Adjacent segment degeneration following spinal fusion for degenerative disc disease.Fusion has become the standard of care for numerous pathologic conditions of the spine over the past 50 years. Instrumented thoracolumbar thoracolumbar /tho·ra·co·lum·bar/ (-lum´bar) pertaining to thoracic and lumbar vertebrae.
1. Of or relating to the thoracic and lumbar parts of the spinal column. fusion for adolescent and adult spinal deformity has enjoyed great success in arresting the progression of and correcting scoliotic sco·li·ot·ic
Of, relating to, or affected by scoliosis. deformity. In the cervical spine cervical spine Clinical anatomy The region of the vertebral column encompassing C1 through C7 , decompression and fusion have provided a greater than 90% likelihood of relieving radicular symptoms and stabilizing or improving myelopathy myelopathy /my·elop·a·thy/ (mi?e-lop´ah-the)
1. any functional disturbance and/or pathological change in the spinal cord; often used to denote nonspecific lesions, as opposed to myelitis.
2. . (1,2) Decompression and posterolateral fusion of the lumbar spine Lumbar spine
The segment of the human spine above the pelvis that is involved in low back pain. There are five vertebrae, or bones, in the lumbar spine.
Mentioned in: Low Back Pain have been shown to be the superior form of surgical management for degenerative spondylolisthesis spondylolisthesis /spon·dy·lo·lis·the·sis/ (-lis´the-sis) forward displacement of a vertebra over a lower segment, usually of the fourth or fifth lumbar vertebra due to a developmental defect in the pars interarticularis. in prospective randomized studies. (3) Given the high clinical success recognized in using fusion for deformity and stenosis of the cervical and lumbar spine, the long-term sequelae sequelae Clinical medicine The consequences of a particular condition or therapeutic intervention of these procedures has been considered of secondary importance. However, as spinal fusion is being performed on younger patients and as the rates of cervical and lumbar spine surgery have increased over the past two decades, (4) concern regarding the effect on adjacent motion segments has been increasing. Furthermore, as indications for fusion have expanded to include mechanical back and neck pain with more variable success rates, concern for adjacent segment degeneration has been amplified.
Adjacent level degeneration, following cervical, lumbar, and lumbosacral fusions, has been well documented in recent literature, yet there remains considerable controversy as to when adjacent level radiographic radiographic (rā´dēōgraf´ik),
adj relating to the process of radiography, the finished product, or its use. degeneration becomes clinically relevant. (5-9) It has also become evident that maintenance of sagittal sagittal /sag·it·tal/ (saj´i-t'l)
1. shaped like an arrow.
2. situated in the direction of the sagittal suture; said of an anteroposterior plane or section parallel to the median plane of the body. alignment of the spine has important clinical implications when treating and preventing adjacent segment degeneration and flat back syndrome. (10,11) Numerous studies have demonstrated in properly selected patients that decompression and fusion can yield marked improvement with respect to pain and outlook for various conditions of the spine. (12-16) However, there are also numerous articles that suggest otherwise, with the results of spinal fusion described as unpredictable, if not unsatisfactory, and often precipitating further surgical intervention. (17,18) It is important, therefore, to understand the long-term consequences of cervical, lumbar, and lumbosacral fusions, and their impact on adjacent segment degeneration.
Clinical Evidence of Adjacent Segment Disease
Radiographic evidence of adjacent level degeneration in the cervical spine has been documented. Katsuura and colleagues noted degenerative changes evident on radiological examination in levels adjacent to a fused segment in 21 of 42 (50%) patients, following anterior cervical interbody fusion, at 9.8 years average follow-up. (19) Goffin and associates reported on 181 patients treated by anterior cervical interbody fusion with an average follow-up of greater than 8 years. Patients were clinically and radiologically examined by independent investigators who reported mild radiologic deterioration at adjacent levels in 92% of cases studied and moderate to severe changes in 43% of cases. (20) The severity of radiographic changes was associated with the time interval since surgery. However, radiographic adjacent segment degeneration was not correlated with clinical symptoms.
Herkowitz and coworkers studied 44 patients with cervical radiculopathy randomized to anterior discectomy disc·ec·to·my
The partial or complete excision of an intervertebral disk. Also called discotomy. and fusion versus posterior foraminotomy with 4.5 years follow-up. Forty-one percent of those undergoing anterior fusion developed adjacent level radiographic degeneration. Interestingly, 50% of those undergoing foraminotomy without fusion developed radiographic adjacent segment changes as well. As in the previously cited studies, no correlation was reported between radiographic degeneration and clinical symptoms. (21)
Several investigators have attempted to evaluate the prevalence of clinically significant adjacent segment degeneration. In a long-term follow-up study evaluating clinically relevant adjacent level degeneration following cervical spinal fusion, Hilibrand and colleagues demonstrated that symptomatic adjacent segment disease may affect more than one-fourth of all patients within ten years after cervical arthrodesis arthrodesis /ar·thro·de·sis/ (-de´sis) the surgical fixation of a joint by a procedure designed to accomplish fusion of the joint surfaces by promoting the proliferation of bone cells; called also artificial ankylosis. , as defined by the presence of new radiculopathy or myelopathy referable to an adjacent motion segment. The study demonstrated an annual incidence of approximately 2.9% of symptomatic disease following the index procedure. A single-level arthrodesis involving the fifth or sixth cervical vertebra vertebra /ver·te·bra/ (ver´te-brah) pl. ver´tebrae [L.] any of the 33 bones of the vertebral (spinal) column, comprising 7 cervical, 12 thoracic, 5 lumbar, 5 sacral, and 4 coccygeal vertebrae . and preexisting radiographic evidence of degeneration at adjacent levels appeared to be the greatest risk factors for new disease. Surprisingly, the study demonstrated that the risk of new disease at an adjacent level was significantly lower following a multilevel arthrodesis than following a single-level arthrodesis. (22) The investigators hypothesized that this finding may have been due to the inclusion of at-risk motion segments in the index procedure.
Yue and associates evaluated clinical and radiologic outcomes at an average of 7.2 years following anterior cervical discectomy and fusion Anterior cervical discectomy and fusion (ACDF) is a common surgical procedure to treat nerve root or spinal cord compression by decompressing the spinal cord and nerve roots of the cervical spine in order to stabilize the corresponding vertebrae. . In this series, 12 of 71 patients (16.9%) required second procedures for symptomatic adjacent level disease at an average of 41.8 months following the index procedure. (23) In a similar study, Ishihara and coworkers determined an incidence of symptomatic adjacent segment disease of 19% of 112 patients studied. Symptoms developed at an average of 6.5 years following the index procedure. Of those patients who developed symptomatic adjacent level disease, 37% failed nonoperative treatment and required additional operations. Keplan-Meier survival analysis determined a disease-free survival of 89% at 5 years, 84% at 10 years, and 67% at 17 years. Disc protrusion protrusion /pro·tru·sion/ (-troo´zhun)
1. extension beyond the usual limits, or above a plane surface.
2. the state of being thrust forward or laterally, as in masticatory movements of the mandible. at the adjacent level demonstrated on preoperative pre·op·er·a·tive
Preceding a surgical operation.
preceding an operation.
the preparation of a patient before operation. myelography Myelography Definition
Myelography is an x-ray examination of the spinal canal. A contrast agent is injected through a needle into the space around the spinal cord to display the spinal cord, spinal canal, and nerve roots on an x ray. or magnetic resonance imaging magnetic resonance imaging (MRI), noninvasive diagnostic technique that uses nuclear magnetic resonance to produce cross-sectional images of organs and other internal body structures. (MRI 1. (application) MRI - Magnetic Resonance Imaging.
2. MRI - Measurement Requirements and Interface. ), was associated with development of adjacent level disease. (24) Based on these studies, the incidence of radiographic adjacent segment degeneration in the cervical spine is estimated to be between 5% and 9% per year. However, symptomatic adjacent segment disease appears to occur at a rate of 2% to 3% per year following anterior cervical discectomy and fusion.
The subaxial cervical spine, where most fusion procedures are performed, is bordered by a highly mobile upper cervical region that provides nearly half of all cervical motion. Numerous biomechanical studies examining the effects of arthrodesis on adjacent levels have been reported although none have utilized a model which includes the upper cervical region. Eck and colleagues performed a biomechanical study using cadaveric ca·dav·er
A dead body, especially one intended for dissection.
[Middle English, from Latin cad cervical spine specimens. The investigators demonstrated significant increases in intradiscal pressure and segmental motion adjacent to a fused segment during normal ranges of motion. They surmised that these changes could partially explain the mechanism of early disc degeneration within the cervical spine. (25) Further studies have substantiated these observations, demonstrating increased stress responses in adjacent levels. (26-29) Lopez-Espina and associates noted a 96% increase in stresses at the nucleus, annulus annulus /an·nu·lus/ (an´u-lus) pl. an´nuli [L.] anulus.
an·nu·lus or an·u·lus
n. pl. an·nu·lus·es or an·nu·li
A circular or ring-shaped structure. , and endplate of levels adjacent to fused cervical motion segments, utilizing finite element analysis Finite element analysis (FEA) is a computer simulation technique used in engineering analysis. It uses a numerical technique called the finite element method (FEM). There are many finite element software packages, both free and proprietary. in a cadaveric model. Increased adjacent level stresses were noted following two-level fusions when compared to single-level. (29) Whether increased stress at motion segments adjacent to arthrodeses is above a clinically relevant threshold is unknown.
Clinical Evidence of Adjacent Segment Disease
There is substantial reporting in the literature regarding the development of adjacent level disease following lumbar fusions. Many investigators have reported their clinical series and demonstrated conflicting results. Lehmann and coworkers, did a retrospective study of 62 patients at a mean of 33 years following lumbar fusion, and they noted segmental instability above the fusion in 45% of patients in whom follow-up radiographs were available. Fifty-seven percent of patients reported episodes of back pain in the previous year and 53% required pain medication. However, radiographic deterioration of the adjacent segment did not correlate with symptoms. (17)
In an attempt to determine the etiology of adjacent level degeneration, some investigators have sought to delineate those distinguishing risk factors that are inherent either within the patients or the surgery. Etebar and Cahill performed a retrospective analysis on 125 consecutive patients who had undergone lumbar fusion with rigid instrumentation for degenerative instability at an average of four-years follow-up. A total of 18 of 125 patients (14%) developed symptomatic adjacent segment degeneration at a previously asymptomatic level, 15 of whom were postmenopausal post·men·o·paus·al
Of or occurring in the time following menopause.
postmenopausal Change of life Gynecology adjective Referring to the time in ♀ when menstrual periods stop for ≥ 1 yr females (83%). The investigators concluded that the risk of adjacent segment degeneration is higher for patients with rigid instrumentation performed to treat degenerative instability, and that this risk appears to be particularly high in postmenopausal females. (30)
In a study evaluating the long-term clinical and radiologic results of anterior lumbar interbody fusion (ALIF) for isthmic spondylolisthesis, Ishihara and colleagues included 23 patients who were followed for more than 10 years (average, 13.3 years). Radiographs demonstrated new adjacent disc degeneration in 52% in the upper adjacent level and in 70% of cases in the lower adjacent level at final follow-up; rates of 4% and 5% per year occurred, respectively. (31) Magnetic resonance images of 11 patients at final follow-up demonstrated 73% prevalence of intervertebral intervertebral /in·ter·ver·te·bral/ (-ver´te-bral) situated between two contiguous vertebrae; see under disk.
Located between vertebrae. disc degeneration in the upper adjacent levels and 100% in the lower adjacent level. Penta and associates performed a radiologic study to evaluate the relationship between adjacent level disease and fusion length. (32) Using plain films and MRI at the ten-year follow-up, the investigators studied 52 patients who, preoperatively, demonstrated a normal disc above the intended level of fusion. The study found that 32% of these 52 patients had degenerative changes and that this percentage was not influenced by the length of the fusion.
In a recent retrospective study of 215 patients who underwent posterior lumbar arthrodesis, with an average follow-up of 6.7 years, Ghiselli and coworkers identified 59 (27.4%) patients who required additional decompression or fusion at the adjacent level. Kaplan-Meier survivorship survivorship n. the right to receive full title or ownership due to having survived another person. Survivorship is particularly applied to persons owning real property or other assets, such as bank accounts or stocks, in "joint tenancy. analysis predicted a disease-free survival rate of 83.5% at five years and 63.9% at ten years following the index procedure. No significant correlation was found between preoperative arthritic grade and the need for additional surgery. (33)
One theory ascribes these adjacent segment degenerative changes to the natural history of the degenerative disease process. The aforementioned study by Penta and colleagues reported that degenerative changes following spinal fusion were not related to the length of fusion. From this, they hypothesized that degeneration following lumbar interbody fusion is determined more by the degenerative disease process than by the fusion itself. (32) The opposing biomechanical theory attributes early degenerative changes to the relative hypermobility of the adjacent motion segment and the increased stresses placed on the adjacent discs, endplates, and facets. (34,35)
There are numerous biomechanical studies that have investigated the effects of lumbar spine fusions on adjacent levels. Most of these studies test the hypothesis that fusion of one level will cause an associated transference of load to its adjacent level. Using roentgen roentgen /roent·gen/ (rent´gen) the international unit of x- or ?-radiation; it is the quantity of x- or ?-radiation such that the associated corpuscular emission per 0. stereophotogrammetric analysis, Axelsson and associates demonstrated that fusion of the lumbosacral spine altered the kinematics of the adjacent segments, redistributing mobility toward the juxtafused segments.36 Alteration in the biomechanics of the adjacent motion segment was evaluated by Weinhoffer and associates in an in vitro study that demonstrated intradiscal pressures increased within adjacent levels as flexion flexion /flex·ion/ (flek´shun) the act of bending or the condition of being bent.
1. The act of bending a joint or limb in the body by the action of flexors.
2. motion increased. An increase in pressure was shown to directly correlate with the number of levels fused. (37)
It has been theorized that an increase in intradiscal pressure predisposes a motion segment to disc deterioration and spondylotic degeneration. In a lumbar cadaveric experiment, Chow and coworkers confirmed hypermobility and an increase in intradiscal pressures of adjacent segments following fusion, but they questioned whether or not the neighboring unfused segments were loaded beyond their physiological limits. (5) In a radiologic study evaluating this transference of stress, Frymoyer and colleagues noted a compensatory increase in the range of lumbar motion in adjacent levels following lumbar fusions using flexion-extension radiographs. (16)
Correlation Between Radiographic Degeneration and Clinical Disease
The clinical correlation of radiologic adjacent level degeneration remains a topic of controversy. The clinical relevance of radiographic degenerative changes and the corroborating biomechanical evidence attempting to demonstrate causality is unclear. Further clouding the issue is the presence of degenerative changes in completely asymptomatic patients. (38) Boden and associates' classic article noted abnormal findings on approximately 57% of lumbar magnetic resonance scans in asymptomatic patients aged 60 years or older.
Surprisingly, there was degeneration or disc bulging involving at least one lumbar level in 35% of subjects between 20 and 39 years of age, and in all but one of the 60-to 80-year-old asymptomatic subjects. (6) In a similar study, Boden and coworkers performed cervical MRI scans on 63 asymptomatic individuals and found disc degeneration or narrowing at one or more levels in 25% of subjects less than 40 years of age and in nearly 60% of those older than forty. (39)
The following studies fail to reveal a high degree of clinical correlation with postoperative radiologic adjacent segment deterioration. Guigui and colleagues reported on 102 patients who underwent posterolateral single-level lumbar fusion. Degenerative changes were present radio-graphically in at least 49% of patients at an average of 8.9 years follow-up. However, only eight of these patients with radiographic changes had symptoms warranting further surgical management. (40) In the study of Ishihara and associates, who evaluated anterior lumbar interbody fusion for isthmic spondylolisthesis, degenerative changes were reported in up to 70% of adjacent levels. However, no evidence of clinical deterioration was found throughout their ten-year follow-up. In cases of nonunion, they found that JOA (Japanese Orthopaedic Association) scores gradually worsened with time, but overall results did not differ from those patients who did achieve union. (31)
Kumar and coworkers performed a long-term study with minimum 30-year follow-up, comparing a cohort of 28 patients treated with a posterior mid-line fusion for degenerative disc disease Degeneration of the intervertebral disc, which is often called "degenerative disc disease" (DDD) of the spine, is a common disorder of the lower spine and for some people can cause low back pain and/or leg pain (sciatica). to 28 patients treated for degenerative disc disease without fusion. The incidence of radiographic deterioration at levels adjacent to the fused segment was twice as high in the fusion group as in the nonfusion group. However, no statistically significant difference was found between the two groups in clinical outcome measures and functional testing. (41)
There are few articles that specifically detail the clinical outcomes of symptomatic adjacent segment breakdown. Lee documented 18 patients in whom new symptoms developed that were associated with the segment adjacent to a fusion after an average symptom-free interval of 8.5 years (range: 1-38 years). The most common pathologic condition at the adjacent segment was hypertrophic Hypertrophic
Mentioned in: Heart Failure
characterized by a state of hypertrophy.
hypertrophic pulmonary osteoarthropathy
see hypertrophic osteopathy. degenerative arthritis of the facet joints. (42) Schlegel and associates analyzed 58 new patients who developed spinal stenosis, disc herniation herniation /her·ni·a·tion/ (her?ne-a´shun) abnormal protrusion of an organ or other body structure through a defect or natural opening in a covering, membrane, muscle, or bone. , or instability at a segment adjacent to a previously asymptomatic fusion performed an average of 13.1 years earlier. Interestingly, 58% of segments immediately next to the adjacent segment deteriorated at the same time as the adjacent segment. (9) The study noted that sagittal and coronal cor·o·nal
1. Of or relating to a corona, especially of the head.
2. Of, relating to, or having the direction of the coronal suture or of the plane dividing the body into front and back portions. imbalance appeared to play a role in adjacent segment breakdown although statistical significance was not evident.
Deformity and Adjacent Segment Disease
Recent literature has highlighted the importance of sagittal alignment and its relation to the development of adjacent level degeneration. In Katsuura's aforementioned study evaluating anterior cervical fusion, a total of 43% of patients with adjacent level degeneration had malalignment of the cervical spine at the time of diagnosis. Degenerative change in adjacent intervertebral levels was observed in 77% of segments fused in kyphosis kyphosis (kīfō`səs): see hunchback. . (19) Kumar and coworkers performed a similar study analyzing the relationship between lumbar sagittal imbalance and the development of adjacent segment degeneration. Thirty-one of 83 patients (38%) who had undergone lumbar fusion for degenerative disc disease had radiographic evidence of adjacent level degeneration above the level of the fusion at an average of 5.2 years following the index procedure. Of these 31 patients, 14 (45%) required a second surgical intervention. The lowest incidence of adjacent level degeneration was seen in patients with a normal C7 sagittal plumb line and normal sacral sacral /sa·cral/ (sa´kral) pertaining to the sacrum.
In the region of or relating to the sacrum.
adj pertaining to the sacrum. inclination (8%). In those with sagittal imbalance, vertical sacral inclination, or both, the incidence of adjacent segment disc degeneration was approximately 50%. (43)
Biomechanical studies have demonstrated the importance of sagittal alignment on adjacent motion segments. Oda and colleagues compared the effects of a kyphotic ky·pho·sis
Abnormal rearward curvature of the spine, resulting in protuberance of the upper back; hunchback.
[Greek k posterolateral fusion to a sagittally balanced in situ fusion in the lumbar spine of sheep. The kyphotic posterolateral fusion significantly influenced supra-adjacent motion segment biomechanics, by inducing more stiffness in the posterior ligamentous complex and increasing lamina LAMINA - A concurrent object-oriented language.
["Experiments with a Knowledge-based System on a Multiprocessor", Third Intl Conf Supercomputing Proc, 1988]. strain under flexion-extension loading. (44) Results of histologic analysis showed significant degenerative changes of the more cephalad cephalad /ceph·a·lad/ (sef´ah-lad) toward the head.
Toward the head or anterior section. L2-L3 facet joints in the kyphotic group. The investigators inferred that, in the group fused in kyphosis, compensatory hyperlordosis at the cranial cranial /cra·ni·al/ (-al)
1. pertaining to the cranium.
2. toward the head end of the body; a synonym of superior in humans and other bipeds.
adj. adjacent level led to lordotic lor·do·sis
n. pl. lor·do·ses
An abnormal forward curvature of the spine in the lumbar region.
[Greek lord contracture contracture /con·trac·ture/ (-cher) abnormal shortening of muscle tissue, rendering the muscle highly resistant to passive stretching. of the posterior ligaments. Significant degenerative changes were noted in the infra-adjacent facet joints in the kyphotic group as well. These results indicate that a kyphotic deformity may lead to adjacent level facet joint contracture and facet arthritis and may be the pain generator in such cases.
Akamura and coworkers performed a biomechanical study in which they tested the effect on adjacent motion segments of fusing a lumbar segment in various sagittal positions. (45) An in vitro biomechanical study of L4-L5 lumbar fixation in three different sagittal alignments was performed, and the total flexion-extension motions at the adjacent levels (L3-L4 and L5-S1) were measured. The three different fixation alignments were in situ fixation, hyperlordotic fixation, and hypolordotic fixation. Hypolordotic alignment at L4-L5 caused the greatest increase of sagittal motion at the adjacent L3-L4 level, and the differences were statistically significant in comparison with in-situ fixation, and hyperlordotic fixation. This study corroborates the importance of fusing the lumbar spine in situ or in hyperlordosis to prevent compensatory increased adjacent segment motion, which may predispose pre·dis·pose
To make susceptible, as to a disease. to early degeneration.
In a radiologic analysis of posture before and after lumbosacral fusion, done in order to evaluate the influence of sagittal alignment on the occurrence and pattern of postsurgical pain, Lazennac and colleagues demonstrated that postfusion pain correlated with a more vertical sacrum sacrum: see spinal column. and pelvic retroversion retroversion /ret·ro·ver·sion/ (-ver´zhun) the tipping backward of an entire organ or part.
1. A turning or tilting backward, as of the uterus.
2. . Appropriate alignment of the fused segments is of paramount importance to minimize muscle fatigue during maintenance of erect posture. (46) Anatomic coronal and sagittal balance appears to reduce posterior strain and associated degenerative changes.
Edwards and associates performed a retrospective clinical and radiographic analysis of long adult deformity fusions, terminating at L5 at a mean follow-up of 5.6 years. The investigators found that L5-S1 degenerative changes developed in 19 of 31 patients (61%) who were previously assessed as having healthy L5-S1 discs prior to surgery. Infra-adjacent disc degeneration was associated with positive sagittal balance and a need for revision surgery. (47)
The Impact of Motion-Sparing Technology on Adjacent Level Disease
Concern for the development of adjacent level disease following arthrodesis has generated interest in the development of motion-sparing alternatives to fusion. Short-term experience with total disc arthroplasty from clinical trials in the United States has been encouraging, but there is little long-term data available regarding the impact of total disc arthroplasty on adjacent segment disease. Robertson and coworkers compared the prevalence of adjacent segment degeneration at two-year follow-up in recipients of the Bryan cervical disc replacement to those who underwent single-level cervical discectomy and fusion. (48) Fusion was found to be significantly more associated with increased radiologic (odds ratio: 2.44) and clinical (odds ratio: 35.8) adjacent level disease. The investigators concluded that motion-sparing procedures in the cervical spine may be protective of adjacent levels when compared to fusion.
Clinical experience with arthroplasty has been more extensive in Europe. Zeegers and colleagues reported a series of 50 patients who underwent lumbar disc arthroplasty with the Charite III implant. Eleven patients (22%) required additional surgery at the adjacent level within two years following the index procedure. Four patients underwent discectomy and seven required prosthetic pros·thet·ic
1. Serving as or relating to a prosthesis.
2. Of or relating to prosthetics.
serving as a substitute; pertaining to prostheses or to prosthetics. replacement for symptomatic adjacent segment disease. (49) Huang and associates noted a decreased prevalence of radiographic adjacent level disease at 8.7 years following total disc replacement in patients who achieved greater than five degrees of motion at the index level. (50) This data would suggest that physiologic motion may be protective in the development of adjacent level degeneration. However, the question as to whether motion preservation reduces adjacent level disease will remain unanswered until more long-term data from randomized controlled trials of total disc replacement versus fusion become available.
Prevention of adjacent level degenerative disease is a complicated and controversial topic. There are no established guidelines for the treatment of degenerative disc disease. The argument for including a degenerative disc above a segment requiring fusion is the prevention of adjacent level degeneration and postfusion pain. On the other hand, the clinical relevance of degenerated lumbar discs is not well established, and an increase in fusion length has been shown to predispose patients to greater perioperative perioperative /peri·op·er·a·tive/ (-op´er-ah-tiv) pertaining to the period extending from the time of hospitalization for surgery to the time of discharge.
adj. morbidity. (51) Many authors have argued against the inclusion of a degenerative adjacent segment in a fusion, based solely on radiographic findings with a paucity of supportive clinical evidence. (52) In a five-year retrospective study, Miyakoshi and coworkers found no significant difference in clinical results between their patients with or without preoperative L5-S1 disc space narrowing who underwent one-level posterior fusion at L4-5. (53) Similarly, Throckmorton and colleagues, in a retrospective review of 25 consecutive patients who underwent lumbar fusion for degenerative instability, found no adverse impact on clinical outcomes when the fusion ended adjacent to a degenerative motion segment. (54)
Many would agree that there may be instances when prophylactic adjacent segment fusion may be beneficial, such as in those patients with sagittal malalignment, instability, or overwhelming axial pain, confirmed by positive provocative discography dis·cog·ra·phy
Examination of the intervertebral disk space using x-rays after injection of contrast media into the disk. . Elimination of painful disc disease with restoration of sagittal alignment seems to play an important role in averting adjacent level degeneration, as well as being vital to a successful surgical outcome. (52)
In the previously cited study by Hilibrand and associates that evaluated adjacent level degeneration following cervical spinal fusion, it was demonstrated that the risk of new disease at an adjacent level was significantly lower following a multilevel arthrodesis than it was following a single-level arthrodesis. (22) The study concluded that all degenerated segments causing radiculopathy or myelopathy should be included in an anterior cervical arthrodesis. It was their belief that further degeneration is likely secondary to progression of the disease process rather than the result of the fusion itself.
The development of adjacent level degeneration following cervical, lumbar, and lumbosacral fusions is most likely related to several postoperative mechanical factors as well as the normal aging process of the spine. The literature seems to support a multivariate etiology of this phenomenon. (9,19,25,30,35,43,45,53-62) In order to consider further operative intervention, radiographic findings of adjacent segment disease must be strongly correlated with clinical findings (Figs. 1 to 3).
[FIGURES 1-3 OMITTED]
The incidence of radiographic adjacent segment disease following fusion has been reported to be as high as 50% in the cervical spine and 70% in the lumbar spine at ten years. (19,31) However, the incidence of clinically relevant symptomatic adjacent segment disease is quite lower, estimated at 25% in the cervical spine and 36% in the lumbar spine at 10 years. (22,33) Sagittal malalignment appears to have a strong influence on the development of adjacent segment disease. In patients with symptomatic adjacent level degeneration, fusion in addition to decompression of the adjacent segment is often warranted. More long-term data is needed to determine the influence of motion sparing alternatives on the development of adjacent segment degeneration.
(1.) Bohlman HH, Emery SE, Goodfellow DB, Jones PK. Robinson anterior cervical discectomy and arthrodesis for cervical radiculopathy. Long-term follow-up of one hundred and twenty-two patients. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 1993 Sep;75(9):1298-307.
(2.) Robinson RA, Smith GW. Anterolateral cervical disc removal and interbody fusion for cervical disc syndrome Noun 1. cervical disc syndrome - an abnormal condition resulting from compression of spinal nerve roots in the neck region; involves neck pains and muscular weakness and paresthesia
cervical root syndrome . Bull Johns Hopkins Hosp. 1955;96:223-4.
(3.) Herkowitz HN, Kurz LT. Degenerative Lumbar Spondylolisthesis with Spinal Stenosis. A prospective study comparing decompression with decompression and intertransverse process arthrodesis. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 1991;73(6):802-8.
(4.) Davis H. Increasing rates of cervical and lumbar spine surgery in the United States, 1979-1990. Spine. 1994;19(10):1117-23; discussion 1123-4.
(5.) Chow DH, Luk KD, Evans JH, Leong JC. Effects of short anterior lumbar interbody fusion on biomechanics of neighboring unfused segments. Spine. 1996;21(5):549-55.
(6.) Boden SD, Davis DO, Dina TS, et al. Abnormal magnetic-resonance scans of the lumbar spine in asymptomatic subjects. A prospective investigation. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 1990;72(3):403-8.
(7.) Dohler, JR, Kahn MR, Hughes SP. Instability of the cervical spine after anterior interbody fusion. A study on its incidence and clinical significance in 21 patients. Arch Orthop Trauma Surg. 1985;104(4):247-50.
(8.) Hambly MF, Wiltse LL, Raghavan N, et al. The transition zone above a lumbosacral fusion. Spine. 1998;23(16):1785-92.
(9.) Schlegel JD, Smith JA, Schleusener RL. Lumbar motion segment pathology adjacent to thoracolumbar, lumbar, and lumbosacral fusions. Spine. 1996;21(8):970-81.
(10.) Kawakami M, Tamaki T, Ando M, et al. Lumbar sagittal balance influences the clinical outcome after decompression and posterolateral spinal fusion for degenerative lumbar spondylolisthesis. Spine. 2002;27(1):59-64.
(11.) Lagrone MO, Bradford DS, Moe JH, et al. Treatment of symptomatic flatback after spinal fusion. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 1988 Apr;70(4):569-80.
(12.) Hutter CG. Posterior intervertebral body fusion. A 25-year study. Clin Orthop Relat Res. 1983 Oct;(179):86-96.
(13.) Brodke DS, Zdeblick TA. Modified Smith-Robinson procedure for anterior cervical discectomy and fusion. Spine. 1992 Oct;17(10 Suppl):S427-30.
(14.) Emery SE, Bolesta MJ, Banks MA, Jones PK. Robinson anterior cervical fusion comparison of the standard and modified techniques. Spine. 1994;19(6):660-3.
(15.) Gore DR, Sepic SB. Anterior cervical fusion for degenerated or protruded discs. A review of one hundred forty-six patients. Spine. 1984;9(7):667-71.
(16.) Frymoyer JW, Hanley EN Jr, Howe J, et al. A Comparison of radiographic findings in fusion and nonfusion patients ten or more years following lumbar disc surgery. Spine. 1979 Sep-Oct;4(5):435-40.
(17.) Lehmann TR, Spratt KF, Tozzi JE, et al. Long-term follow-up of lower lumbar fusion patients. Spine. 1987;12(2):97-104.
(18.) Turner JA, Ersek M, Herron L, et al. Patient outcomes after lumbar spinal fusions. JAMA. 1992 Aug 19;268(7):907-11.
(19.) Katsuura A, Hukuda S, Saruhashi Y, Mori K. Kyphotic malalignment after anterior cervical fusion is one of the factors promoting the degenerative process in adjacent intervertebral levels. Eur Spine J. 2001 Aug;10(4):320-4.
(20.) Goffin J, Geusens E, Vantomme N, et al. Long-term follow-up after interbody fusion of the cervical spine. J Spinal Disord. 2004 Apr;17(2):79-85.
(21.) Herkowitz HN, Kurz LT, Overholt DP. Surgical management of cervical soft disc herniation. A comparison between the anterior and posterior approach. Spine. 1990 Oct;15(10):1026-30.
(22.) Hilibrand AS, Carlson GD, Palumbo MA, et al. Radiculopathy and myelopathy at segments adjacent to the site of a previous anterior cervical arthrodesis. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 1999 Apr;81A(4):519-28.
(23.) Yue WM, Brodner W, Highland TR. Long-term results after anterior cervical discectomy and fusion with allograft allograft: see transplantation, medical. and plating. A 5- to 11-year radiologic and clinical follow-up study. Spine. 2005 Oct 1;30(19):2138-44.
(24.) Ishihara H, Kanamori M, Kawaguchi Y, et al. Adjacent segment disease after anterior cervical interbody fusion. Spine J. 2004 Nov-Dec;4(6):624-8.
(25.) Eck JC, Humphreys SC, Lim TH, et al. Biomechanical study on the effect of cervical spine fusion cervical spine fusion Orthopedics The operative fusing of 2 or more cervical vertebrae due to trauma to the spine and/or bone degeneration on adjacent-level intradiscal pressure and segmental motion. Spine 2002 Nov;27(22):2431-4.
(26.) Maiman DJ, Kumaresan S, Yoganandan N, et al. Biomechanical effect of anterior cervical spine fusion on adjacent segments. Biomed Mater Eng. 1999; 9(1): 27-38.
(27.) Kim YE, Goel VK, Weinstein JN, et al. Effect of disc degeneration at one level on the adjacent level in axial mode. Spine. 1991 Mar;16(3):331-5.
(28.) Panjabi MM, Krag MH, Chung TQ. Effects of disc injury on mechanical behavior of the human spine. Spine. 1984 Oct;9(7):707-13.
(29.) Lopez-Espina CG, Amirouche F, Havalad V. Multitlevel cervical fusion and its effect on disc degeneration and osteophyte osteophyte /os·teo·phyte/ (os´te-o-fit?) a bony excrescence or outgrowth of bone.
A small abnormal bony outgrowth. Also called osteophyma. formation. Spine. Apr 20;31(9):972-8.
(30.) Etebar S, Cahill DW. Risk Factors for adjacent-segment failure following lumbar fixation with rigid instrumentation for degenerative instability. J Neurosurg. 1999;90(2 Suppl):163-9.
(31.) Ishihara H, Osada R, Kanamori M, et al. Minimum 10-year follow-up study of anterior lumbar interbody fusion for isthmic spondylolisthesis. J Spinal Disord. 2001 Apr;14(2):91-9.
(32.) Penta M, Sandhu A, Fraser RD. Magnetic resonance imaging assessment of disc degeneration 10 years after anterior lumbar interbody fusion. Spine. 1995 Mar 15;20(6):743-7.
(33.) Ghiselli G, Wang JC, Bhatia NN, et al. Adjacent segment degeneration in the lumbar spine. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 2004 Jul;86-A(7):1497-503.
(34.) Dekutoski MB, Schendel MJ, Ogilvie JW, et al. Comparison of in vivo and in vitro adjacent segment motion after lumbar fusion. Spine. 1994 Aug 1;19(15):1745-51.
(35.) Chou WY, Hsu CJ, Chang WN, Wong Cy. Adjacent segment degeneration after lumbar spinal posterolateral fusion with instrumentation in elderly patients. Arch orthop trauma surg. 2002 Feb;122(1):39-43.
(36.) Axelsson, P, Johnsson R, Stromqvist B. The spondylolytic vertebra and its adjacent segment. Mobility measured before and after posterolateral fusion. Spine. 1997 Feb 15;22(4):414-7.
(37.) Weinhoffer SL, Guyer RD, Herbert M, Griffith Sl. Intradiscal pressure measurements above an instrumented fusion. A cadaveric study. Spine. 1995 Mar 1;20(5):526-31.
(38.) Bell GR. Ross JS. Diagnosis of nerve root compression. myelography, computed tomography, and MRI. Orthop Clin North Am. 1992 July;23(3):405-19.
(39.) Boden SD, McCowin PR, Davis DO, et al. Abnormal magnetic resonance scans of the cervical spine in asymptomatic subjects. A prospective investigation. J Bone Joint Surg Am 1990 Sept; 72(8):1178-84.
(40.) Guigui P, Wodecki P, Bizot P, et al. Long-term outcome at adjacent levels of lumbar arthrodesis. Rev Chir Orthop Reparatrice Appar Mot. 1997;83(8):685-96.
(41.) Kumar MN, Jacquot F, Hall H. Long-term follow-up of functional outcomes and radiographic changes at adjacent levels following lumbar spine fusion for degenerative disc disease. Eur Spine J. 2001 Aug;10(4):309-13.
(42.) Lee C.K. Accelerated degeneration of the segment adjacent to a lumbar fusion. Spine. 1988 Mar;13(3):375-7.
(43.) Kumar MN, Baklanov A, Chopin D. Correlation between sagittal plane changes and adjacent segment degeneration following lumbar spine fusion. Eur Spine J. 2001 Aug; 10(4):314-9.
(44.) Oda I, Cunningham BW, Buckley RA, et al. Does spinal kyphotic deformity influence the biomechanical characteristics of the adjacent motion segments? An in vivo animal model. Spine. 1999 Jul 1; 24(20):2139-46.
(45.) Akamaru T, Kawahara N, Tim Yoon S, et al. Adjacent segment motion after a simulated lumbar fusion in different sagittal alignments: A biomechanical analysis. Spine. 2003 Jul 15;28(14):1560-6.
(46.) Lazennec JY, Ramare S, Arafati N, et al. Sagittal alignment in lumbosacral fusion: Relations between radiological parameters and pain. Eur Spine J. 2000 Feb; 9(1):47-55.
(47.) Edwards CC 2nd, Bridwell KH, Patel A, et al. Thoracolumbar deformity arthrodesis to l5 in adults: The fate of the L5-S1 disc. Spine. 2003 Sep 15; 28(18): 2122-31.
(48.) Robertson JT, Papadopoulos SM, Traynelis VC. Assessment of adjacent-segment disease in patients treated with cervical fusion or arthroplasty. A prospective 2-year study. J Neurosurg Spine. 2005 Dec;3(6):417-23.
(49.) Zeegers WS, Bohnen LM, Laaper M, Verhaegen MJ. Artificial disc replacement Artificial disc replacement is a medical procedure in which degenerated discs in the spine are replaced with artificial ones. The procedure is also known as "total disc arthroplasty." It is primarily used to treat chronic, severe low back pain from degenerative disc disease. with the modular type SB Charite III: 2-year results in 50 prospectively studied patients. Eur Spine J. 1999; 8(3):210-7.
(50.) Huang RC, Tropiano P, Marnay T, et al. Range of motion and adjacent level degeneration after lumbar total disc replacement. Spine J. 2006 May-Jun;6(3):242-7.
(51.) Sherman FC, Rosenthal RK, Hall JE. Spine fusion for spondylolysis and spondylolisthesis in children. Spine. 1979 Jan-Feb; 4(1):59-66.
(52.) Herkowitz HN, Abraham DJ, Albert TJ. Management of degenerative disc disease above an L5-S1 segment requiring arthrodesis. Spine. 1999 Jun 15;24(12):1268-70.
(53.) Miyakoshi N, Abe E, Shimada Y, et al. Outcome of one-level posterior lumbar interbody fusion for spondylolisthesis and postoperative intervertebral disc degeneration adjacent to the fusion. Spine. 2000 Jul 15;25(14):1837-42.
(54.) Throckmorton TW, Hilibrand AS, Mencio GA, et al. The impact of adjacent level disc degeneration on health status outcomes following lumbar fusion. Spine. 2003;28(22):2546-50.
(55.) Aota Y, Kumano K, Hirabayashi S. Postfusion instability at the adjacent segments after rigid pedicle pedicle /ped·i·cle/ (ped´i-k'l) a footlike, stemlike, or narrow basal part or structure.
1. A constricted portion or stalk.
2. screw fixation for degenerative lumbar spinal disorders. J Spinal Disord. 1995 Dec;8(6):464-73.
(56.) Buckwalter JA. Aging and degeneration of the human intervertebral disc. Spine. 1995 Jun 1;20(11):1307-14.
(57.) Fraser RD. Interbody, Posterior, and combined lumbar fusions. Spine. 1995 Dec 15;20(24 Suppl):167S-177S.
(58.) Ha KY, Schendel MJ, Lewis JL, et al. Effect of immobilization Immobilization Definition
Immobilization refers to the process of holding a joint or bone in place with a splint, cast, or brace. This is done to prevent an injured area from moving while it heals. and configuration on lumbar adjacent-segment biomechanics. J Spinal Disord. 1993 Apr; 6(2):99-105.
(59.) Hayes MA, Tompkins SF, Herndon WA, et al. Clinical and radiological evaluation of lumbosacral motion below fusion levels in idiopathic scoliosis Scoliosis Definition
Scoliosis is a side-to-side curvature of the spine.
When viewed from the rear, the spine usually appears perfectly straight. . Spine. 1988 Oct;13(10):1161-7.
(60.) Hutton WC, Toribatake Y, Elmer WA, et al. The effect of compressive com·pres·sive
Serving to or able to compress.
com·pressive·ly adv. force applied to the intervertebral disc in vivo. a study of proteoglycans and collagen. Spine. 1998 Dec 1;23(23):2524-37.
(61.) Shono Y, Kaneda K, Abumi K, et al. Stability of posterior spinal instrumentation and its effects on adjacent motion segments in the lumbosacral spine. Spine. 1998 Jul 15;23(14):1550-8.
(62.) Rahm MD, Hall BB. Adjacent-segment degeneration after Lumbar Fusion with Instrumentation. A retrospective study. J Spinal Disord. 1996 Oct;9(5):392-400.
David A. Levin, M.D., James J. Hale, M.D., and John A. Bendo, M.D.
David A. Levin, M.D., was a Fellow in the Spine Service, NYU NYU New York University
NYU New York Undercover (TV show) Hospital for Joint Diseases Department of Orthopaedic Surgery, NYU Hospital for Joint Diseases, New York, New York. James J. Hale, M.D., was a Chief Resident in the NYU Hospital for Joint Diseases Department of Orthopaedics Surgery, New York, New York. John A. Bendo, M.D., is Clinical Assistant Professor of Orthopaedic Surgery, the NYU School of Medicine and Associate Director of the NYU Hospital for Joint Diseases Spine Center, New York, New York.
Correspondence: John A. Bendo, M.D., 301 East 17th Street, NYU Hospital for Joint Diseases, New York, New York, 10003.