CalSTRS Rejects Icahn Offer for Lear Corporation.SACRAMENTO Sacramento, city, United States Sacramento (săkrəmĕn`tō), city (1990 pop. 369,365), state capital and seat of Sacramento co., central Calif. , Calif. -- The California California (kăl'ĭfôr`nyə), most populous state in the United States, located in the Far West; bordered by Oregon (N), Nevada and, across the Colorado River, Arizona (E), Mexico (S), and the Pacific Ocean (W). State Teachers' Retirement System has decided to vote its 1.4 million shares of common stock in the Lear Corporation against the merger with the Carl Icahn Carl Celian Icahn (born February 16, 1936) is an American billionaire financier, corporate raider, and private equity investor. Carl Icahn Net worth is $14.5 Billion as of 2007 Forbes estimate. unit, American Real Estate Partners American Real Estate Partners, L.P. (AREP) (NYSE: ACP) is a diversified real estate holding company based in White Plains, New York. History The Sands in Atlantic City and some adjacent property, was sold in November of 2006 for $274. (AREP AREP Aircraft Repair Enhancement Program AREP Affiliated retail electric provider AREP Address Reply AREP Atmospheric Research and Environment Program AREP Army Reserve Expeditionary Package AREP Averaged Relativistic Effective Potential ). CalSTRS believes that the offer price is too low, by almost half, and that the long-term Long-term Three or more years. In the context of accounting, more than 1 year. long-term 1. Of or relating to a gain or loss in the value of a security that has been held over a specific length of time. Compare short-term. value of Lear will be realized more successfully if the current merger is not consummated con·sum·mate tr.v. con·sum·mat·ed, con·sum·mat·ing, con·sum·mates 1. a. To bring to completion or fruition; conclude: consummate a business transaction. b. . CalSTRS wrote a letter to the corporation's Chairman and Chief Executive Officer detailing its concerns with the merger and informing the company that CalSTRS is pursuing the filing of its Appraisal Rights Appraisal rights A right of shareholders in a merger to demand the payment of a fair price for their shares, as determined independently. under Delaware Delaware, state, United States Delaware (dĕl`əwâr, –wər), one of the Middle Atlantic states of the United States, the country's second smallest state (after Rhode Island). Law. "This merger makes no economic sense for the shareholders of Lear Corporation and the stunningly inadequate price causes us to wonder about the board's representation of shareholders in this transaction," said Christopher J. Ailman, CalSTRS Chief Investment Officer. "CalSTRS owns almost two percent of the outstanding shares of Lear and is a long-term holder of the stock; we do not want to see the long-term value accrue To increase; to augment; to come to by way of increase; to be added as an increase, profit, or damage. Acquired; falling due; made or executed; matured; occurred; received; vested; was created; was incurred. to favored share owners like Carl Icahn at the expense of the other 85 percent of shareholders. Although we are mindful mind·ful adj. Attentive; heedful: always mindful of family responsibilities. See Synonyms at careful. mind of the $100 million termination fee termination fee The one-time charge for terminating or transferring an individual retirement account. If a financial institution charges a termination fee, the fee must be spelled out in the original agreement that is signed when the account is opened. that exists in this deal, we believe that this merger should be terminated and that the company should be shopped in a transparent and arms-length manner. CalSTRS supports Delaware Chancery chancery: see equity. chancery Court of public record and archive of state documents. The chancery system of the Roman Empire served as the model for the royal chanceries of medieval France and Germany. Judge Strine's decision to require Lear to disclose more information on this deal to its investors before that meeting was to have taken place on June 27, 2007," Mr. Ailman concluded. With a $171.1 billion investment portfolio, the California State Teachers' Retirement System is the second-largest public pension fund in the United States United States, officially United States of America, republic (2005 est. pop. 295,734,000), 3,539,227 sq mi (9,166,598 sq km), North America. The United States is the world's third largest country in population and the fourth largest country in area. . It provides retirement, disability and survivor benefits to California's nearly 800,000 public school educators from kindergarten kindergarten [Ger.,=garden of children], system of preschool education. Friedrich Froebel designed (1837) the kindergarten to provide an educational situation less formal than that of the elementary school but one in which children's creative play instincts would be through community college. Below please find a letter from CalSTRS to the CEO (1) (Chief Executive Officer) The highest individual in command of an organization. Typically the president of the company, the CEO reports to the Chairman of the Board. of Lear Corporation. June 22, 2007 Mr. Robert E Rossiter Chairman and Chief Executive Officer Lear Corporation. 21557 Telegraph Road Southfield, MI 48033 Dear Mr. Rossiter, This letter is sent to you on behalf of the California State Teachers' Retirement System (CalSTRS). As of the record date, May 14, 2007, for the upcoming meeting scheduled for June 27, 2007, CalSTRS held 1.4 million shares of common stock in the Lear Corporation. Representatives of CalSTRS and Lear shared a conference call regarding the proposed merger between Lear and AREP on June 18, 2007. During that call, we expressed our concern that this offer did not reflect the underlying value of the company and that, in the absence of a competing offer; we would prefer that the merger not proceed. It is regrettable that shareholders may have to pay the $100 million termination or break-up fee if this transaction fails, but even with its consideration, we still believe that Lear has the capacity to earn its way out of the conditions surrounding this offer. We have also talked to some of the other large shareholders of Lear Corporation and found that they share our belief that this is not an attractive offer and that the merger should be scuttled. CalSTRS is a long-term investor in Lear Corporation and does not wish to see the long-term value accrue to other interested or favored shareholders. The $36.00 per share offer from AREP only represents a 3.8% premium for the shares' closing price on February 2, 2007. The unfairness of this offer has caused us to pursue the issue of Appraisal Rights. We understand that these large shareholders have talked with the Company several times, each time stating that Lear could command values of as much as $60.00 per share on its own and expressing their desire that the merger not proceed. From the filing of the litigation by several shareholders over the merger terms, it is clear that shareholders believe that they are being shut out of any opportunity to receive the true value for Lear. We are also dismayed by senior management's decision to keep the substantial change-in-control payments even though the executive team will be practically unchanged as a result of this merger. Finally, we do not believe that the "shopping process" was conducted fairly or thoroughly; this "go-shop" feature was hamstrung from the beginning by the signed agreement with Icahn and the large termination penalty. The speed with which the Lear board approved this transaction hardly left any time for other suitors to either emerge or entertain merging with the Company. All of these circumstances give the impression of a less than "arms-length" transaction, concocted in short hurried time periods, to the benefit of one large shareholder, Mr. Icahn at the expense of the other 85% owned by public shareholders. Additionally, the related transactions among the board members and the Company also call into question whether the board was fulfilling its fiduciary duty to the public shareholders when it was "negotiating" this deal. CalSTRS' portfolio is valued at $170 billion, as of March 30, 2007; $100 billion of our portfolio is invested in the public equity markets, on both U.S, and Non-U.S. markets. For reasons of diversification, risk, costs and other reasons, that I won't take the time to get into in this letter, a substantial portion of the CalSTRS portfolio is invested in the indexed or passive style of investment management. These securities are held for the long-term as we do not trade them on company news or events. Over the past two decades, we have experienced a great many mergers; during this same time period, we have seen that the great majority of these mergers did not live up to their promise and instead of being deals that created value for the shareholders, especially long-term shareholders like CalSTRS, these transactions were value destroyers. The automotive and automotive supplier industries have been undergoing a secular, wholesale restructuring over the past four years. We believe that this consolidation/restructuring is in its early stages and that while a substantial shakeout may take place, shareholders will be rewarded with tremendous upside from some of the companies; and, we believe that Lear is one of those companies where long-term patient capital will be rewarded. We do not believe that the $36.00 per share offer from American Real Estate Partners is adequate or even close to the true value of Lear. It is my hope that you will reconvene the "Special Committee" of the board and terminate this deal and go out into the market place in a sincere fashion that encourages other bidders. Please feel free to contact me to discuss this letter. Sincerely, Christopher J. Ailman Chief Investment Officer |
|
||||||||||||||

Printer friendly
Cite/link
Email
Feedback
Reader Opinion