Printer Friendly

CRUISE WARS; Southampton steps up its bid to block Pier Head.

Byline: DAVID BARTLETT The Honourable David John Bartlett is the Minister for Education in Tasmania. He is a Tasmanian Labor politician and member of the Tasmanian House of Assembly in the electorate of Denison. ;VICKI KELLAWAY

SOUTHAMPTON has stepped up its attempt to block Liverpool's Pier Head The Pier Head is a riverside location in the city-centre of Liverpool, England.

Landing stages
The Pier Head is the historic location of Liverpool's landing stages and a trio of landmarks, which around 2001/02 were dubbed the 'Three Graces': Royal Liver Building,
 from being allowed to become a start and finish base for cruise liners.

The Department for Transport is currently considering whether to relax rules to allow a full "turnaround" facility to be created at Liverpool's Cruise Liner Terminal.

The DfT has to give its approval because of a pounds 9m grant from the European Union that helped fund the pounds 20m terminal.

But Associated British Ports, which owns Southampton, is objecting saying that would amount to unfair help that would "distort" competition in the port sector.

The firm has now also accused Liverpool of going behind its back to seek the support of arch rival Portsmouth.

And the war of words is escalating with websites in Southampton filled with stereotypical criticism of Liverpool.

HAVE The latest protests from ABP 1. (networking) ABP - Alternating bit protocol.
2. ABP - Microsoft Address Book Provider.
 about Liverpool's bid concern emails sent from officials here to other ports including Portsmouth, but not Southampton, which it claims appeared they were in cahoots ca·hoots  
pl.n. Informal
Questionable collaboration; secret partnership: an accountant in cahoots with organized crime.
 to "get one over on Southampton".

But the ECHO understands that ABP have not been kept in the dark and actually held a meeting with officials from Liverpool in the last month to discuss the plans.

A Liverpool Council spokesman said: "Everything we have done has been done in agreement with the Department for Transport."

Southampton's economic development leader, Tory Cllr Royston Smith has also stepped into the row saying what Liverpool was requesting was "an abuse of state aid".

Southampton port director Doug Morrison Doug Morrison (born February 1, 1960 in Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada) is a professional ice hockey player who played 23 games in the National Hockey League. He played with the Boston Bruins.  said: "If you were contacting a cruise port on the south coast, would you go to Portsmouth? That shows you they are worried about competition.We are concerned that obviously Portsmouth and the likes are in cahoots with Liverpool to try and get one over on Southampton. It is not how we should be doing business.

"We have no argument with Liverpool City Council
See City of Liverpool for other meanings

Liverpool City Council is the governing body for the city of Liverpool in Merseyside, England. It consists of 90 councillors, three for each of the city's 30 wards.
. We know how important the cruise business is and how it can be used to regenerate a city. But taxpayers' money distorts the marketplace."

Critical commentators on websites in Southampton have been quick to slam Liverpool.

One wrote: "Cruise ship passengers would get fleeced in Liverpool by taxi drivers or forced to go to the Beatles Museum."

Cllr Gary Millar, Liverpool's enterprise and tourism leader, said: ''We believe that the creation of a full turn-around facility at Liverpool will benefit the cruise liner industry in the UK, as the city is uniquely positioned to attract business from outside of Europe.

"The application has been made in response to calls from the industry and passengers."

HAVE YOUR SAYContact www. /forums


COMPARE AND CONTRAST: A cruise ship at the Pier Head versus the less glamorous view at Southampton
No portion of this article can be reproduced without the express written permission from the copyright holder.
Copyright 2009 Gale, Cengage Learning. All rights reserved.

 Reader Opinion




Article Details
Printer friendly Cite/link Email Feedback
Publication:Liverpool Echo (Liverpool, England)
Date:Sep 25, 2009

Related Articles
City's cruise liner bid hit by rival's protests; Southampton blocks Pier Head upgrade: Pier Head cruise upgrade faces attack by rival port.
RIVAL PORT TRIES TO SCUPPER PIER HEAD; Southampton move over our cruise liners.
Casting envious glances towards - Southampton?!
CRUISE WARS; Southampton steps up its bid to block Pier Head.
TAX RAP FOR FIRM IN PIER HEAD CRUISE WAR; Port company 'domiciled' in Jersey.
Unfair? What a cheek.
Southampton is just afraid of the competition.
'HYPOCRISY' RAP OVER CRUISE WARS; Firm received pounds 7.6m from taxpayers.
Pay back all the terminal grant cash; Rival port boss hits back in row over city cruise berth.
CRUISE CONTROL; Liverpool's pounds 20m plan ignites UK port battle.

Terms of use | Copyright © 2014 Farlex, Inc. | Feedback | For webmasters