Printer Friendly
The Free Library
14,734,713 articles and books
Member login
User name  
Password 
 
Join us Forgot password?

And that's the truth.


Wipe away that political grime with The Pledge!

CALIFORNIA IS THE LAST GREAT American frontier, bordering, as it does, on reality. And as one of its few indigenous citizens old enough to have resisted the temptation to vote for Nixon, I am proud to report that the Golden State is again setting the pace in yet another space-age invention: political ethics.

Organic chemists have discovered the cure for centuries of public sophistry soph·is·try  
n. pl. soph·is·tries
1. Plausible but fallacious argumentation.

2. A plausible but misleading or fallacious argument.


sophistry
Noun

1.
 cultivated in the rich California soil. In fact, if you'll excuse the expression, it was grafted onto the current campaign when would-be governor Kathleen Brown Kathleen Brown (born 15 October 1946) is Democratic politician from California. She is the daughter of former Governor Pat Brown and the sister of California Attorney General Jerry Brown (also a former Governor of California).  challenged her rivals to sign a document indicating--and I quote--"We pledge to be honest."

Ms. Brown, the Democratic state controller, has crafted a remarkably discerning lie detector test lie detector test n. a popular name for a polygraph which tests the physiological reaction of a person to questions asked by a testing expert. A potential or actual criminal defendant or possible witness cannot be forced or ordered to take a lie detector test. . To casual voters, it appears that once politicians courageously commit to telling the truth in signed and notarized statements, they will be less tempted to shade the facts. Yet, since liars are not deterred in the slightest by a pledge to be truthful, they are happy to do so publicly. Indeed, they welcome the opportunity to put another layer of paperwork between their embellishments and the plain truth.

In short, the righteous man is insulted by such a charade and denounces the essential dishonesty of which such a vacuous public exhibition smacks. The crook exclaims, "Where do I sign?"

SOME OF THE LITTLE PEOPLE SEEM TO be picking up on this logic, but only in crude ways. Many patriotic Americans now find a politico who openly admits to dishonesty to be refreshingly candid. Hence, when Col. Ollie North proudly tells his legions that he lied to Congress in order to protect American lives, he is given a thunderous standing-O. His people gush over a man who would rise above the cads and charlatans in Washington to be honest and forthright about his mendacities.

There are variations on this theme. The White House has a phalanx phalanx, ancient Greek formation of infantry. The soldiers were arrayed in rows (8 or 16), with arms at the ready, making a solid block that could sweep bristling through the more dispersed ranks of the enemy.  of apologists who argue with conviction that, from day one, Mr. William Jefferson William Jefferson can refer to more than one person.
  • William J. Jefferson, Louisiana Democratic congressman
  • Will Jefferson, English cricketer
See also:
  • William Jefferson Clinton, better known as Bill Clinton, U.S.
 Clinton had to bluff the common folk with loose talk about middle-class tax cuts and free health care. If he hadn't, then he, otherwise a man of virtue, could not have remained electorally competitive. Had it been up to him alone, Mr. Clinton would have told us the "honest truth" (as opposed to the slicker sort, in which he is clearly a consensus All-American). But in an age in which people don't want to hear what they need to, maybe the "dishonest truth" is a necessary evil.

Ms. Brown, a gifted campaigner who is as smooth before the cameras as her brother Jerry is spacey spac·ey  
adj. Slang
Variant of spacy.

Adj. 1. spacey - stupefied by (or as if by) some narcotic drug
spaced-out, spacy

unconventional - not conventional or conformist; "unconventional life styles"
, ingeniously issued the "honesty pledge" challenge to both of her acknowledged rivals, Democratic Insurance Commissioner John Garamendi John Raymond Garamendi (born January 24, 1945) is a U.S. politician and a member of the Democratic Party. He became the 46th Lieutenant Governor of California on January 8 2007.  and Republican Gov. Pete Wilson For others named Pete Wilson, see .
Peter Barton Wilson (born August 23, 1933) is an American Republican politician from California. Wilson served as the thirty-sixth Governor of California (1991–1999), the culmination of more than three decades in the public arena that
. The cute trick was that she actually had a third major competitor--Democratic state Sen. Tom Hayden Thomas Emmett "Tom" Hayden (born December 11, 1939) is an American social and political activist and politician, most famous for his involvement in the anti-war and civil rights movements of the 1960s. . She strategically elected to ignore the radical Fonda-Hayden because the publicity would constitute a nuisance on Ms. Brown's left flank. Hence, she clearly signaled that lying by omission was no violation of the honesty pledge.

Further innovations of the Brown campaign were its "no negative ad" pledge and a vow to air television commercials only along the lines of an "honest and issue-oriented campaign." Of course, among the greatest issues in any campaign are the competency and integrity of one's opponent. In the context of an either-or choice, any factor which is pro one candidate is by definition anti another. Yet to be honestly straightforward about this is to be "negative."

CLEVERLY ENOUGH, BROWN'S ENTIRE pledge-taking challenge was a preemptive pre·emp·tive or pre-emp·tive  
adj.
1. Of, relating to, or characteristic of preemption.

2. Having or granted by the right of preemption.

3.
a.
 negative attack on her opponents. Her message to voters was that her opponents were such vile bottom-feeders that she had to set some civilized ground rules on behalf of common decency. Having gotten in this below-the-belt shot, it is no wonder she'd like to call it quits on all that "negative" campaigning.

For their part, Brown's challengers have been exceedingly reluctant to get sucked into any sort of "honesty pledge." This is not due to any genuine disgust over disingenuousness. They object to signing off on their opponent's pledge, thus giving the impression that it is a real deal. That would be dishonest and, far worse, bad politics. Instead, they have taken the opportunity afforded to viciously counter-attack Brown's subtext sub·text  
n.
1. The implicit meaning or theme of a literary text.

2. The underlying personality of a dramatic character as implied or indicated by a script or text and interpreted by an actor in performance.
. They have responded with all guns blazing, characterizing her as one who has engaged in malicious personal denigrations to attain high public office, including her current one. That she has issued such an "honesty pledge" challenge, claim Democratic and Republican foes alike, is an indication of just how far she'll go to deceive the people.

H. L. Mencken once noted that every philosopher spent his whole day proving that every other philosopher was an ass, and--what was more--always did it successfully. This may explain why I am so easily convinced when candidates call each other liars. Especially when they've taken the "honesty pledge."

Contributing Editor A contributing editor is a magazine job title that varies in responsibilities. Most often, a contributing editor is a freelancer who has proven ability and readership draw.  Thomas W. Hazlett teaches economics and public policy at the University of California, Davis The University of California, Davis, commonly known as UC Davis, is one of the ten campuses of the University of California, and was established as the University Farm in 1905. .
COPYRIGHT 1994 Reason Foundation
No portion of this article can be reproduced without the express written permission from the copyright holder.
Copyright 1994, Gale Group. All rights reserved. Gale Group is a Thomson Corporation Company.

 Reader Opinion

Title:

Comment:



 

Article Details
Printer friendly Cite/link Email Feedback
Title Annotation:Selected Skirmishes; politicians making pledges of honest behavior
Author:Hazlett, Thomas W.
Publication:Reason
Article Type:Column
Date:Jun 1, 1994
Words:836
Previous Article:What Went Right in the 1980s.
Next Article:Persecution complex. (religion in the workplace) (Editorial)
Topics:



Related Articles
What is bothering me. (honesty and partisanship in journalistic writing) (Column)
Action Committee calls for action on taxes. (Action Committee for Reasonable Real Estate Taxes; New York)
Riot response: an innovative approach.
The trust gap.(lack of trust in politicians in Canada)
Re: Clinton & Lewinsky. (sex scandal involving Pres Bill Clinton and Monica Lewinsky)
PUBLIC FORUM : SIMI POLICE WERE RIGHT TO ROUST BIKERS.(NEWS)
Ethics in the workplace; The best strategy: start with honesty with others.
EDITORIAL POLITICIZING 9-11 TERRORIST ATTACKS SHADOW AMERICA'S POLITICS.(Editorial)(Editorial)
Honesty at heart of recovery.(Columns)(Column)

Terms of use | Copyright © 2009 Farlex, Inc. | Feedback | For webmasters | Submit articles