstream level is believed to contribute substantially to reducing overall blood flow through the myocardium -- which may be a contributory cause of ischemia in patients with heart disease. In that regard, many patients continue to experience angina even after surgical and other interventions have been performed to mechanically open or bypass accessible portions of the large upstream blood vessels that initially conduct blood flow into the heart. Cardium's therapeutic approach to the treatment of heart disease has been the focus of the most widely-conducted clinical studies for Angiogenic Gene Therapy (AGENT 1 through AGENT 4), which to date have involved 663 patients and more than one hundred United States, European and other medical centers. Results from meta-analyses of the AGENT 3 and AGENT 4 studies, as well as results from the AGENT 2 mechanism-of-action study (demonstrating positive enhancement of myocardial myocardial /myo·car·di·al/ (-kahr´de-al) pertaining to the muscular tissue of the heart. myocardial pertaining to the muscular tissue of the heart (the myocardium). perfusion (blood flow to the heart muscle in patients with ischemia) as measured by single-photon emission computed tomography (SPECT SPECT single-photon emission computed tomography. SPECT abbr. single photon emission computed tomography SPECT, n See single photon emission computer tomography. ) imaging), are expected to be discussed with the FDA in preparation for the planned initiation of an AGENT 5 clinical study of Generx and to be reviewed at one or more upcoming scientific symposia. In Europe, Arch Development and its licensee Boston Scientific Corporation have pursued patent claims based on a patent application of Dr. Jeffrey Leiden et al., which was published as WO 94/11506. Cardium and Collateral Therapeutics, its predecessor-in-interest in the technologies, opposed the European grant of the Leiden patent , which led to a decision by the European Patent Office (EPO EPO see erythropoietin. EPO Erythropoietin, see there Opposition Division) to reverse the grant. Arch Development and Boston Scientific then appealed from the decision against them. Following a review by the Technical Board of Appeal of the EPO, their appeal has now been dismissed and their corresponding patent grant has been revoked in Europe. In the United States, Arch Development and Boston Scientific used related patent applications by Leiden et al. that were not yet issued to "copy" claims from three United States patents granted to the University of California, which are exclusively licensed to Cardium. An interference proceeding to determine priority of inventorship was then initiated by the United States Patent and Trademark Office The United States Patent and Trademark Office (PTO or USPTO) is an agency in the United States Department of Commerce that provides patent protection to inventors and businesses for their inventions, and trademark registration for product and intellectual property . Following submissions of evidence from both sides and a review conducted by the United States Board of Patent Appeals and Interferences The Board of Patent Appeals and Interferences (BPAI) is a body of the United States Patent and Trademark Office (USPTO), which decides issues of patentability. If an applicant for an invention cannot convince a patent examiner that they are entitled to their claims, then the (BPAI BPAI Board of Patent Appeals and Interferences ), a panel of Administrative Patent Judges reached a decision on preliminary motions ordering that the Leiden applicants be denied the benefit of their priority applications, that the interference be re-declared to reflect Hammond's status as the "senior" or earlier party, and that Hammond be granted a motion that the Leiden claims are unpatentable over the prior art, including the Hammond applications. The BPAI then issued an Order to Show Cause, directing the Leiden applicants to demonstrate how they could prevail on the issue of priority of invention over Hammond. Following Leiden's response, the BPAI entered a final judgment against the Leiden applicants ordering that the interference count (representing the claims in dispute) be awarded to Hammond, and that Leiden et al. be held not entitled to any patent containing claims corresponding to those in the interference. Arch Development and Boston Scientific have appealed from the decision against them in the United States as they had previously done in Europe. Additional information and case files regarding the European Opposition Proceedings are currently available from the Boards of Appeal of the European Patent Office with reference to Arch Development Corporation patent file 0 668 913. Additional information and case files regarding the United States interference proceedings are currently available from the United States Patent and Trademark Office with reference to patent files 5,792,453, 6,100,242 or 6,174,871, which are assigned to the Regents of the University of California The Regents of the University of California make up the governing board of the University of California. The Board has 26 full (i.e., voting) members:
Cardium is a medical technology company primarily focused on the development, manufacture and sale of innovative therapeutic products for the interventional cardiology market. In October 2005, Cardium acquired a portfolio of cardiovascular growth factor therapeutics from the Schering AG Group, Germany, including the later-stage product candidate, Generx, and completed a US$30 million financing. Generx (alferminogene tadenovec) is a DNA-based growth factor therapeutic being developed for potential use by interventional cardiologists as a one-time treatment to promote and stimulate the growth of collateral circulation in the heart of patients with angina pectoris. As announced in March 2006, Cardium has also acquired InnerCool Therapies, Inc. (San Diego, CA) a medical technology company in the emerging field of therapeutic hypothermia hypothermia Abnormally low body temperature, with slowing of physiological activity. It is artificially induced (usually with ice baths) for certain surgical procedures and cancer treatments. , which is designed to rapidly and controllably cool the body in order to reduce cell death and damage following acute ischemic events such as cardiac arrest or stroke, and to potentially lessen or prevent associated injuries such as adverse neurologic outcomes. InnerCool Therapies, Inc. www.innercool.com Cardium Therapeutics, Inc. +1-858-436-1018 www.cardiumthx.com |
|
||||||||||||||

Printer friendly
Cite/link
Email
Feedback
Reader Opinion