BUTCHER GETS TO MEAT OF THE MATTER IN `I STAND ALONE'.Byline: Stephen Holden The New York Times Which of us hasn't at one time or another felt at least a twinge of the despair, fury and misanthropy Misanthropy Misbehavior (See MISCHIEVOUSNESS.) Ahab, Captain consumed by hate, pursues whale that ripped off his leg. [Am. Lit.: Moby Dick] Alceste antisocial hero. [Fr. Lit. that engulf the unlucky protagonist of Gaspar Noe's devastating film ``I Stand Alone''? The story of an unemployed 50-year-old Parisian butcher (Philippe Nahon), whose disgruntled dis·grun·tle tr.v. dis·grun·tled, dis·grun·tling, dis·grun·tles To make discontented. [dis- + gruntle, to grumble (from Middle English gruntelen; see bitterness accumulates into a sustained psychotic rage, suggests a darker sequel to ``Taxi Driver,'' filtered through Dostoyevsky by way of Godard with an added touch of ``Hard Copy.'' ``I Stand Alone'' probes as relentlessly into the psychology of nihilism nihilism (nī`əlĭzəm), theory of revolution popular among Russian extremists until the fall of the czarist government (1917); the theory was given its name by Ivan Turgenev in his novel Fathers and Sons (1861). as any movie has ever attempted. It uses the most extreme images and jarring sound effects to brand its character's searing message onto our brains whether we like it or not. Those devices include the use of amplified gunshots to demarcate de·mar·cate tr.v. de·mar·cat·ed, de·mar·cat·ing, de·mar·cates 1. To set the boundaries of; delimit. 2. To separate clearly as if by boundaries; distinguish: demarcate categories. scenes, unblinking close-up images of shuddering violence (a pregnant woman is repeatedly kicked and punched in the stomach, a girl is shot in the throat and writhes in agonized ag·o·nize v. ag·o·nized, ag·o·niz·ing, ag·o·niz·es v.intr. 1. To suffer extreme pain or great anguish. 2. To make a great effort; struggle. v.tr. death throes throe n. 1. A severe pang or spasm of pain, as in childbirth. See Synonyms at pain. 2. throes A condition of agonizing struggle or trouble: a country in the throes of economic collapse. ), a swatch of hard-core pornography and a continual torrent of hateful epithets directed at almost everybody but especially at those suspected of being homosexual. Most of the harsh language isn't spoken aloud but is the unedited, voice-over stream-of-consciousness in the boiling mind of a man who sees the entire world as his implacable enemy. In the most disturbing passages of his monologue, he insists that all human love is essentially self-interested and acquisitive, that no matter what we tell ourselves, we are each of us forever unutterably alone in a meaningless universe. The movie's animalistic an·i·mal·ism n. 1. Enjoyment of vigorous health and physical drives. 2. Indifference to all but the physical appetites. 3. The doctrine that humans are merely animals with no spiritual nature. imagery, which includes close-ups of human hands slicing and manipulating large chunks of red horse meat, underscores this view of human life as essentially bestial. ``I Stand Alone'' begins as a staccato recap of the butcher's life until 1980, when the story begins. As an impersonal male voice recites his history, snapshots tracing his life and screaming black-and-white tabloid headlines announce such themes as ``justice'' and ``morality.'' Those headlines keep appearing through the rest of the film. As the story opens, the butcher has already done prison time for assaulting a man who he mistakenly believed had raped his daughter. With the girl institutionalized, our anti-hero anti-hero, principal character of a modern literary or dramatic work who lacks the attributes of the traditional protagonist or hero. The anti-hero's lack of courage, honesty, or grace, his weaknesses and confusion, often reflect modern man's ambivalence toward , determined to start life over, has moved from Paris to Lille, where he shares a cramped apartment with his pregnant lover and her mother. Unable to find employment at a deli counter (his refusal to smile when told to brighten up costs him the job), he sinks into a despondent rage. After a brutal domestic quarrel, he returns to Paris and his bleak old neighborhood, where he takes a room in a fleabag flea·bag n. Informal 1. A seedy, rundown hotel or other lodging place. 2. An animal considered to be inferior or in poor condition. Noun 1. hotel and futilely seeks employment in the meat industry. Each rejection spurs his increasingly violent fantasies of revenge. Reuniting with his daughter, he takes her back to his hotel, where he broods on how to spend the last three bullets left in his gun. As surges of tenderness and self-pity mingle with his vivid fantasies of incest, murder and suicide, the movie offers the tiniest glimmer of redemption. Despite these glimmerings, ``I Stand Alone'' is unrelievingly grim. Fleshy, hollowed-eyed and glowering glow·er intr.v. glow·ered, glow·er·ing, glow·ers To look or stare angrily or sullenly. See Synonyms at frown. n. An angry or sullen look or stare. impassively, Nahon's butcher suggests a walking piece of meat wired with dynamite. The movie's triumph - if that's what it is - is in the force of its assault. It takes one man's unbearable truth and bashes us in the skull with it. The hurt lingers. The facts The film: ``I Stand Alone'' (not rated; ; sex, violence, language). The stars: Philippe Nahon, Blandine Lenoir, Frankye Pain, Martine Audrain. Behind the scenes: Written and directed by Gaspar Noe. Produced by Noe and Lucille Hadzihalilovic. Distributed by Strand Releasing. Running time: One hour, 32 minutes. Playing: Nuart, West Los Angeles
Our rating: Three stars CAPTION(S): photo PHOTO An unwillingness to smile gets a butcher (Philippe Nahon) fired in ``I Stand Alone,'' which was written and directed by Gaspar Noe. |
|
||||||||||||||||||

Printer friendly
Cite/link
Email
Feedback
Reader Opinion