Printer Friendly
The Free Library
22,728,043 articles and books

BLACK LUNG: Anatomy of a Public Health Disaster.

BLACK LUNG black lung: see pneumoconiosis. : Anatomy of a Public Health Disaster By Alan Derickson Cornell University Cornell University, mainly at Ithaca, N.Y.; with land-grant, state, and private support; coeducational; chartered 1865, opened 1868. It was named for Ezra Cornell, who donated $500,000 and a tract of land. With the help of state senator Andrew D.  Press, $29.95

Black's law dictionary Black's Law Dictionary is the law dictionary for the law of the United States. It was founded by Henry Campbell Black. It has been cited as legal authority in many Supreme Court cases (see Secondary authority).  says that "criminal homicide constitutes manslaughter when it is committed recklessly." Criminal homicide constitutes murder when "it is committed recklessly under circumstances manifesting extreme indifference to the value of human life." Do either of these categories apply to the conduct of an industry which knows that it is causing fatal disease in its workers, covers up the harm, opposes remedial measures and then cheats on monitoring tests designed to assure its workers' safety?

Certainly Alan Derickson's Black Lung: Anatomy of a Public Health Disaster offers a searing sear 1  
v. seared, sear·ing, sears
1. To char, scorch, or burn the surface of with or as if with a hot instrument. See Synonyms at burn1.

 indictment of the industry. In a richly detailed account of the worker, public, corporate and medical understanding of the diseases once grouped under the name "miners' asthma" but now called black lung, Derickson shows that the devastating dev·as·tate  
tr.v. dev·as·tat·ed, dev·as·tat·ing, dev·as·tates
1. To lay waste; destroy.

2. To overwhelm; confound; stun: was devastated by the rude remark.
 effects of coal dust on miners' health have long been known, but long denied by coal operators, medical doctors--many company-influenced--and government regulators.

Derickson's book opens by recounting an 1881 presentation by H.A. Lemen, a professor of medicine at the University of Denver Background and rankings
The University was founded in 1864 as Colorado Seminary by John Evans, the former Territorial Governor of Colorado, who had been appointed by US President Abraham Lincoln.
, to the Colorado State Medical Society. Discussing a coal-miner patient, Lemen reported not only on his "harassing cough" but that he spit up a pint of black liquid--of a "decidely inky appearance"--a day. "The sentence I am reading was written with this fluid," he said. Lemen was not a maverick. British medical researchers had linked coal mining and respiratory ailments a full half century earlier. By the beginning of the twentieth century, there was widespread recognition of "miners' asthma" among medical professionals in the United States United States, officially United States of America, republic (2005 est. pop. 295,734,000), 3,539,227 sq mi (9,166,598 sq km), North America. The United States is the world's third largest country in population and the fourth largest country in area. , although there was no good epidemiological evidence available. And while there was substantial confusion over the etiology of miners' asthma, some doctors emphasized the need for ventilation as a preventive measure to address a disease for which there was no cure. "Even the coal operators grudgingly grudg·ing  
Reluctant; unwilling.

grudging·ly adv.

Adv. 1.
 conceded that miners' asthma existed," Derickson reports.

But following the great 1902 strike, progress toward understanding the disease came to a halt, and the mining companies, company doctors, and even independent physicians increasingly denied the existence or at least importance of miners' asthma. Indeed, for a long period of time it was argued that exposure to mine dust may provide a protective coating for the lungs, which would guard against tuberculosis.

The turnabout was due in part to developments in the medical profession, such as the increasing reliance on x-rays, which often fail to reveal black lung, but especially to a newfound recalcitrance among mining companies. The industry exerted its political power in state after state to ensure that workers' compensation workers' compensation, payment by employers for some part of the cost of injuries, or in some cases of occupational diseases, received by employees in the course of their work.  did not cover miners' asthma, except silicosis silicosis (sĭlĭkō`sĭs), occupational disease of the lungs caused by inhalation of free silica (quartz) dust over a prolonged period of time. , a severe form of black lung visible in x-rays.

Government and industry acknowledgement of black lung came only in the late 1960s. The shift was spurred not by any scientific breakthroughs, but by miners' organizing efforts to influence the legal, medical and popular conception of what had long been a disease defined by politics. Responding to a handful of progressive doctors who validated their disease and forcefully articulated the case of coal dust causation of lung impairments, thousands of miners joined the West Virginia West Virginia, E central state of the United States. It is bordered by Pennsylvania and Maryland (N), Virginia (E and S), and Kentucky and, across the Ohio R., Ohio (W). Facts and Figures

Area, 24,181 sq mi (62,629 sq km). Pop.
 Black Lung Association. In early 1969, 40,000 miners went on strike, demanding that West Virginia recognize black lung as a compensable com·pen·sa·ble  
Being such as to entitle or warrant compensation: compensable injuries.

Adj. 1.
 condition. The strike led directly to passage of West Virginian workers' compensation legislation covering all forms of black lung, and soon to passage of the Federal Coal Mine Safety and Health Act of 1969.

The Mine Safety and Health Act had numerous shortcomings A shortcoming is a character flaw.

Shortcomings may also be:
  • Shortcomings (SATC episode), an episode of the television series Sex and the City
, but it represented a giant leap forward for the miners. It established a federal compensation scheme; it required mines to transfer workers with early signs of black lung to less dusty jobs with no loss in pay; and it put in place a federal standard for coal dust exposure. That federal standard stipulated that three years after enactment, miners could not be exposed to more than two milligrams of dust per cubic meter Noun 1. cubic meter - a metric unit of volume or capacity equal to 1000 liters
cubic metre, kiloliter, kilolitre

metric capacity unit - a capacity unit defined in metric terms
 of air, the standard still in effect. Finally, it seemed, the cruel black lung deaths of coal miners would fade into history, as exposure declined and new cases were prevented.

As dramatic and hard-fought as the miners' victory was, it proved much less effective at curbing coal company abuses than must have been expected. Coal companies routinely cheat on coal dust sampling tests designed to evidence mine compliance with federal standards, making it impossible to know how serious dust exposures are. Black lung remains commonplace in coal country, with nearly 1,500 black lung deaths registered in 1994.

In 1991, then-Secretary of Labor Lynn Martin announced that coal operators had demonstrated a virtual "addiction to cheating" on coal dust sampling tests, charging that more than one third of the underground mines in the United States had tampered with coal dust samples submitted to the Mine Safety Health Administration (MSHA MSHA Mine Safety and Health Administration (US government)
MSHA Master of Science in Health Administration
MSHA Mine Safety and Health Administration
MSHA Maison des Sciences de l'Homme d'Aquitaine (French) 
). Following a guilty plea by the nation's largest coal company, Peabody Coal, the Labor Department The Department of Labor (DOL) administers federal labor laws for the Executive Branch of the federal government. Its mission is "to foster, promote, and develop the welfare of the wage earners of the United States, to improve their working  found "abnormal white centers" (AWCs) in the mine dust sampling cassettes submitted by approximately 500 mine operators. The Department alleged that the AWCs were caused by companies vacuuming the cassettes before forwarding them to inspectors. The mine operators bitterly fought the charges, arguing that the AWCs could result from the cassettes being dropped or from rough handling. Without eyewitness evidence, a judge threw out most of the citations.

But the Louisville Courier-Journal has done the Labor Department one better. In a stunning series on black lung published in April 1998, the paper examined coal dust sampling records and found that, in fiscal year 1997, 80 percent of the nation's underground mines submitted air samples that were impossibly clean. Samples taken in working areas at these mines registered .1 milligram milligram /mil·li·gram/ (mg) (mil´i-gram) one thousandth (10-3) of a gram.

n. Abbr. mg
A metric unit of mass equal to one thousandth (10-3) of a gram.
 of dust--the level that would be expected on a city street and a level which MSHA head J. Davitt McAteer calls "unfathomable" and "statistically impossible" Nearly half of the mines cheated on at least one in seven of their sampling tests.

In an extraordinary piece of journalism, reporter Gardiner Harris supplemented the statistical analysis with interviews with foremen and workers who describe how the coal companies cheated on the dust sampling tests. "You just don't get bad samples and stay with these companies. They will fire your butt," explained one foreman. "They run them [dust tests] for 30 minutes and it's supposed to be eight hours," said a miner. And another foreman: "I was told by the superintendent or the owner to see to it that the dust pumps was turned off.... I turned off the machines myself where I was a foreman."

There are, of course, other hazards of mining, as Duane Lockard recalls in Coal, an interesting meld of analysis and personal memoir from a Princeton University Princeton University, at Princeton, N.J.; coeducational; chartered 1746, opened 1747, rechartered 1748, called the College of New Jersey until 1896. Schools and Research Facilities
 professor emeritus who comes from a coal family and spent some time in mines as a young man. Lockard's book provides a useful but rather general overview of mine explosions and other disasters, low pay, the successful fight of the Miners for Democracy to clean up the miners' union and other chapters in the story of the coal industry in twentieth century America. Where Lockard's book comes alive is with his personal recollections and quotations from the diary he kept as a young man. Through the eyes of a child in coal towns and of a young miner, Lockard conveys the life of a mining family--how they simultaneously depend on, and suffer at the hands of, the unaccountable corporations that dominate their community.

Life in coal country has certainly improved since Lockard's Depression-era childhood. Company towns are a thing of the past, pay is much higher, mine explosions are much rarer and workers have won significant pension rights. These gains are largely due to the efforts of the United Mine Workers of America United Mine Workers of America (UMW), international labor union formed (1890) by the amalgamation of the National Progressive Union (organized 1888) and the mine locals under the Knights of Labor. It is an industrial union, including all workers in the coal industry.  (UMWA UMWA n abbr (= United Mineworkers of America) → amerikanische Bergarbeitergewerkschaft ), nothwithstanding all of its faults during the 40-year autocratic reign of John Lewis and a decade of rule under a corrupt successor. The union is now a forceful advocate for health and safety, and union mines are much less likely to cheat on dust samples than non-union mines, according to according to
1. As stated or indicated by; on the authority of: according to historians.

2. In keeping with: according to instructions.

 the Courier-Journal's analysis.

But even as the triumph of Miners for Democracy, a democratic insurgent INSURGENT. One who is concerned in an insurrection. He differs from a rebel in this, that rebel is always understood in a bad sense, or one who unjustly opposes the constituted authorities; insurgent may be one who justly opposes the tyranny of constituted authorities.  movement, installed a more responsive union leadership, mechanization mechanization

Use of machines, either wholly or in part, to replace human or animal labour. Unlike automation, which may not depend at all on a human operator, mechanization requires human participation to provide information or instruction.
 and a shift of the U.S. mining industry to the largely non-union West has drastically shrunk the size of the union and, consequently, diminished its bargaining strength and political influence. In the near term, at the very least, it does not appear that the miners' union will be able to function as a sufficient countervailing force to offset the mine owners' power.

How then to deal with the ongoing black lung issue, among the many problems still created by King Coal? MSHA head McAteer, a harsh industry critic before he assumed a place in government, says the federal government should take over dust monitoring responsibilities from the mines. But the UMWA says this move would be inadequate unless the number of federal inspectors was significantly increased. If the feds only test four times a year, the union says, the mine operators will be able to operate dirty on 361 days.

Until McAteer is able to finagle a large enough congressional appropriation, another approach might make sense: cracking down on fraud. After the Bush administration lodged the 1991 high-profile charges of dust-sample tampering, fraud dropped, according to the Louisville Courier-Journal's analysis.

McAteer is disinclined dis·in·clined  
Unwilling or reluctant: They were usually disinclined to socialize.


unwilling or reluctant

 to pursue this approach. "I'm not so much concerned about the criminal stuff," he told the Louisville paper. The "criminal stuff," however, is exactly what needs attention. And the seeming technicality of dust-sample tampering needs to be placed in an appropriate context. When violations of the law cause thousands of people to continue to suffer wrenching illness and die from foreseeable and preventable causes, why aren't criminal homicide prosecutions in order?

Robert Weissman is the editor of the Washington, D.C.-based Multinational Monitor.
COPYRIGHT 1999 Washington Monthly Company
No portion of this article can be reproduced without the express written permission from the copyright holder.
Copyright 1999, Gale Group. All rights reserved. Gale Group is a Thomson Corporation Company.

 Reader Opinion




Article Details
Printer friendly Cite/link Email Feedback
Title Annotation:Review
Author:Weissman, Robert
Publication:Washington Monthly
Article Type:Book Review
Date:Jan 1, 1999
Previous Article:BETWEEN VENGEANCE AND FORGIVENESS: Facing History after Genocide and Mass Violence.
Next Article:COAL: A Memoir and Critique.

Related Articles
American Anatomies: Theorizing Race and Gender.
COAL: A Memoir and Critique.
A Map of the Child: A Pediatrician's Tour of the Body.

Terms of use | Copyright © 2014 Farlex, Inc. | Feedback | For webmasters