Printer Friendly
The Free Library
14,634,129 articles and books
Member login
User name  
Password 
 
Join us Forgot password?

Bread and circuses: report card.


BY the time you read this, Kenneth Starr
This article is about the lawyer. For the rapper, see Kenn Starr (rapper)


Kenneth Winston Starr (born July 21, 1946) is an American lawyer and former judge who was appointed to the Office of the Independent Counsel to investigate the death of the
 will almost certainly have forwarded to the House of Representatives his report on possible impeachable im·peach·a·ble  
adj.
1. Capable of being impeached: venal, impeachable public servants.

2. Being such as to warrant impeachment: an impeachable offense.
 offenses committed by President Clinton. The question now is what the ground rules will be for the House's review of the findings. The House must adopt, by simple majority, a resolution governing the Judiciary Committee's investigative authority and members' access to the report. Only after these matters have been settled will the public finally learn the results of Mr. Starr's investigation.

Until recently, Republicans were divided over how to handle the report, with many of them wishing the whole thing would somehow dispose of itself. But now the disarray is on the Democratic side. The House's next move -- like the fate of the Clinton Presidency itself -- depends on how the Democrats resolve it.

Republicans are inclined to support Henry Hyde's desire to limit access to the full report until his Judiciary Committee Judiciary Committee may refer to:
  • U.S. House Committee on the Judiciary
  • U.S. Senate Committee on the Judiciary
 has reviewed its findings. Hyde worries that full disclosure, particularly of grand-jury testimony, could at once protect the guilty (by compromising possible criminal prosecutions) and damage innocent third parties. So the Republicans' draft resolution provides that after the House Sergeant at Arms SERGEANT AT ARMS, An officer appointed by a legislative body, whose duties are to enforce the orders given by such bodies, generally under the warrant of its presiding officer.  takes custody of Starr's report, the Judiciary Committee will consider it behind closed doors, in executive session.

Under this Republican plan, other Members of Congress and the public would have immediate access to the executive summary of the report. Additional material from the full report would be released as the Committee conducted its initial review. The trouble with this plan is that the inevitable leaks would threaten the kind of orderly, judicious review that Rep. Hyde wants.

The Democrats, meanwhile, don't even have a plan. Whereas Henry Hyde

For other people named Henry Hyde, see Henry Hyde (disambiguation).


Henry John Hyde (born April 18 1924), American politician, was a Republican member of the United States House of Representatives from 1975 to 2006, representing the 6th
 has the complete confidence of his Republican colleagues, Hyde's Democratic counterpart, the erratic John Conyers John Conyers, Jr. (born May 16, 1929) is a member of the United States House of Representatives representing Michigan's 14th congressional district, which includes all of Highland Park and Hamtramck, as well as parts of Detroit and Dearborn.  of Michigan, emphatically does not have the confidence of his chief, Minority Leader Dick Gephardt. So Gephardt hopes to assume a larger role for himself, which means he has to get his counterpart, Speaker Newt Gingrich, more directly involved in the process.

Democrats are also divided on the threshold question of how much of the report should be made public. Rep. John Dingell John David Dingell, Jr. (born in Colorado Springs, Colorado, July 8 1926) is a Democratic United States Representative from Michigan and is currently the Dean (longest-serving member) of the House of Representatives, with a tenure longer than the entire current time served of 121  (D., Mich.) favors immediate full disclosure so as to resolve the President's fate as quickly as possible -- and avoid any unpleasant revelations just before November's elections. Others would rather postpone receipt of the report until after the elections, and still others would try to minimize damage to the President by releasing information in dribs and drabs dribs and drabs
Noun, pl

Informal small occasional amounts
 (as the White House has done to great effect so far).

No doubt plenty of Democrats hope with Sen. Daniel Patrick Moynihan Noun 1. Daniel Patrick Moynihan - United States politician and educator (1927-2003)
Moynihan
 (N.Y.) that ''we can have this all behind us in six weeks' time,'' but that will happen only if they can persuade Clinton to resign. Republicans don't anticipate a full impeachment impeachment, formal accusation issued by a legislature against a public official charged with crime or other serious misconduct. In a looser sense the term is sometimes applied also to the trial by the legislature that may follow.  inquiry until after the elections. If, after its initial review, the Judiciary Committee determines that the Starr report contains substantial and credible evidence of impeachable acts, it will request authority to conduct an impeachment inquiry. A majority of the House would have to agree to launch the inquiry and provide the Committee resources for a full investigation.

The Committee would then call witnesses, and the President would be represented by counsel. At this stage, the Committee would no longer be limited to the evidence of wrongdoing wrong·do·er  
n.
One who does wrong, especially morally or ethically.



wrongdo
 contained in the Starr report. It would be free to investigate other possible misdeeds by the Clinton Administration, such as whether the Internal Revenue Service conducted politically motivated audits.

At that point the political community will still be debating the relative merits of congressional censure, resignation, or impeachment. But one imaginative GOP aide in the Senate worries that the President might have a constitutional trick up his sleeve. If there is bipartisan support for impeachment, the President, suffering from clinical depression, might invoke the Twenty-Fifth Amendment The Twenty-fifth Amendment to the U.S. Constitution reads:


Section 1. In case of the removal of the President from office or of his death or resignation, the Vice President shall become President.

Section 2.
 and step aside temporarily. Acting President Gore would then assume the duties of the office, until a deeply remorseful re·morse·ful  
adj.
Marked by or filled with remorse.



re·morseful·ly adv.
 President Clinton emerged from some clinic and was pronounced ''healed.'' It's a far-fetched scenario, but it shows that the ''Comeback Kid'' still stalks the nightmares of conservatives.

IN fact, the President will be removed from office if, and only if, Democrats decide that he must go. Through each and every scandal Democrats aggressively defended their President and attacked his accusers. But the first defectors have now appeared. By pinning responsibility squarely on the President, Sen. Joseph Lieberman (Conn.) and others have made it clear that Ken Starr cannot be blamed for Clinton's predicament. That robs the White House of its central argument. And Democrats who have asserted that the President is in the clear if the Starr report contains evidence ''only'' of lying under oath Noun 1. lying under oath - criminal offense of making false statements under oath
bearing false witness, perjury

infraction, misdemeanor, misdemeanour, violation, infringement - a crime less serious than a felony
 in a civil case must now contend with Sen. Moynihan's declaration that such behavior is an ''impeachable offense.''

Nor is it likely that the President can rescue himself by battling the Republican Congress on the issues this fall, as some Democrats are urging. In late August, the Pew Research Center The Pew Research Center is a "fact tank" based in Washington, D.C., that provides information on the issues, attitudes and trends shaping the USA and the world. The Center and its projects receive funding from The Pew Charitable Trusts.  asked Americans what one word best describes Bill Clinton. The top choice wasn't ''effective,'' but ''liar'' (offered by 42 per cent), with another 18 per cent favoring ''dishonest,'' and 12 per cent ''untrustworthy.'' The President cannot advance his own policy agenda, or anyone else's political agenda.

But then he has never done much for other Democrats. Since his election they have lost 52 House seats, 12 Senate seats, and 14 governorships -- and those losses will mount in November. My bet is that over the next few weeks, congressional Democrats will finally decide they have suffered enough.
COPYRIGHT 1998 National Review, Inc.
No portion of this article can be reproduced without the express written permission from the copyright holder.
Copyright 1998, Gale Group. All rights reserved. Gale Group is a Thomson Corporation Company.

 Reader Opinion

Title:

Comment:



 

Article Details
Printer friendly Cite/link Email Feedback
Title Annotation:how Congress will handle independent counsel Kenneth W. Starr's report
Author:O'Beirne, Kate
Publication:National Review
Article Type:Brief Article
Date:Sep 28, 1998
Words:935
Previous Article:Bubble trouble.(economist Milton Friedman)(Interview)(Brief Article)
Next Article:Russian rubble.(Russia's crisis is moral)



Related Articles
THE SCANDAL II: Without Counsel.(effect of independent counsel on impeachment process)
Hunting The President.(Review)
STARR WINS FIRST ROUND ON PRIVILEGE.(News)
CLINTON COUNTS ON PUBLIC TO FORGIVE AFFAIR.(News)
STARR'S PROBE OF CLINTON ABOUT MORE THAN SEX.(VIEWPOINT)
GALLEGLY SEES UNEASY TASK AHEAD; CONGRESSMAN FEARS EFFECTS OF STARR REPORT.(News)
IMPEACHMENT THREAT LOOMING AMONG LEADERS.(News)
STARR DELIVERS REPORT ON PROBE TO CONGRESS.(News)
LEAKS TIED TO STARR, DEPUTIES.(NEWS)
HOUSE MAY LACK HEART TO IMPEACH.(NEWS)

Terms of use | Copyright © 2009 Farlex, Inc. | Feedback | For webmasters | Submit articles