Attention deficit hyperactivity disorder in adults: review of an article.
Studies of patients with ADHD over their lifespan do show a decrease in hyperactivity in adults but with persistence of symptoms of attentional syndromes. Not unlike some children with ADHD, adults with ADHD tend to have "executive function" defects, which include organizational problems as well as difficulties with problem solving. Adults with ADHD tend to have difficulties with educational achievement and do best if their curriculum is structured. Academic problems continue to manifest themselves as underachievement in college. Frequently, there is a history of suspension of driver's licenses for DUI and other violations.
Although the diagnostic criteria may seem unduly cumbersome and numerous, it is important that they be adhered to because of the many different etiologies of this syndrome and actual misdiagnosis because of similarities to other diagnostic etiologies.
Diagnosis of ADHD requires a minimum of six symptoms listed in Section A1 (inattention) and Section A2 (hyperactivity and impulsivity) as well as all the symptoms listed in Sections B through E, according to DSM-IV.
Diagnostic Criteria for ADHD
For inattention, those symptoms are:
a. Often fails to give close attention to details or makes careless mistakes in school or other work
b. Often has difficulty paying close attention in games or other tasks
c. Often does not listen carefully
d. Often fails to complete schoolwork or other tasks
e. Has difficulty organizing tasks
f. Often has difficulty with tasks that require sustained activity
g. Often loses things necessary for activities or tasks
h. Is easily distracted
i. Is often forgetful in daily activities
For hyperactivity, those symptoms are:
a. Often fidgets with hands or feet
b. Often leaves seat in situations where remaining seating is expected
c. Often runs about where remaining still would be expected (or in adults excessive feelings of restlessness)
d. Often has difficulty engaging in leisure activities quietly
e. Often constantly "on the go"
f. Talks excessively
For impulsivity, those symptoms are:
a. Often blurts out answers before questions have been completed
b Often has difficulty awaiting one's turn
c. Often interrupts
Section B. Some hyperactive or inattentive criteria must have been present before age seven.
Section C. Some impairment from the symptoms must be present in at least two settings (e.g. school, home, work).
Section D. There must be clear evidence of clinically significant impairment in social, academic, or occupational functioning.
Section E. The symptoms do not occur exclusively during the course of a pervasive developmental disorder, or schizophrenia, or other psychotic disorder and are not better accounted for by another mental disorder (e.g. mood disorder, anxiety disorder, dissociative disorder or a personality disorder).
General Points Regarding Diagnosis
In determining the correct diagnosis, particularly in adults where ADHD may not be suspected, 15-20 percent of adults with substance abuse disorders, anxiety, depressive disorders, and bipolar disorders have ADHD. Conversely, in primary depression, anxiety, and dementia, cognitive defects which exist as part of the disorder might be misinterpreted as being secondary to ADHD. In the reviewer's experience, however (as well as the authors), the diagnosis of ADHD may be missed more often in the context of symptoms suggesting major depression, bipolar disorder, panic, and substance abuse.
Because of the difficulty in establishing the diagnosis of autism, a variety of scales and tests have been developed. Many of these are presented on this internet site: http://www.neurodiversity.com/diagnostic_instruments.html and can be utilized to improve diagnostic accuracy.
Genetic Susceptibility to ADHD in Adults
The genetic susceptibility to ADHD is about 70 percent in all age groups and is thought to be somewhat higher in adults with ADHD (reviewers note: this means that 70 percent of patients diagnosed with ADHD will have a positive family history and emphasizes the importance of a family history in adults who have ADHD as a possible basis of their symptoms as discussed above). Genetic studies of children and adults with ADHD have found evidence for the involvement of the D2 dopamine-receptor gene, the SNAP-25 and the D4 dopamine receptor gene. The D4 receptor gene associated with ADHD is important because of its association with the blunted response to norepinephrine and dopamine. Such a blunted response is part of the putative cause of ADHD.
The Influence of Perinatal Factors in the Incidence of ADHD
Since the publication of the article under review, a review published in the Mayo Clinic Proceedings (St. Sauver-2004) investigated the relationship between the characteristics of labor and delivery on the incidence of ADHD. The investigators found there was no relationship between such factors as length of labor, breech presentation, and breech delivery. In addition, they investigated the relationship between twinning and ADHD and found that none existed.
Brain Anomalies in Adults with ADHD
It has been known for some time that defects in tasks requiring vigilance, motoric inhibition, organization, planning, complex problem solving ability, verbal learning, and memory exist in children with ADHD. Recent studies have shown similar problems in adults with ADHD. The following points representing the current neurophysiological and neurological thinking underlying the above findings are as follows:
* defects in the cingulate cortex, which plays a role in motivational aspects of attention and in response selection and inhibition.
* a system mainly involving the right prefrontal and parietal cortex which is activated during sustained attention across different modalities is thought to be defective.
* the inferior parietal lobe and superior temporal sulcus, areas that provide a representation of extrapersonal space which plays an important role in focusing on a target stimulus, has been thought to be a factor.
* the reticular activating system and the reticular thalamic nuclei have also been implicated since they regulate attention (it is important, in the reviewer's opinion, to be familiar with the pathophysiology of ADHD because future therapeutic advances may be dependent on such knowledge, but the authors fail to provide information about whether such information is based on gross or micropathology, neuropsychological, or neurophysiological studies)
Neuroimaging studies, which are again compatible with a diagnosis of ADHD but not conclusively diagnostic, are as follows:
* smaller volumes in the frontal cortex, cerebellum, and subcortical structures.
* functional imaging systems suggest that fronto-cortical systems are part of the pathophysiology of ADHD. If the readers of this review (as does the reviewer) suggest that neuroimaging studies are compatible with ADHD but not diagnostic, these studies may be of value in determining the pathophysiology and future treatment possibilities for ADHD. Structures such as the caudate, putamen, and globus pallidus serve as inhibitors or modulators of behavior and have found to be abnormal. Such studies may also provide a means of determining the proper diagnosis of such patients. They (the functional varieties of MRI scans at any rate) are quite expensive, and the proper diagnosis may often be made in adults by at least considering it based on clinical criteria rather than resorting to an MRI. (reviewer's comment).
Treatment of ADHD
For accurate details regarding dosage and treatment alternatives, it is suggested that the reader refer to the original article. In general, the medications used to treat ADHD affect neurotransmission of catecholamines, including dopamine and norepinephrine. The categories of medications approved for adult use only include mixed amphetamine compounds and the noradrenergic specific reuptake inhibitor, atomoxetine. Other types of agents that have been approved for all age groups include antidepressants and cholinergic agents. The stimulant agents--amphetamine, methylphenidate, and pemoline--block the presynaptic reuptake of dopamine and norepinephrine in the synaptic cleft. Amphetamine releases dopamine and norepinephrine directly.
This is a valuable paper for clinicians (or their patients) interested in developmental disabilities primarily for two reasons: a) ADHD, which has been thought until recently to occur almost exclusively in children has now been shown to occur in a substantial number of adults. b) behavioral problems occur frequently in the context of developmental disabilities in adults and may occasionally be due to ADHD resulting from another developmental disability. Alternatively, the cause of the behavioral problems may actually be due to the "primary" developmental disability of unknown etiology as described above (or one of the other causes, such as drug abuse, as described in the article).
The clinical characteristics of ADHD in adults are somewhat different. The principal difference seems to be that a greater percentage of adults have the inattentive variety.
To what extent imaging is useful in actually making the diagnosis (except to rule out other causes of the patient's developmental disorder) is problematical except in the hands of an expert neuroradiologist. My personal opinion is that the patient's history is extremely valuable, particularly since there is a family history in 70 percent of patients.
It goes without saying that the value of a proper diagnosis to the patient is great since a proper diagnosis may require the use of a different category of medication (i.e stimulants) than would ordinarily be considered. Furthermore, dramatic results can be anticipated in a significant number of cases. It is particularly important to graph the patients daily progress based on objective parameters (such as the number of instances of inattentiveness or the degree of restlessness based on an objective scale).
Recent literature has emphasized an increase in the number of cases of ADHD in both children and adults, probably based on increased knowledge of diagnostic criteria. It is very important to rule out other conditions when making the diagnosis, whether it is a problem of a mistaken diagnosis or a comorbid condition. Examples include hyperthyroidism, central nervous system problems, and manic depressive or borderline conditions. It cannot be stressed too highly that since this is a disorder of eclectic etiology, patients may respond to different groups of medication so there may be some therapeutic trial and error involved.
Wilens T., Faraone S., Biederman J: Attention Deficit-Hyperactivity Disorder in Adults. JAMA 2004; 292:619-623.
For CME credit, read the editorial and the article and complete the Content Test and CME Evaluation Form at the end. Please read "Information and Instructions" following the article.
Specific learning objectives for this CME activity (please refer to general objectives).
Upon completion of the reading of this article the learner will be able to:
1. Appreciate the influence of family history in making the diagnosis of ADHD in adults.
2. Describe the criteria for making a DSM-IV-tr diagnosis of ADHD.
3. Describe the comorbid conditions, which complicate the diagnosis of ADHD in an adult.
Upon receipt and acceptance of the completed evaluation form/post-test, the AADMD CME Program will maintain on file a record for six years designating your credits earned. If you should need a written verification, contact Philip May, M.D. at 908-510-3062.
Continuing Medical Education Offered by The American Academy of Developmental Medicine & Dentistry Continuing Medical Education Program
INFORMATION AND INSTRUCTIONS
1. Overall program goal. The goal of the AADMD Continuing Medical Education Program (CMEP) is to improve the overall health of adults with neurodevelopmental disorders (mental retardation and other developmental disabilities) by enhancing the ability of primary care physicians and specialists to effectively evaluate and manage those complex health conditions that frequently occur in this patient population.
2. Target audience. Our educational activities are designed for primary care physicians and specialists whose practice consists of significant numbers of adults with neurodevelopmental disorders, such as those physicians who practice in State Developmental Centers, State Mental Health facilities, public or private Intermediate Care Facilities for the Mentally Retarded, Family Practice Clinics, and General Internal Medicine Clinics.
3. General learning objectives of the AADMD Northeastern Regional CME Program. Our educational/training programs are designed so that trainees will be better able to:
a. apply the concepts of the "Developmental Medicine Paradigm".
b. determine an accurate neurodevelopmental diagnosis
c. evaluate and manage cognitive dysfunction in adults with neurodevelopmental disorders.
d. evaluate and manage motor dysfunction in adults with neurodevelopmental disorders.
e. evaluate and manage seizure disorders in adults with neurodevelopmental disorders.
f. evaluate and manage behavior disorders of adults with neurodevelopmental disorders.
g. evaluate and manage syndrome-related conditions in adults with neurodevelopmental disorders.
h. evaluate and manage secondary health consequences of complications in adults with neurodevelopmental disorders.
i. effectively practice "care-coordination."
j. effectively work with families and other caregivers.
k. apply a data-driven medical decision-making process to clinical practice, known as Longitudinal Graphic Analysis (LGA).
4. Full disclosure policy affecting CME activities: As a sponsor of CME which is accredited by the Medical Society of NJ (MSNJ), it is the policy of the AADMD CME Program to require the full disclosure of the existence of any financial interest or other relationship an author, speaker, or co-sponsor has with the manufacturer(s) of any commercial product(s) or service(s) discussed in an educational activity.
The author of this article (Dr. Rapp) reports no financial or advisory relationships with corporate organizations related to this activity.
Costs of publication of this article, including graphic design, promotion, and distribution of this CME activity, have been contributed in-kind by EP Global Communications, Inc.
5. Accreditation statement: This activity was planned and implemented in accordance with the Essential Areas and Their Elements of the MSNJ-CME Accreditation Program. The AADMD CME Program is accredited by the MSNJ to sponsor continuing medical education for physicians.
6. Credit designation statement: The AADMD CME Program designates this activity for a maximum of 1.0 AMA PRA Category 1 Credit(s)[TM]. Physicians should only claim credits commensurate with the extent of their participation in the activity.
The estimated maximum time to complete this activity: 1.0 hour.
7. Disclaimer statement: Disclaimer Statement: The opinions and recommendations expressed by authors/contributors are their own. This journal article is produced for educational purposes only. Use of the AADMD CME Program name implies review of educational format design and approach. The AAMDD is not itself responsible for statements made by any contributor. Statements or opinions expressed in the AADMD Reviews and Reports reflect the views of the author(s) and not the official policy of the Academy unless so stated. The Academy does not endorse any of the advertising that appears in the body of EP magazine nor does it receive any compensation from EP advertising revenues. Any financial support provided to the AADMD CME Program will be designated and clearly identified as such. Material printed by the Academy is copyrighted by the American Academy of Developmental Medicine and Dentistry and EP Global Communications, Inc. No part of this publication may be reproduced or transmitted in any form without written permission from both organizations.
8. Instructions: Physicians who read specific articles designated for CME credit in this issue of the AADMD Developmental Medicine and Dentistry Reviews & Reports can complete the CME evaluation form for AMA Physicians Recognition Award credit. To earn credit you must read the entire article(s) and then successfully (minimum 70% correct answers) complete both the Content Test and the CME Evaluation Form located following the article(s). Mail the documents to:
American Academy of Developmental Medicine and Dentistry
CME Program, PO Box 5220
Clinton, NJ 08809
Disclaimer Statement: The opinions and recommendations expressed by authors/contributors are their own. This journal article is produced for educational purposes only. Use of the AADMD Northeastern Regional CME Program name implies review of educational format design and approach.
NEDD RAPP, M.D, PENN VALLEY, PENNSYLVANIA