Printer Friendly
The Free Library
6,672,335 articles and books
Member login
User name  
Password 
 
Join us Forgot password?

BJC = [JMD.sup.2]: the contributions of Joseph M. Dawson and James M. Dunn to the Baptist Joint Committee: like the old Campbell's Soup television jingle about "soup and sandwich," Joseph M. Dawson and James M. Dunn "go together.".


Both of their portraits hang on the same wall in the Baptist Joint Committee (BJC BJC British Journal of Cancer
BJC Baptist Joint Committee
BJC Bechtel Jacobs Company, LLC
BJC Bryce Jordan Center (Penn State University building)
BJC Barnes-Jewish/Christian (BJC Healthcare) 
) conference room in Washington, D.C., as if to continue their watching over the work of the agency that they both headed. Dawson was the first executive director of what was then the Joint Conference Committee on Public Relations public relations, activities and policies used to create public interest in a person, idea, product, institution, or business establishment. By its nature, public relations is devoted to serving particular interests by presenting them to the public in the most  (1946-1953). Dunn was the executive director in 1981-1999. Both were born and bred Born and Bred is a light-hearted British drama series that aired for four series on BBC One from 2002 to 2005. It was created by Chris Chibnall and Nigel McCrery. The cast was led by James Bolam and Michael French, who played a father and son who run a cottage hospital in  in Texas, both have the same initials, and both will be remembered by history as fierce champions of religious liberty and church-state separation.

Dawson and Dunn profoundly shaped Baptist social ethics throughout the twentieth century. Dawson was twenty-one years old at the turn of that century, and Dunn "retired" at the end of it. While their legacies continue to influence Baptist and American life, from the Brazos to the Potomac and beyond, the focus of this article is on their understanding of the proper relationship between church and state and religion and politics, in the context of their BJC leadership.

After a brief overview of their general approach to the subject, and with a nod to David Letterman David Michael Letterman (born April 12, 1947, in Indianapolis, Indiana, U.S.) is an award-winning American comedian, late night talk show host, television producer, philanthropist, and IRL IndyCar Series car owner. , I will outline what I judge to be Dawson's and Dunn's "Top 10 Contributions" (five each) to the preservation of religious liberty during their service as executive directors of the Baptist Joint Committee.

Dunn's Understanding of His Life's Work Life's Work is a sitcom that aired from 1996 to 1997 on the American Broadcasting Company channel that starred Lisa Ann Walter as Lisa Ann Minardi Hunter, the assistant district attorney who had a husband named Kevin Hunter

Dawson and Dunn both approached their life's work as a ministry, as nothing short of a calling of God and grounded firmly in their Baptist heritage. Dunn often outlined his understanding of this spiritual enterprise by a living metaphor:
   Drop a pebble in a pond. Watch the ripples. Concentric circles go
   out from the center. That spot takes on life. Energy emanates.

      That little snapshot symbolizes the Baptist vision of religious
   liberty. It is a dynamic vision; there is nothing static about it.
   Baptists see religious liberty as springing from and directly
   related to the center of the divine-human encounter. (1)


In Dunn's metaphor, the first circle represents "soul freedom," the theological taproot taproot

Main root of a primary-root system. It grows vertically downward. From the taproot arise smaller lateral roots (secondary roots), which in turn produce even smaller lateral roots (tertiary roots).
 based squarely in the Genesis creation accounts and the imago imago /ima·go/ (i-ma´go) pl. ima´goes, ima´gines   [L.]
1. the adult or definitive form of an insect.

2. a usually idealized, unconscious mental image of a key person in one's early life.
 dei. We are created in the image of God, free and able to respond to God as we choose and thus are "response-able." "We all are wired up for freedom," Dunn has often said. This volitional vo·li·tion  
n.
1. The act or an instance of making a conscious choice or decision.

2. A conscious choice or decision.

3. The power or faculty of choosing; the will.
 faculty is inherent in all humanity, an "'I' at the center of our being that even Almighty God will not trample." (2)

The second concentric circle rippling from the pebble is religious liberty. If soul freedom is the theological underpinning, religious liberty is the "moral and ethical inevitability" that naturally flows. (3) Because God will not defy our freedom, heaven forbid that we should violate each other's. Dunn's vision of religious liberty is universal, freedom not just for Christians or Baptists, but freedom for all. This moral imperative A moral imperative is a principle originating inside a person's mind that compels that person to act. It is a kind of categorical imperative, as defined by Immanuel Kant. Kant took the imperative to be a dictate of pure reason, in its practical aspect.  also has self-serving implications. One of Dunn's most prolific sound bites was: "If anyone's religious liberty is denied, everyone's is endangered."

The third circle is church-state separation--the constitutional corollary to the theological and ethical precepts. A sensible separation between the institutions of church and state is good for both. But Dunn has always been quick to argue that separation should not result in hostility to religion or a complete walling off of one from another. Sometimes it may be no more than a "strand of barbed wire barbed wire, wire composed of two zinc-coated steel strands twisted together and having barbs spaced regularly along them. The need for barbed wire arose in the 19th cent. ." The separation principle does not require a segregation of religion from politics, God from government, or Christians from their duty of citizenship.

In the final analysis, neither God (soul freedom), nor one's neighbors (religious liberty), nor the state (separation) will or should be allowed to vitiate To impair or make void; to destroy or annul, either completely or partially, the force and effect of an act or instrument.

Mutual mistake or Fraud, for example, might vitiate a contract.
 that voluntary response to God that is the essence of one's humanity.

Dawson's Understanding of His Life's Work

Although he rarely if ever used the term "soul freedom," Dawson understood that liberty began with a gift from God, based on "Divine Revelation Noun 1. divine revelation - communication of knowledge to man by a divine or supernatural agency
revelation

making known, informing - a speech act that conveys information
 as expressed in Christianity." (4) Liberty had nothing to do with any grudging toleration TOLERATION. In some. countries, where religion is established by law, certain sects who do not agree with the established religion are nevertheless permitted to exist, and this permission is called toleration.  from the hand of the state. Toleration is a "weasel word weasel word
n.
An equivocal word used to deprive a statement of its force or to evade a direct commitment.



[From the weasel's habit of sucking the contents out of an egg without breaking the shell.
," Dawson would often say, that fails to capture the essence of individual freedom. Dawson's understanding of freedom was highly Christological: "[Jesus'] message centered on the dignity, worth, and competency of the individual, emphasized the power to choose and promised deliverance from fear of death." (5)

In his speaking and writing, Dawson stressed the principle of religious liberty. For him, religious liberty was "the right and security of every person and group for freedom of conscience, belief and practice, together with free association and unrestricted propagation of faith." (6) Dawson revered his colonial predecessors who championed religious liberty, including Roger Williams, Isaac Backus, and John Leland
This is about John Leland, antiquary. For other people called John Leland see John Leland (disambiguation).


John Leland (September 13 1506 – April 18 1552) was an English antiquary.
. Dawson also saw religious liberty to be a universal right for all, not one guided by self-interest. (7)

As a no-holds-barred believer in church-state separation, Dawson was dubious of the power of government to do anything other than to destroy or at least diminish the vitality of religion. He often wrote that "the sole function of the American state is to recognize [religion's] existence and protect its liberty." (8) Such an institutional separation was "best for the church and best for the state." (9)

Dawson's insistence upon a religiously neutral state prompted him to embrace a word that was as unpopular then as it is today--"secularism sec·u·lar·ism  
n.
1. Religious skepticism or indifference.

2. The view that religious considerations should be excluded from civil affairs or public education.
." In articles, speeches, and even his autobiography, Dawson defended the word. Although acknowledging that "secular" sometimes connotes humanism and materialism, he argued that "when one says ours is a secular state A secular state is a state or country that is officially neutral in matters of religion, neither supporting nor opposing any particular religious beliefs or practices. A secular state also treats all its citizens equally regardless of religion, and does not give preferential  or that our public schools form a secular system, he means they are outside church control, simply that." (10) Any attempt to "sanctify sanc·ti·fy  
tr.v. sanc·ti·fied, sanc·ti·fy·ing, sanc·ti·fies
1. To set apart for sacred use; consecrate.

2. To make holy; purify.

3.
 the secular" ought to come from the church, not the state. (11)

Moreover, Dawson would never say that church-state separation strips religion from public life or excuses bad citizenship on the part of Christians. He wrote, "separation of church and state
See also: .
Separation of church and state is a political and legal doctrine which states that government and religious institutions are to be kept separate and independent of one another.
 means separation on an official, organizational, legally contractual level. This allows freest interaction between both on a moral and spiritual level." (12) As he said many times: "If religion is to guide and control the state ..., it must do so morally and spiritually." (13)

Although highly educated and well read, neither Dawson nor Dunn was an ivory tower ivory tower
n.
A place or attitude of retreat, especially preoccupation with lofty, remote, or intellectual considerations rather than practical everyday life.
 intellectual. Both were inveterate inveterate /in·vet·er·ate/ (-vet´er-at) confirmed and chronic; long-established and difficult to cure.

in·vet·er·ate
adj.
1. Firmly and long established; deep-rooted.

2.
 activists. They were "doers of the word." Their remarkable deeds are what have had the greatest influence.

"Top 10 Contributions"

Following are my picks for their "Top 10 Contributions," beginning with Dawson.

1. A Friend of the (Supreme) Count. Early in his tenure as executive director, Dawson led the Joint Committee to file friend-of-the-court briefs in two seminal Supreme Court cases: Everson v. Board, 330 U.S. 1 (1947) and McCollum v. Board, 333 U.S. 203 (1948). These cases helped fashion the Court's post-World War II Establishment Clause jurisprudence dealing with funding for parochial education parochial education

Education offered institutionally by a religious group. The curriculum usually includes both religious and general studies. In the U.S. and Canada, parochial education has referred primarily to elementary and secondary schools maintained by Roman Catholic
 and religion in the public schools.

Everson involved the challenge to a New Jersey statute that allowed reimbursement to be made to the parents of parochial school parochial school (pərō`kēəl), school supported by a religious body. In the United States such schools are maintained by a number of religious groups, including Lutherans, Seventh-day Adventists, Orthodox Jews, Muslims, and  children for transportation expenses. The Joint Committee's chairman, E. Hilton Jackson, a Washington lawyer, filed a brief arguing that the practice was unconstitutional. The Supreme Court, however, disagreed. Although all nine justices wrote or joined opinions that were strongly separationist sep·a·ra·tion·ist  
n.
A separatist.

Noun 1. separationist - an advocate of secession or separation from a larger group (such as an established church or a national union)
separatist
, a majority of five decided that the funding practice benefited primarily students and their parents, not the parochial schools. Therefore, the scheme did not breach the wall of separation between church and state. Ironically, the opinion was authored by Justice Hugo Black Hugo LaFayette Black (February 27, 1886–September 25, 1971) was an American politician and jurist. A member of the Democratic Party, Black represented the state of Alabama in the United States Senate from 1926 to 1937, and served as an Associate Justice of the Supreme Court , a Baptist who had served briefly on the Committee before his appointment to the Court. The fact that the Court unanimously endorsed a robust understanding of the Establishment Clause while upholding the funding scheme caused Dawson to remark cheerfully that "We had lost a battle, but won the war!" (14)

McCollum involved a challenge to a program that provided voluntary religious instruction by religious groups in a public school classroom. The Joint Committee again filed a brief arguing that such practice violated the Establishment Clause. In an 8-1 decision, also authored by Justice Black, the Court agreed with the Committee's position and struck down the on-campus "released time Released Time is a concept used in the United States public school system wherein pupils enrolled in the public schools are permitted by law to receive religious instruction. " program.

Although most of its Baptist constituents applauded the Committee's participation in Everson, the reaction to its position in McCollum was hostile. Dawson observed that "Nothing our Committee ever did caused so much turmoil," and he even traveled to Nashville to defend the Committee's position before the Executive Committee of the Southern Baptist Convention Noun 1. Southern Baptist Convention - an association of Southern Baptists
association - a formal organization of people or groups of people; "he joined the Modern Language Association"

Southern Baptist - a member of the Southern Baptist Convention
. (15)

Dawson's involvement in these two cases is significant. It established the precedent of filing friend-of-the court briefs, which the Joint Committee has done more than one hundred times since then. His leadership set the tone of robust interpretation of the Establishment Clause that continues to inform the Committee's view, and it presaged the harsh criticism the Committee often would suffer at the hands of both friends and foes.

2. Setting up Shop. Although the Joint Committee and its predecessors had been in existence for some ten years, Dawson was obliged to create a viable organizational framework for the Committee's work after arriving in Washington, D.C., in 1946. He wasted little time in launching a monthly newsletter, which he called Report from the Capital. Beginning in October 1946 and continuing to this day, Report from the Capital has been published on a regular basis, usually monthly, but several years during the 1990s, every two weeks, as the Committee's flagship publication.

The BJC initially was founded by the Northern Baptist Convention Noun 1. Northern Baptist Convention - an association of Northern Baptists
American Baptist Convention

association - a formal organization of people or groups of people; "he joined the Modern Language Association"
 (now American Baptist American Baptist may refer to:
  • American Baptist Association
  • American Baptist Churches USA
  • Baptist who is an American
 Churches, USA) and the Southern Baptist Convention. In 1939, the predominately African-American denomination, the National Baptist Convention National Baptist Convention is the name of several historically African-American Christian denominations, among which are the following:
  • National Baptist Convention, USA, Inc. - The oldest and largest
  • National Baptist Convention of America, Inc.
, U.S.A., Inc., joined the Committee. In addition to strengthening participation of other African-American Baptists, Dawson was able to attract representatives from the Seventh Day Baptists, the Baptist General Conference The Baptist General Conference (BGC) is a national evangelical Baptist body with roots in Pietism in Sweden and inroads among evangelical Scandinavian-Americans, particularly persons located in the American Upper Midwest.  (Swedish tradition), and the North American Baptist Conference North American Baptist Conference (NABC) - initially an association of Baptists in the United States and Canada of German ethnic heritage.

The roots of the NABC go back to 1839, when Konrad Anton Fleischmann began work in New Jersey and Pennsylvania with German immigrants.
 (German heritage). These groups continue to play a vital role in the now fourteen-member-body coalition of the BJC.

Finally, Dawson was instrumental in founding Protestants and Other Americans United for the Separation of Church and State in 1947. POAU is now Americans United for Separation of Church and State Americans United for Separation of Church and State (Americans United or AU for short) is a religious freedom advocacy group in the United States which promotes the separation of church and state, a legal doctrine seen by the AU as being enshrined in the Establishment . Dawson counted his role in forming POAU and serving as its first secretary one of his most important contributions to the defense of religious liberty. Joining the organizational meeting at the historic National Baptist Memorial Church in Washington were Brooks Hays, member of Congress and Baptist lay leader, and representatives of various other religious groups and organizations. According to according to
prep.
1. As stated or indicated by; on the authority of: according to historians.

2. In keeping with: according to instructions.

3.
 Dawson, "POAU had not a penny on which to operate" and thus began in a single room in the offices of the Joint Committee. Though physically proximate proximate /prox·i·mate/ (prok´si-mit) immediate or nearest.

prox·i·mate
adj.
Closely related in space, time, or order; very near; proximal.



proximate

immediate; nearest.
, Dawson was careful to point out their different missions. Eager that the public not be confused, Dawson averred in his autobiography that "the Baptist Committee existed primarily for study and pronouncement, while POAU proposed action." (16) Thus, Dawson not only expanded the coalition of Baptists but established the precedent of working with other religious and civil liberties groups. Americans United continues to be a valued coalition partner with the BJC.

3. Speaking Out and Writing. Dawson made important contributions through his writing and speaking on Baptist distinctives Baptist Distinctives is a name usually given to a list of doctrinal principles that have traditionally described what Baptists as a whole believe.

One way of classifying a set of principles common to most Baptist traditions is called the "Four Freedoms," articulated by
 and religious liberty. In addition to Report from the Capital and other BJC pamphlets and publications, Dawson published three books during and after his tenure as executive director. His volumes, Separate Church and State Now (1948), America's Way in Church, State, and Society (1953), and Baptists and the American Republic (1956) contributed markedly to Baptists' understanding of church and state. James Dunn James Dunn or Jim Dunn or Jimmy Dunn may refer to:
  • James Dunn (actor), (Bad Girl, A Tree Grows In Brooklyn)
  • James Dunn (hockey), Hockey Hall of Fame member
  • James Dunn (UK politician), formerly MP for Liverpool, Kirkdale
 reflected on Dawson's incredible significance: "[Dawson] was an understandable, visible and articulate spokesman for so many years. His voice was heard. His words were read. His presence was felt in the Baptist family for at least seventy-five years. That was almost 60 percent of the then history of the Southern Baptist Convention." (17) According to Dunn, "Dawson wrote virtually the only books written by any Southern Baptist in this period on ... separation of church and state." (18)

4. Truman and the Holy See. In their respective histories of the BJC, Stan Hastey and Pare Parry considered the Committee's opposition to the appointment of an ambassador to the Vatican to be the most time-consuming and important issue during Dawson's tenure. (19) In 1947, President Harry S. Truman For other persons named Harry Truman, see Harry Truman (disambiguation).
Harry S. Truman (May 8 1884 – December 26 1972) was the thirty-third President of the United States (1945–1953); as vice president, he succeeded to the office upon the death of Franklin D.
 assured Dawson and other Baptist leaders that he would recall the then-ambassador Myron S. Taylor from the Vatican. When Truman refused to follow through with that promise, Dawson launched a withering attack against the Baptist president. The controversy subsided when Ambassador Taylor voluntarily resigned. Despite another promise not to appoint a successor, Truman expressed his intention to tap General Mark Clark for the post. The Joint Committee responded by publishing a tract which began "an earthquake [that] shook the country when President Truman nominated a full ambassador to the Vatican." (20) Dawson publicly accused Truman of changing course "for political purposes, to get votes in the big industrial cities of North and East, not in the interest of the nation." (21) Apparently the Vatican objected to Clark because of his military background, and Clark withdrew. Truman left office without nominating another person for the post.

Although previously on cordial terms, and despite having worshiped together on occasion at First Baptist Church First Baptist Church may refer to many churches: Canada
  • First Baptist Church of Ottawa, Ontario, Canada
United States
  • First Baptist Church (Bay Minette, Alabama)
  • First Baptist Church (Greenville, Alabama)
 of Washington, D.C., the battle over the ambassador to the Vatican chilled the relationship between Dawson and Truman. "Truman apparently never forgave for·gave  
v.
Past tense of forgive.


forgave
Verb

the past tense of forgive

forgave forgive
 me, as a letter from the White House in my files would tend to substantiate," Dawson cryptically wrote in his autobiography. (22) After later seeking an appointment with Truman to discuss other matters, Dawson received a curt response from the president's secretary informing him that "no useful purpose could be served by the conference." (23) Thus, Dawson set the direction for the Committee's position on an issue that would surface periodically for the next fifty-plus years and established a precedent of speaking the truth to power no matter the politician's party or denomination.

5. Religious Liberty Abroad and the United Nations. Dawson left a powerful legacy in international religious liberty issues. In March 1945, he attended a conference in Cleveland held to flesh out the Dumbarton Oaks Accords for the formation of a "union of nations in behalf of peace." (24) In fact, he served as chairman of the conference's committee on religious liberty. John Foster Dulles Noun 1. John Foster Dulles - United States diplomat who (as Secretary of State) pursued a policy of opposition to the USSR by providing aid to American allies (1888-1959)
Dulles
 opposed Dawson's committee report favoring full religious liberty.

Undaunted, Dawson attended the United Nations organizational meeting in San Francisco. He carried to that meeting petitions of 100,000 Baptists asking that the proposed United Nations Charter include a guarantee of religious liberty for all. Dawson was not successful in having his proposed language included, but his efforts bore fruit two years later when the United Nations General Assembly adopted the Universal Declaration of Human Rights Universal Declaration of Human Rights

Declaration adopted by the United Nations General Assembly in 1948. Drafted by a committee chaired by Eleanor Roosevelt, it was adopted without dissent but with eight abstentions.
, recognizing the "freedom of thought, conscience and religion ... and freedom ... to manifest one's religion or belief in teaching, practice, worship and observance."

The Dawson years were filled with many other accomplishments. Stan Hastey noted that "during the Dawson years, the Joint Committee became a potent factor on the public scene and in Baptist life as well." Although acknowledging Dawson's sometimes "unnecessarily strong" statements against and in confrontation with Roman Catholics, Hastey concluded:
   [T]he years 1946 to 1953 were of crucial importance to the life of
   the new agency. The period was characterized by growth of influence
   and power both in Washington and within the Baptist constituency.
   The vital issues in the church-state field were faced squarely and
   courageously. Finally, ... the Baptist Joint Committee on Public
   Affairs won a number of most significant victories which would
   have no doubt been lost without its presence in Washington,
   D.C. (25)


I find it more difficult to identify James Dunn's five most significant contributions. Dunn served nearly two decades to Dawson's seven years, and I served with Dunn during his second decade at the Joint Committee, rendering my objectivity somewhat suspect.

As a general proposition, Dunn took seriously the First Amendment's protections for the free exercise of religion. This commitment to the First Amendment is ironic because Dunn is commonly regarded as an Establishment Clause hawk--fighting state-sponsored prayer and school vouchers. However, he devoted at least as much time arguing that church-state separation protected free exercise as he did advancing Establishment Clause values, and he put in the shoe leather to prove his point. Dunn's greatest accomplishment, however, was his ability to keep the agency alive and even thriving during the onslaught by and the divorce from the Southern Baptist Convention.

1. Prayer Pushers and Student Clubs. Shortly after Dunn arrived in Washington, Ronald Reagan proposed a school prayer amendment. The BJC vigorously opposed tinkering with the First Amendment to encourage government-sponsored prayer in schools, and Dunn accused the President of "despicable demagoguery Demagoguery
Hague, Frank

(1876–1956) corrupt mayor of Jersey City, N. J., for 30 years. [Am. Hist.: NCE, 1173]

Long, Huey P.

(1893–1935) infamous “Kingfish” of Louisiana politics. [Am. Hist.
" and playing "petty politics with prayer." (26)

In an effort to find an acceptable alternative to the prayer amendment, the Committee supported the practice of allowing students to gather voluntarily before and after school for prayer and other religious exercises in club meetings. In 1983, Senator Mark Hatfield (R-Ore.), a Baptist and a friend of Dunn's, introduced legislation in the Senate "to provide that it shall be unlawful to discriminate against any meetings of students in public secondary schools." After eighteen months of negotiations, this incipient legislation became the Equal Access Act of 1984, passing the Senate 88-11 and the House 337-77. The BJC, particularly its general counsel, John W. Baker, provided critical leadership in the bill's drafting and passage.

The BJC also helped develop guidelines to assist in the law's implementation and, in 1990, urged the Supreme Court to uphold its constitutionality. In Board of Education v. Mergens, 496 U.S. 226 (1990), the Court not only upheld the Equal Access Act but also interpreted its provisions broadly to strengthen its application in the public schools.

Dunn's leadership in the effort to pass the Equal Access Act and to defend it in court was important for several reasons. It indicated a strategic decision on his part not simply to say "no" to bad ideas but to say "yes" to a common sense, constitutionally acceptable alternative. He was right to criticize President Reagan and his school prayer amendment; and Dunn's credibility and effectiveness were heightened because he advanced a better idea. He also demonstrated the BJC's willingness to work with both sides of the aisle on Capitol Hill to promote religious liberty. In this effort, Dunn had worked with Republicans such as Hatfield and Democrats such as Carl Perkins of Kentucky. The project also demonstrated Dunn's courage to break from the typical coalition structures. In supporting the bill, the BJC worked with some erstwhile opponents, including the National Association of Evangelicals The National Association of Evangelicals (NAE) is an agency dedicated to coordinating cooperative ministry for evangelical denominations of Protestant Christians in the United States.  and Christian Legal Society The Christian Legal Society (CLS), founded in 1961, is a nonprofit organization of lawyers, judges, law professors, and law students. The group's missions are to promote high ethical standards within the legal profession, to support its members' commitment to Christian professional lives, , and the Committee was willing to fend off criticism from usual allies such as Jewish and civil liberties organizations who at first opposed the Equal Access Act. Finally, Dunn's and the BJC's leadership in equal access set the tone for future efforts to urge accommodation of students' exercise of religion in public schools while fighting state-sponsored prayer and religious exercise.

2. Peyote peyote (pāō`tē), spineless cactus (Lophophora williamsii), ingested by indigenous people in Mexico and the United States to produce visions.  and Anarchy. If Dunn's greatest achievement during the 1980s was the passage and defense of the Equal Access Act, his most significant legislative effort in the 1990s was the passage and defense of the Religious Freedom Restoration Act The Religious Freedom Restoration Act (, also known as RFRA) is a 1993 United States federal law aimed at preventing laws which substantially burden a person's free exercise of their religion.  of 1993 (RFRA RFRA Religious Freedom Restoration Act of 1993
RFra Rhine Franconian (linguistics) 
).

In April 1990, the Supreme Court dropped a constitutional bombshell that virtually destroyed the Free Exercise Clause. In the so-called Native American Peyote case, the Court's majority ruled that government would no longer be required to demonstrate a "compelling state interest" to justify burdening the free exercise rights of its citizens. As long as the law was facially neutral and generally applicable, a religious claimant has no right to an exemption. To do otherwise, according to Justice Scalia, would be to encourage "anarchy."

Recognizing the decision's devastating dev·as·tate  
tr.v. dev·as·tat·ed, dev·as·tat·ing, dev·as·tates
1. To lay waste; destroy.

2. To overwhelm; confound; stun: was devastated by the rude remark.
 effect on religious liberty, the BJC again spearheaded an effort to provide an appropriate legislative remedy. Led by then-general counsel Oliver S. Thomas, the Committee organized a broad and diverse coalition of religious and civil liberties groups to seek legislation that again would require government to show a compelling interest before it would be permitted to burden someone's exercise of religion. After more than three years of rigorous politicking, RFRA passed the House unanimously and the Senate 97-3 and was signed by President Bill Clinton in a Rose Garden ceremony on November 16, 1993.

As with equal access, the BJC defended RFRA's constitutionality in the Supreme Court. However, unlike equal access, the Court struck down the parts of RFRA that purported to bind the states. In turn, the BJC led efforts to pass additional legislation, finally succeeding with the adoption of the Religious Land Use and Institutionalized Persons Act The Religious Land Use and Institutionalized Persons Act, Pub.L. 106-274, 42 U.S.C.  2000cc-1 et seq. (RLUIPA) is a United States federal law that prohibits the imposition of burdens on the ability of prisoners to worship as they please, as well as making it easier  of 2000 under the leadership of then general counsel Melissa Rogers. RFRA, however, continues to ensure strong protection for religious liberty at the federal level, and comparable legislation and constitutional provisions provide the same protection at the state level. All of this, in Dunn's inimitable in·im·i·ta·ble  
adj.
Defying imitation; matchless.



[Middle English, from Latin inimit
 estimation, was to "add a little legislative Viagra" to the law of free exercise. (27)

3. Taxman! During Dunn's tenure, the BJC worked with the Internal Revenue Service to maintain tax exemption for religious organizations and to otherwise guard churches' autonomy against intrusive governmental regulation. The Committee chaired a group of attorneys from various religious organizations that met periodically with the commissioner of the Internal Revenue Service to discuss and resolve tax and tax exemption issues. For example, when President George H. W. Bush Editing of this page by unregistered or newly registered users is currently disabled due to vandalism.  proposed requiring churches to report to the IRS An abbreviation for the Internal Revenue Service, a federal agency charged with the responsibility of administering and enforcing internal revenue laws.  annual gifts of $500 or more, along with the donors' names and Social Security numbers, Dunn cried foul at the top of his lungs. The administration sheepishly sheep·ish  
adj.
1. Embarrassed, as by consciousness of a fault: a sheepish grin.

2. Meek or stupid.



sheep
 backed down. When the Senate Finance Committee proposed doing away with tax exemption for church pension and welfare boards, the BJC filed a statement protesting the change, maintaining that taxation of these boards would be tantamount to taxing churches. The proposal was defeated.

These efforts to protect the tax exemption and autonomy of churches went hand and glove Adv. 1. hand and glove - in close cooperation; "they work hand in glove"
cooperatively, hand in glove
 with Dunn's insistence that the best thing that government can do for religion is to leave it alone. The government should not give religious institutions money (grants or vouchers), but neither should the government take money away (through taxation).

4. International Religious Liberty. Following Dawson's precedent, Dunn understood that religious freedom was part and parcel of human rights abroad. During Dunn's tenure, the BJC insisted on legislation to end double taxation of missionaries in both the United States and their host countries, saving Baptist missionaries millions of dollars. Dunn prepared and personally handed to Secretary of State George Shultz a list of 116 prisoners of conscience in the then USSR USSR: see Union of Soviet Socialist Republics. . The State Department was successful in obtaining their release. The BJC also worked to ensure that military personnel in the First Gulf War were allowed to receive Bibles and other religious materials for their own use through the U.S. mail. The BJC sought and obtained amendments to the International Religious Freedom Act (1997) in order to ensure the rights of conscience for everyone, not just Christians. The BJC sponsored a conference at the historic Bloomsbury Central Baptist Church in London, in 1999, titled "Beyond Mere Toleration: Religious Liberty as a Basic Human Right," attracting speakers and attendees from twenty countries.

5. Battlin' Baptists. For all of Dunn's heroic work on issues and policy concerns, perhaps the most significant legacy was the ability to lead the BJC through the Southern Baptist controversy and to ensure that the Committee emerged as a healthy agency. The story of the fundamentalist takeover of the SBC (1) (SBC Communications Inc., San Antonio, TX, www.sbc.com) A large, national telecommunications company that grew from a multitude of local and regional companies, including Southwestern Bell, Pacific Bell and Nevada Bell, into a single, unified brand by 2002.  and its dispute with the BJC is well known. I will simply highlight several areas in which I judge Dunn's leadership to have been determinative in the outcome of that battle.

Some have suggested that had Dunn been more conciliatory con·cil·i·ate  
v. con·cil·i·at·ed, con·cil·i·at·ing, con·cil·i·ates

v.tr.
1. To overcome the distrust or animosity of; appease.

2.
, the rupture could have been avoided. Not so. Events have shown that the stakes were either a full-blown takeover or a divorce. The former did not happen; the latter did.

Although the SBC contributed about 60 percent of the BJC's financial support for 1988-1989, the SBC's Public Affairs Committee was never able to take over the agency. To maintain its "jointness," the BJC bylaws The rules and regulations enacted by an association or a corporation to provide a framework for its operation and management.

Bylaws may specify the qualifications, rights, and liabilities of membership, and the powers, duties, and grounds for the dissolution of an
 did and do not allow any one group to gain hegemony no matter how much it contributes. Thus, Southern Baptists had to curry alliances with other BJC bodies to seek a majority position. All-out efforts to take over the BJC failed in large measure because of Dunn's credibility and good will with other groups, such as the conservative Baptist General Conference and the Northern American Baptist Conference.

Dunn's leadership likewise ensured that draconian budget cuts through SBC defunding efforts would not sink the agency. Although the BJC budget was cut by more than half in 1990, Dunn provided leadership that led to the giving of replacement funds by the Cooperative Baptist Fellowship Cooperative Baptist Fellowship, Inc. (CBF)—"a fellowship of Baptist Christians and churches who share a passion for the Great Commission of Jesus Christ and a commitment to Baptist principles of faith and practice. , the Alliance of Baptists The Alliance of Baptists is a fellowship of Baptist churches and individuals espousing moderate-to-liberal theological and social stances. The Alliance was formed in 1987 by congregations in schism from the Southern Baptist Convention as a result of the 1980s , state Baptist conventions, and individual supporters. Significantly, no staff member was laid off because of these budget cuts.

Dunn also provided leadership to build a significant endowment to ensure the BJC's future. When Dunn arrived in 1981, the BJC had only $5,000 in the bank; when he retired, he left a $1,000,000 endowment. Much of the original corpus came from a delicately renegotiated settlement with the SBC by which the BJC received $180,000 from funds placed in the Southern Baptist Foundation in 1967 to be used by the BJC for capital purposes and expenses.

Bill Moyers, reflecting on Dunn's leadership during the SBC fight, said:
   Rarely have I witnessed such courage and perseverance as were
   exhibited by James Dunn.... He and the Baptist Joint Committee
   survived to fight another day, and another, and another,
   subsequently winning some of their most important victories in
   the continuing battle for religious liberty. What is his secret?
   He believes in a very big God. (28)


Conclusion

The often cited credo, "Bible in one hand, newspaper in the other," may have been a tad over used, but it aptly describes Dawson's and Dunn's biblically grounded social ethic and policy activism. As churchmen thoroughly steeped in Baptist heritage, they understood, as Dunn often has said, "You don't speak for Baptists. You speak to Baptists." Well, they spoke for many Baptists and to an entire culture in need of a prophetic witness as to the centrality of religious liberty and the indispensability of church-state separation. Those of us who carry on the fight stand on their broad Texas shoulders everyday.

(1.) James M. Dunn, Truth with the Bark on It: The Wit and Wisdom of James M. Dunn (Washington, D.C.: Baptist Joint Committee Staff Commemoration of Retirement, 1999), 13.

(2.) James M. Dunn, "The Baptist Vision of Religious Liberty," Walter B. Shurden, ed., Proclaiming the Baptist Vision Religious Liberty (Macon: Smyth & Helwys, 1997), 33.

(3.) Ibid.

(4.) Joseph Martin Dawson, "The Church and Religious Liberty," The Review, and Expositor, 50 (April, 1953): 148.

(5.) Ibid.

(6.) Ibid., 147.

(7.) James M. Dunn, The Ethical Thought of Joseph Martin Dawson (Th.D. dissertation, Southwestern Baptist Theological Seminary Southwestern Baptist Theological Seminary, headquartered in Fort Worth, Texas, is a private, non-profit institution of higher education, associated with the Southern Baptist Convention, whose stated mission is "to provide theological education for individuals engaging in Christian , 1966), 237.

(8.) James M. Dunn, "J. M. Dawson: Shaper of Public Affairs and Religious Liberty," Shapers of Southern Baptist Heritage (Nashville: The Historical Commission of the Southern Baptist Convention, 1987).

(9.) Joseph Martin Dawson, Baptists and the American Republic (Nashville: Broadman Press, 1956), 14.

(10.) Joseph Martin Dawson, A Thousand Months to Remember: An Autobiography (Waco: Baylor University Press, 1964), 257.

(11.) Joseph Martin Dawson, "Sanctifying the Secular," The Review, and Expositor, 47 (July, 1950): 304-09.

(12.) Dawson, Baptists and the American Republic, 13.

(13.) Joseph Martin Dawson, Separate Church and State Now (New York New York, state, United States
New York, Middle Atlantic state of the United States. It is bordered by Vermont, Massachusetts, Connecticut, and the Atlantic Ocean (E), New Jersey and Pennsylvania (S), Lakes Erie and Ontario and the Canadian province of
: Richard R. Smith, 1948), 91.

(14.) Dawson, Separate Church and State Now, 194.

(15.) Ibid., 195.

(16.) Ibid., 202.

(17.) Dunn, "J. M. Dawson: Shaper of Public Affairs."

(18.) Dunn, The Ethical Thought of Joseph Martin Dawson, 209.

(19.) See Stanley L. Hastey, A History of the Baptist Joint Committee on Public Affairs, 1946-1971 (Ph.D. diss diss  
v.
Variant of dis.


diss
Verb

Slang, chiefly US to treat (a person) with contempt [from disrespect]

Verb 1.
., Southern Baptist Theological Seminary References
External links
  • The Southern Baptist Theological Seminary
  • Archives Southern Baptist Seminary
  • Boyce College
  • SBTS Student and Faculty MetaBlog
  • Said At Southern, index of blogs and current events
, 1973); Pam Parry, On Guard for Religious Liberty: Six Decades of the Baptist Joint Committee (Macon, GA: Smyth & Helwys, 1996).

(20.) Hastey, A History of the Baptist Joint Committee, 87.

(21.) Dawson, A Thousand Months, 203.

(22.) Ibid.

(23.) Hastey, A History of the Baptist Joint Committee, 87.

(24.) Dawson, A Thousand Months, 160.

(25.) Hastey, A History of the Baptist Joint Committee, 102.

(26.) Dunn, Truth with the Bark on It, 24.

(27.) Ibid.

(28.) J. Brent Walker, James Dunn: Champion for Religious Liberty (Macon, GA: Smyth & Helwys, 1999), xiii.

J. Brent Walker is the executive director of the Baptist Joint Committee for Religious Liberty The Baptist Joint Committee for Religious Liberty (BJC) is an education and advocacy association in the United States with a number of Baptist denominations. It states that it seeks to promote religious liberty for all and to uphold the principle of church-state separation. , Washington, D.C.
COPYRIGHT 2006 Baptist History and Heritage Society
No portion of this article can be reproduced without the express written permission from the copyright holder.
Copyright 2006, Gale Group. All rights reserved. Gale Group is a Thomson Corporation Company.

 Reader Opinion

Title:

Comment:



 

Article Details
Printer friendly Cite/link Email Feedback
Author:Walker, J. Brent
Publication:Baptist History and Heritage
Date:Jun 22, 2006
Words:4792
Previous Article:Seven Things They Don't Teach You in Seminary: I recommend to you a book that has no intention of being a book on Christian history or Baptist...
Next Article:The rise, decline, and fall of Christian Life commission entities and voices.



Related Articles
Soul Freedom: Baptist Battle Cry.
The United States Field Artillery Association salutes our lifetime members!
Christian martyrs and religious liberty.
The United States Field Artillery Association salutes our lifetime members!(Illustration)
The United States Field Artiuery Association salutes our lifetime members.(Illustration)
Members of the 108th United States Congress.(Illustration)
The Trophy of Baptists: Words to Celebrate Religious Liberty.(Book Review)
Florida Rep. says church-state separation is 'a lie'.(Katherine Harris )(Brief article)
Baptist influence in the public arena: Baptists began as a small, oppressed movement in the American colonies, and Baptists became well-known and...

Terms of use | Copyright © 2009 Farlex, Inc. | Feedback | For webmasters | Submit articles