Printer Friendly
The Free Library
19,595,263 articles and books
Member login
User name  
Password 
 
Join us Forgot password?

Antonio, age five, is labelled obese; MUMS' FURY AT LETTERS BRANDING 'HEALTHY' CHILDREN FAT.


Byline: JOANNE BUTCHER

FIVE-YEAR-OLD Antonio Coates looks a picture of health as he enjoys the swings at his local park - but he and a school pal have been labelled fat by the NHS NHS
abbr.
National Health Service


NHS (in Britain) National Health Service
.

Now their angry mums have hit out at health chiefs after receiving letters telling them their children would be regarded as obese by doctors.

Beth Coates and Jeri Kariuki say the letters, which placed the boys in a category doctors would call "clinically obese", were an insult.

And they warned parents could feel forced to starve healthy kids to meet Government figures.

Antonio and best pal Best Pal (born February 12, 1988 in Ramona, California - died November 24, 1998 in Ramona, California) was a champion racehorse, who to this day holds the record for purses of any California-bred racehorse, earning his owners, the Golden Eagle Farm, US$5.  Carl Kariuki, also five, were weighed and measured with classmates at Greenfields Primary School in Wide Open, North Tyneside North Tyneside is a metropolitan borough of Tyne and Wear in the North East of England. Its seat is at the Town Hall, Wallsend.

Created in 1974, the borough lies within the historic county boundaries of Northumberland.
.

It was part of the NHS's National Child Measurement Programme, which checks kids across the country to monitor rising obesity levels.

At 3st 10lb and 3st 9lb respectively, the youngsters fell into the "very overweight" and "overweight" categories.

A letter explained they would be classed as "clinically obese" by doctors, and warned of possible health risks including heart problems, high blood pressure and diabetes.

Furious mum Beth, of Dudley, near Cramlington, was shocked to be told her son needed to lose a stone in weight.

She said: "Antonio is normal. He is not obese, nothing close to it. It is a load of rubbish."

"He eats fresh food, doesn't snack, and is always running around with his friends.

"Working out the BMI BMI body mass index.

BMI
abbr.
body mass index


Body mass index (BMI)
A measurement that has replaced weight as the preferred determinant of obesity.
 of children is ridiculous as their bodies are constantly changing."

Beth, a social services social services
Noun, pl

welfare services provided by local authorities or a state agency for people with particular social needs

social services nplservicios mpl sociales 
 administrator, added: "It's shocking they said this to me in a letter.

"Any issues should have been raised through an appointment with a doctor or health visitor."

And she feared other parents of supposedly "fat" kids might put them on dangerous diets.

She said: "If I wasn't stronger in myself I might decide I was doing something wrong and deny Antonio food. It could give children serious eating disorders.

"I know what it is like to be fat, I used to be overweight and I changed that by healthy eating.

"I don't want Antonio thinking he is obese when he is not."

Jeri, 50, said she was disgusted health professionals got it so wrong.

"I am disregarding their advice," said the mum, from Wide Open. "But how will I know whether to take them seriously the next time they tell me something about my son? "Carl eats healthy organic food, and he does a lot of exercise. He has a trampoline trampoline

Resilient sheet or web (often of nylon) supported by springs in a metal frame and used as a springboard and landing area in tumbling. Trampolining is an individual sport of acrobatic movements performed after rebounding into the air from the trampoline.
 and he goes to football training.

In a joint statement, North Tyneside Primary Care Trust and North Tyneside Council said: "We are really sorry if any child or parent has been upset by this programme.

"Being overweight is an increasing problem across the country and in North Tyneside we are working closely with the council to address this.

"We measure children aged five and eleven and write to parents to share this information and offer advice and support.

"We would be very happy to talk to parents and re-measure their children."

CAPTION(S):

THAT'S MY BOY: Beth fears the letters sent out could encourage unhealth y diets PUSHED TOO FAR: Antonio Coates and mum Beth who are unhappy at Antonio being labelled "very overweight" by the NHS
COPYRIGHT 2009 MGN Ltd.
No portion of this article can be reproduced without the express written permission from the copyright holder.
Copyright 2009 Gale, Cengage Learning. All rights reserved.

 Reader Opinion

Title:

Comment:



 

Article Details
Printer friendly Cite/link Email Feedback
Publication:Evening Chronicle (Newcastle, England)
Date:Jul 24, 2009
Words:542
Previous Article:Harper skipper role on cards.
Next Article:How the BMI index works.
Topics:

Terms of use | Copyright © 2012 Farlex, Inc. | Feedback | For webmasters | Submit articles