Printer Friendly

Blood alternative products: correction regarding Jehovah's Witnesses.

To the Editor: You published a gross inaccuracy in the SAMJ SAMJ South African Medical Journal  (1) by stating that Hemopure has the 'Thumbs up from Jehovah's Witnesses'. With regard to bovine and human-derived haemoglobin-based oxygen carriers (HBOCs) you also incorrectly stated that both 'Hemopure ... and another similar product, Polyheme ... are unconditionally accepted by Jehovah's Witnesses'. These statements are very misleading to readers who may treat our members who endeavour to follow the Bible injunction to 'abstain from ... blood' (Acts 15:20).

First of all, it is not our policy to endorse any medical product. Secondly, the decision as to whether an individual Witness will accept or reject fractions from red blood cells Red blood cells
Cells that carry hemoglobin (the molecule that transports oxygen) and help remove wastes from tissues throughout the body.

Mentioned in: Bone Marrow Transplantation

red blood cells 
, such as Hemopure or Polyheme, is a personal one and will vary from one Witness patient to another.

The manager of the American Biopure Corporation in South Africa South Africa, Afrikaans Suid-Afrika, officially Republic of South Africa, republic (2005 est. pop. 44,344,000), 471,442 sq mi (1,221,037 sq km), S Africa. , Dr Mandisa Mholwana, is aware of our stand on this matter, which was communicated to her in writing in early 2008, and she agreed to delete any statement in their publications and website to the effect that Hemopure is acceptable to Jehovah's Witnesses. It is regrettable that she did not inform you of our clearly stated viewpoint on this.

Considering the importance of the underlying personal, medical and constitutional issues in connection with an individual's decision whether to accept Hemopure, we are sure that you would wish to correct any impression given in the article that we, as Jehovah's Witnesses, unconditionally accept such commercial products.

C F Muller

Chairman, Christian Congregation of Jehovah's Witnesses The non-profit corporation Christian Congregation of Jehovah's Witnesses was established to organize and administer the congregational affairs of Jehovah's Witnesses in the United States.  of South Africa

fmuller@jw.org.za

(1.) Bateman C. Metanalysis critical of blood alternative product challenged. S Afr Med J 2008; 98: 746-748.

Chris Bateman Chris Bateman is a game designer and writer who is best known for his work on the games Discworld Noir and Ghost Master. Founder and director of game design and narrative consultancy company International Hobo.  replies: I apologise for what seems to have been a misunderstanding of the claims made by the Hemopure designers and distributors during my interview with them, but more especially for not having contacted you to verify and clarify. The intention was to convey that the product, unlike human blood, was acceptable to Jehovah's Witnesses, a contention I accepted in good faith.

One of the key Hemopure designers quoted in the article, Professor Colin Mackenzie
For the Australian fauna park founder known by the same name, see William Colin Mackenzie
For Colin Mackenzie (1898-1986), the head of Force 136, see Colin Hercules Mackenzie
Colonel Colin Mackenzie
, has read your objections. He acknowledges that Jehovah's Witness patients abstain from blood, noting also that many Jehovah Witnesses do accept HBOCs. Professor Mackenzie adds: 'the author is correct, the decision to accept HBOCs is an individual decision. The Jehovah's Witness religious movement does not and never has endorsed any medical product such as HBOCs.'

Professor Mackenzie has apologised for the confusion about the church stance that arose during the interview, as has Dr Mahlowana for any inference that Hemopure is acceptable to all Jehovah's Witness patients. We hope that publication of your letter and this response will help better inform our readers.
COPYRIGHT 2009 South African Medical Association
No portion of this article can be reproduced without the express written permission from the copyright holder.
Copyright 2009 Gale, Cengage Learning. All rights reserved.

 Reader Opinion

Title:

Comment:



 

Article Details
Printer friendly Cite/link Email Feedback
Title Annotation:Briewe
Author:Muller, C.F.
Publication:South African Medical Journal
Article Type:Letter to the editor
Date:Feb 1, 2009
Words:453
Previous Article:HIV prevalence among medical students in Johannesburg, South Africa.
Next Article:Health services battle as KZN'S budget implodes.

Terms of use | Copyright © 2014 Farlex, Inc. | Feedback | For webmasters