Printer Friendly
The Free Library
14,694,313 articles and books
Member login
User name  
Password 
 
Join us Forgot password?

By definition, if you're a landlord, you're wrong.


It seems as if i am developing a fixation. For the past few columns I have written about my recent experiences in the Housing Court. Well guess what? I am going to amaze you and write about my most recent Housing Court saga.

Once again, as an owner of and manager of real property, I have encountered out-and-out bigotry Bigotry
See also Anti-Semitism.

Beaumanoir, Sir Lucas de

prejudiced ascetic; Grand Master of Templars. [Br. Lit.: Ivanhoe]

Bunker, Archie

middle-aged bigot in television series.
 by our judiciary. But the bigotry I have and probably will continue to experience has nothing to do with my race or ancestry. Nor does it have anything to do with my age, sex or sexual orientation sexual orientation
n.
The direction of one's sexual interest toward members of the same, opposite, or both sexes, especially a direction seen to be dictated by physiologic rather than sociologic forces.
. This prejudice is quite simply because I happen to he a "Landlord." That label automatically centers upon me the worst stereotyping imaginable.

This blatant bias is not limited to only tenants, but is endemic to our court system as well. In some instances, judges and their clerks are so prejudiced that fairness is an abstract concept in their dealings with us. We are assumed to be greedy when we bring a case seeking the rent owed.

"How dare this landlord believe be should he entitled to attorney's fees attorney's fee n. the payment for legal services. It can take several forms: 1) hourly charge, 2) flat fee for the performance of a particular service (like $250 to write a will), 3) contingent fee (such as one-third of the gross recovery, and nothing if there is no ," most judges seem to be saying. apparently, even when a tenant forces us to go to court to collect the rent, we should bear the cost.

For another strange reason, all property owners are assumed to be billionaires, while tenants, no matter who they happen to be, are treated as if they are destitute des·ti·tute  
adj.
1. Utterly lacking; devoid: Young recruits destitute of any experience.

2. Lacking resources or the means of subsistence; completely impoverished. See Synonyms at poor.
. Sometimes I feel as if the judge thinks that he is Robin Hood Robin Hood, legendary hero of 12th-century England who robbed the rich to help the poor. Chivalrous, manly, fair, and always ready for a joke, Robin Hood reflected many of the ideals of the English yeoman. , protecting the common folk against Prince John and the Sheriff of Nottingham Sheriff of Nottingham

traditional badman; thwarted in at-tempts to capture Robin Hood. [Br. Lit.: Robin Hood]

See : Villainy
. I want to scream at the top of my lungs at them to see me, the tenant and our dispute for what it is. I am sick of the courts seeing our little non-payment proceeding as some epic class struggle of the serfs against a landed nobility Landed nobility is a category of nobility in various countries over the history, for which landownership was part of their noble privileges. Their character depends on the country.
  • Landed gentry is the landed nobility in the United Kingdom.
!

I want the law as written to be upheld. Is that so difficult for judges to understand? Enforce the provisions of the lease as agreed upon Adj. 1. agreed upon - constituted or contracted by stipulation or agreement; "stipulatory obligations"
stipulatory

noncontroversial, uncontroversial - not likely to arouse controversy
 when it was entered into by the parties. A tenant should not have cane blanche to ignore contractual obligations and then use the courts as a shield. The courts ignoring a property owner's rights in favor of some perceived need to help the downtrodden down·trod·den  
adj.
Oppressed; tyrannized.


downtrodden
Adjective

oppressed and lacking the will to resist

Adj. 1.
 tenant is just plain wrong.

Just this week I experienced an outcome in a case that illustrates my point exactly. Let me summarize the facts for you: A tenant - who was renting a large retail space - and I could not agree on a new lease. When the term ended, the tenant requested a one-month extension, to which I said yes. A short time before the extended time lapsed, I walked through the space with the superintendent and noticed the amount of old trade fixtures trade fixture n. a piece of equipment on or attached to the real estate which is used in a trade or business. Trade fixtures differ from other fixtures in that they may be removed from the real estate (even if attached) at the end of the tenancy of the business,  and garbage being left behind. I told the super to make sure that the tenant understood that he had to clean the premises.

In fact, I even wrote the tenant and told him that in order for him to be in compliance with his lease, he must leave it empty and in broom-clean condition. The tenant called me back and said "no problem." Five days after the end of the extended time, the tenant left the store keys with the building's elevator operator. The next day, upon examining the store and finding it filled with fixtures and trash, I telephoned the tenant in his new location, but he did not return my call.

I received an estimate from two contractors to clean the premises, the cheapest of which was nearly $20,000. At that point the new tenant, who was anxious to get into the space, said he would clean it if I gave him more free rent. Since if I had hired a contractor I still would have been unable to collect the rent from the new tenant, I felt this was the cheapest way to accomplish the task at hand. At the same time, I minimized my damages, which I intended to have the old tenant pay.

After several months of going to court, and of course getting nowhere near a trial, the judge who would have heard the case announced that as far as he was concerned, I should eat the expense and chalk it up as a cost of doing business. He ignored the photographs showing the mess and the lease provisions regarding broom-clean condition.

The judge didn't see himself as an impartial arbiter of the law. He was Don Quixote, protecting the helpless tenant. Facts, contractual obligations, fairness or even the law would not stand in his way. An owner of real property is an enemy of the people An Enemy of the People (original Norwegian title: En folkefiende) is an 1882 play written by Norwegian playwright Henrik Ibsen. Ibsen wrote this play in the response to the public outcry against his play Ghosts, which was considered scandalous for the time. , if not officially the state. I don't know Don't know (DK, DKed)

"Don't know the trade." A Street expression used whenever one party lacks knowledge of a trade or receives conflicting instructions from the other party.
 if we are trapped in an Orwellian nightmare or a fantasy by Heller - but I can tell you, this isn't justice.

(Thomas F. Campenni is a real estate consultant advising owners, condominiums and coops. He welcomes responses in writing at 21 West 40th Street, NY, NY 10036, or by calling 212-921-8043).
COPYRIGHT 1997 Hagedorn Publication
No portion of this article can be reproduced without the express written permission from the copyright holder.
Copyright 1997, Gale Group. All rights reserved. Gale Group is a Thomson Corporation Company.

 Reader Opinion

Title:

Comment:



 

Article Details
Printer friendly Cite/link Email Feedback
Author:Campenni, Thomas F.
Publication:Real Estate Weekly
Date:Dec 3, 1997
Words:837
Previous Article:Premium office space availabilities dwindle nationwide.
Next Article:PWC Trade Fair draws rave reviews for networking. (Professional Women in Construction's 7th Annual Trade Fair)
Topics:



Related Articles
Housing Court: and justice for all? (Review and Forecast Section III)
Trial by jury: a rarity that can take you by surprise. (Property Management Supplement)
Whose house is it: Five tips to take the hassle out of the landlord-tenant relationship.
We need to blunt the teeth of the shark. (growing inflexibility of rental housing laws)(Annual Review and Forecast, section 4)
A lease can expand the 'Roommate Law'.
Much Ado About Nothing?(Brief Article)
Buy, sell & rent: managing investment property takes a keen understanding of housing laws and regulations.(Real Estate)
The life of a landlord: acquiring the building is just the beginning. Maintaining tenant relations is critical to becoming a successful property...
Negotiate a successful commercial lease.(Valley Real Estate Spotlight)(Advertisement)
Lease administration musts--lease abstracting.

Terms of use | Copyright © 2009 Farlex, Inc. | Feedback | For webmasters | Submit articles