A pitfall of new growth theory: rhetoric, rent seeking and the semi-informed voter.
New Growth Theory, or endogenous growth theory In economics, endogenous growth theory or new growth theory was developed in the 1980s as a response to criticism of the neo-classical growth model. , provides economists with a more complete way to systematically investigate economic growth, as it focuses on the endogenous nature of growth due to positive externalities externalities
side-effects, either harmful or beneficial, borne by those not directly involved in the production of a commodity. in knowledge (Romer, 1986; and Solow, 1994). Although a greater understanding of the importance of technology utilization in growth theory is laudable, New Growth theorists can provide intellectual ammunition to those willing to misuse the theory as a public-interest veneer over their rent-seeking activities.
Broadband providers, NASA NASA: see National Aeronautics and Space Administration.
in full National Aeronautics and Space Administration
Independent U.S. , software companies, educators, and even stem-cell researchers have asked for and received government benefits under the auspices of New Growth Theory. Although New Growth Theory may present a theoretical reason for government interference in the technology sector, government agents may lack the knowledge or the incentives to deal with these externalities. Policy-oriented economists must be cautious when recommending government intervention, regardless of how reasonable intervention may seem. New Growth Theory, like many other reasonable sounding arguments, can be used to obscure rent seeking In economics, rent seeking occurs when an individual, organization, or firm seeks to make money by manipulating the economic and/or legal environment rather than by making a profit through trade and production of wealth. from semi-informed voters.
Differences between Classical and New Growth Theory
Classical Growth Theory
Classical Growth Theory suggests that capital is the answer to economic growth, but empirical evidence has found this theory wanting. In particular, classical growth theory suggested that the wealth of countries should converge to the same per capita [Latin, By the heads or polls.] A term used in the Descent and Distribution of the estate of one who dies without a will. It means to share and share alike according to the number of individuals. GDP GDP (guanosine diphosphate): see guanine. over time. Growth in rich countries should slow as the marginal productivity of capital diminishes, while capital inflows should speed the growth of poor countries. The real world shows little evidence of convergence, however, so economists have sought new theories (Easterly, 2002).
New Growth Theory
New Growth Theory focuses on a country's ability to utilize technology, which the theory posits is characterized by numerous positive externalities. When someone creates a new product or process, others not only copy it, but also use it as a springboard for other ideas (Easterly, 2002). Innovators often fail to see all the benefits of their ideas. Increased productivity raises wages in the long run, and higher wages lead to increased demand, which results in more capital and more R&D. Hence, in New Growth Theory, more capital is the result, not the cause, of increased growth.
The theoretical ammunition that New Growth Theory provides appears especially applicable to the technology sector. New technology and knowledge provide spillover spill·o·ver
1. The act or an instance of spilling over.
2. An amount or quantity spilled over.
3. A side effect arising from or as if from an unpredicted source: benefits, or positive externalities, which are the strongest impetus for growth (Romer, 1986). This growth-causing new technology is largely the result of deliberate investment in a search for new technology (Grossman and Helpman, 1994; Schumpeter, 1934; Solow, 1970; Romer, 1990; and Aghion and Howitt, 1992). Because technology firms claim to spend a much greater percentage of their revenue on deliberate research and development than do firms in other sectors, in New Growth Theory the technology sector is a primary impetus for growth (Romer, 1986 and 1990). As such, technology companies can use the theory as rhetorical ammunition when they petition for government subsidies and inclusion in special programs. The danger of New Growth Theory is that if government could just spend enough money jump-start starting technology firms, those firms would continuously build a vibrant economic sector.
[FIGURE A OMITTED]
As illustrated in Figure A, technology firms will invest in R&D to optimize their marginal private benefit (Q'). This is an under-investment, according to according to
1. As stated or indicated by; on the authority of: according to historians.
2. In keeping with: according to instructions.
3. standard welfare theory, because firms do not consider the social benefits of their research. Firms only produce those new technologies where they expect to reap benefits that recoup the costs, even if there is only a penny of private, appropriable ap·pro·pri·a·ble
That can be appropriated: appropriable funds.
Adj. 1. appropriable - that can be appropriated; "appropriable funds"
alienable - transferable to another owner benefit while ignoring of a dollar of social benefit. When private and social benefits diverge, the social optimum (Q*) will not be reached. This provides an argument for government subsidies for private technology research.
Empirical Shortcomings A shortcoming is a character flaw.
Shortcomings may also be:
While this paper focuses on how firms can use New Growth Theory to disguise rent seeking from semi-informed voters, the theory also has empirical shortcomings. Studies have indicated that the theory of significant spillover effects also has flaws. Delong and Summers (1991), for example, found that machinery investment played a large part in which countries' economies grew. But countries that could neither import nor create large amounts of machinery were later found to have other problems such as import controls and other bad policies (Pack 1994). It is these problems that cause low growth, not a lack of spillovers from imported technology. Technology was also mismeasured. Some R&D was defense related, and defense technology tends to have much less spillover simply because security clearances make it less available to others. Early studies showed that machinery imports were important for economic development may be flawed because countries with small machinery inputs often have import controls and other bad policies. The other bad policies matter so the marginal impact of additional machinery imports may not as valuable. As we improve our data and add years to our studies, New Growth Theory looks weaker instead of stronger.
In regards to economic development, New Growth Theory suggests that countries with good institutions should be able to benefit from technology transfers. As such, groups such as the IMF IMF
See: International Monetary Fund
See International Monetary Fund (IMF). , the World Bank, and even the U.S. government have promised to change how they distribute international aid by shifting from countries with strategic military and political values to countries that have good institutions that will encourage technology development with positive externalities. Aid provided in this form does not seem to help very much (Easterly, 2002 and 2003; Boone 1996). Furthermore, the benefits of aid do not appear in National Income Statistics. This is a real quandary for economists who would like to help people in developing nations. While the organizations that receive and distribute aid have not successfully used New Growth Theory to convince donors of their need, the failings of New Growth Theory suggest that any attempts to use New Growth Theory when fundraising should be viewed with some suspicion.
Investment and technology inputs alone do not necessarily lead to more growth. The former Soviet Union is a prime example of a country where there was lots of technology input, but the country was still relatively poor. Education in sub-Saharan Africa is an example where inputs, years of education, which should help countries utilize technology, have little to do with outputs (Easterly, 2002). When economists try to control for all the factors important in New Growth Theory, "Distance from the equator is the single strongest predictor of long-term economic success in our specification" (Hall and Jones, 1997, 176. See also Sala--i Martin, 1997). That distance from the equator is the largest predictor of economic success suggests that neither research and development nor technology transfers are the most important factor in economic development at least across countries.
A Potential Danger of New Growth Theory
External benefits from research constitute a public good. If R&D will be under-provided due to a lack of private benefits, Pigovian subsidies (Pigou 1920) can remedy the matter. The government can pay the firm a subsidy corresponding to the vertical difference in Figure A between the firm's private benefits and the social benefits (the difference between points B and C). Alternatively, government can encourage increased investment through tax code distortions or direct funding of research by government agencies such as the NSF NSF - National Science Foundation , NASA, and DOD (1) (Dial On Demand) A feature that allows a device to automatically dial a telephone number. For example, an ISDN router with dial on demand will automatically dial up the ISP when it senses IP traffic destined for the Internet. . However, the knowledge problem (Mises, 1977; and Cordato, 1995) and the rent seeking problem (Coase, 1960; and Buchanan 1969) hamper the implementation of this solution. Black (1969) and Arrow (1962) show that a rational social welfare function cannot exist. Mises (1998) shows that even if it did exist, the government could never maximize it because government lacks the knowledge to do so. We will see that the Pigovian solutions are faulty on many grounds and that rhetoric will be used by rent seekers.
The Rent Seeking Problem
The public goods argument for government intervention is long established, though harshly criticized, in the literature (Cowen and Crampton, 2003). In most cases, "public goods" arguments serve as public-interest veneers for the activities of private interest groups. Consequently, the public choice critique is more relevant here. Interest groups will organize to get technology R&D subsidies (Tullock, 1967). Rent seeking will proceed until the private costs equal the expected private gain. Because rent seeking uses valuable resources, it will dissipate some of the public benefits that might accrue from increased investment in technology.
Under traditional analysis, rent seeking should proceed until the private cost equals the expected return Expected Return
The average of a probability distribution of possible returns, calculated by using the following formula: . But once there is government acknowledgement of positive externalities arising from the technology sector this will simply signal to firms that the rent seeking doors are wide open. There are two reasons for this. First, there is a behavioral explanation; the idea that people's perspectives are framed by the way information is presented to them. In a world where people see more rent seeking, they consider rent seeking more (Kahneman and Tversky, 1984). Second, there is an institutional or Olson perspective once rent seeking takes over, any institutional constraints that may have minimized rent seeking are removed because they don't have the support (Krueger, 1974; Olson, 1996; and Greif, 2006). Hence it is very possible to get a whole new equilibrium with significantly lower GDP and standard of living.
The Importance of Theoretical Ammunition
Both the budget and the effect of the Downsian median voter constrain politicians. Funds spent on a technology program are necessarily money not spent elsewhere. In a pure rent seeking model, theoretical ammunition is not needed (Tullock, 1967); politicians simply provide patronage to the interest group providing the highest bribe. In more realistic models, however, rhetoric and moral suasion Moral Suasion
A persuasion tactic used by an authority (i.e. Federal Reserve Board) to influence and pressure, but not force, banks into adhering to policy. Tactics used are closed-door meetings with bank directors, increased severity of inspections, appeals to community spirit, or affect the position of the median voter and the voters' resistance to new taxes. Voters are rationally ignorant of details, but they are still voting on overall programs (Tollison and Wagner, 1991). Voter constraints that have been changed by rhetoric allow elected politicians to allocate resources to different programs: those with good rhetoric.
Voter preferences do not necessarily correspond to their economic interests, as voters have an ideology about what is "right" or "moral" (Dixit and Londregan, 1995; see also Becket beck·et
A device, such as a looped rope, hook and eye, strap, or grommet, used to hold or fasten loose ropes, spars, or oars in position.
Noun 1. , 1983, 392). Experiments suggest that people will pay a monetary penalty to gain more "fairness," punishing those who do not provide an equitable outcome (Roth 1995). They also vote "expressively" to satisfy emotional needs and express their opinions. Voting is an ideal way for people to do this because in most elections voting morally instead of economically is costless due to the very low probability of being the marginal voter (Brennan and Lomasky, 1993).
Individual voters, however, often have conflicting and changing views; they seem to want what is "right," but do not know precisely what that is. While voters sometimes have a specific philosophy about one or two issues, they can easily hold contradictory views about other issues. For example, some voters are opposed to globalization globalization
Process by which the experience of everyday life, marked by the diffusion of commodities and ideas, is becoming standardized around the world. Factors that have contributed to globalization include increasingly sophisticated communications and transportation but want the working poor in developing countries to have good jobs. Other voters want both a Christian America and separation of church and state
A brief statement, as by a politician, taken from an audiotape or videotape and broadcast especially during a news report: "The box has been spitting forth maddening nine-second sound bites" , or catchphrase Noun 1. catchphrase - a phrase that has become a catchword
phrase - an expression consisting of one or more words forming a grammatical constituent of a sentence at the moment (Caplan, 2001a and 2001b).
Caplan (2003) provides an interesting behavioral component of rhetoric. In behavioral economics Behavioral Economics
A field of economics that studies how the actual decision-making process influences the decisions that are reached.
The two most important questions in this field are: , cognitive bias A cognitive bias is any of a wide range of observer effects identified in cognitive science and social psychology including very basic statistical, social attribution, and memory errors that are common to all human beings. is the idea that people have systematic bias on a variety of problems. Caplan argues that once government intervention in the market has begun, voters' rationality actually worsens. A cognitive bias can occur among voters. "When economic outcomes are bad, people's economic beliefs perversely become less-not more-realistic. Rather than 'learning from their failures,' they become more committed to making failed policy work, one way or another" (196). Voters who have been fooled into supporting bad policy have a tendency to let the poor results of a bad policy reinforce their desire for the bad policy. Semi-informed voters who are fooled by rhetoric are more likely to want to be biased in the future, to their detriment (see also Alesina and Scheundeln, 2005).
Failed policies should result in calls for new policies, but since voters are poorly informed, they often want more of the bad policies. People who hear emotional appeals often believe that the policies were not bad but rather did not go far enough. For example, during the Great Depression, the National Recovery Act and other failed policies led not to calls for more markets, but rather calls for even more government intervention (Caplan, 2003). In this situation, societies would be better off if voters had never heard of these bad policies. In the case of New Growth Theory it might be better if voters never hear about positive externalities associated with technology. Because voters poorly understand positive externalities, they allow increased rent seeking. Bad results from poorly spent government money in R&D can lead to more support for bad R&D programs.
When the costs of systematic bias are low, bias should be common. The cost of biased voting is almost zero to the individual voter (Downs, 1957) but costly to society as a whole. As such, voters do not have any incentive to learn to perceive when government is beneficial and when it is not and can be easily swayed by rhetoric and appeals to ideology. If voters were perfectly informed on policy issues, education would be unnecessary, and if voters were perfectly irrational, education would be pointless. Yet, voters often vote based on a mixture of a tiny bit of learning and some sound bites, rhetoric, and ideology, which they sometimes use to decide which "team" they want to root for and vote accordingly (Brennan and Lomasky, 1993). New Growth Theory gives the technology sector more ammunition to appeal to voters. Unfortunately, this appeal only allows voters to harm themselves (Dougan and Munger, 1989).
Politicians do not need any good facts or studies to support technology transfers they merely need a good story: something that sounds plausible to voters. Politicians need a story that keeps voters from being suspicious and finding out the facts for themselves. New Growth Theory provides just such a story. There is a real theory behind it. There are real studies in support of New Growth Theory, and there are real empirical shortcomings. But voters do not read studies. If voters were perfectly informed, they would know rent seeking for what it is. If voters were completely clueless clue·less
Lacking understanding or knowledge.
Slang helpless or stupid
Adj. 1. , then they would just allow more efficient bribes. But voters are semi-informed. They get riled rile
tr.v. riled, ril·ing, riles
1. To stir to anger. See Synonyms at annoy.
2. To stir up (liquid); roil.
[Variant of roil.]
Adj. 1. up when they see obvious graft (Brennan and Lomasky, 1993). New Growth Theory allows politicians to replace obvious graft with less obvious graft. Every state has an office of technology and economic development. Technology incubation areas are scattered across the states in the most unlikely of areas-for actual technology development. It would be more efficient if the interested parties just took the money instead of pretending to provide economic development.
The Rent Seeking Spiral
In a static theory, government intervention, whether subsidies or other industrial policy, can improve social welfare by setting marginal private cost equal to marginal social cost. A more dynamic understanding of the economy shows that interventionism in·ter·ven·tion·ism
The policy or practice of intervening, especially:
a. The policy of intervening in the affairs of another sovereign state.
b. itself costs society in a variety of ways (Murphy, Schliefer, and Vishny, 1993). Intervention tends to organize and strengthen interest groups. The incentive to create is diminished, and the incentive to become politically powerful increases. Interest groups find that lobbying the government is profitable even though it decreases the gross domestic product. As a result, the government transfers the wealth of productive members of society to the politically powerful.
Not only do subsidies and special programs encourage entrepreneurs to focus on lobbying instead of creating, Easterly (2002) argues that a downward spiral occurs because all sorts of other bad policies follow, but we should at least expect a lower equilibrium. While it might make sense for government to encourage the creation of new technology because there are positive externalities, subsidies have secondary costs. People will naturally try to get around an intervention in the market, which leads to more intervention. Regulators must then intervene in the market again to protect the first intervention (Mises, 1977). Any calculation of benefits from Pigovian subsidies must include the potential costs of continuous intervention. While people will innovate to get around the regulation, that innovation will tend to be second best.
Pigovian public finance would suggest directly or indirectly subsidizing the technology sector to increase social welfare. In reality, regulatory protection for favored firms often occurs instead. Protection requires no expenditures, which makes it easier to pass on costs to voters, the consumers. Subsidies attract new entrants to technology markets. This is good for economies hoping to expand their technology sector, but bad for firms already in the sector. Early entrants will thus lobby for rules that increase the cost of doing business for late arrivals. So far internet, stem cell stem cell
In living organisms, an undifferentiated cell that can produce other cells that eventually make up specialized tissues and organs. There are two major types of stem cells, embryonic and adult. research, computer chip, and nanotech companies have not yet asked to be regulated so that they can form cartels or avoid new competition, a strategy adopted by many old-economy firms. Economists and policy analysts from a wide range of ideological perspectives agree that firms often benefit from regulation because it asymmetrically raises costs to smaller firms and prevents market entry (Yandle, 1989; Portne, et al. 2000; and The Economist, 1994). Hence, interest groups lobby the government for specific rules that reduce the property rights of firms but make it easier to form cartels. Voters are only partially cognizant of how these laws work.
A wide range of special projects currently involve the technology sector. Policy analysts have begun referring to these as "cyberpork" (Thierer, Crews, and Pearson, 2002). Firms often present projects as being growth or security enhancing, but the ratio of pork to truly useful projects is likely high because information asymmetries make determining the legitimacy of these projects difficult. As such, budget overseers are unable to separate the wheat from the chaff chaff
1. chaffed hay; called also chop.
2. the winnowings from a threshing, consisting of awns, husks, glumes and other relatively indigestible materials. and end up providing too much funding (Niskanen, 1971). Even programs that seem to have positive externalities will tend to be too large such that marginal cost Marginal cost
The increase or decrease in a firm's total cost of production as a result of changing production by one unit.
The additional cost needed to produce or purchase one more unit of a good or service. exceeds marginal benefits.
Companies in the tech sector obviously think that rent seeking will be beneficial to them privately and not just for the public welfare. In 2005, Microsoft and its executives spent $8.7 million on lobbying. In the 2004 election cycle Microsoft gave $3.3 million to PACS (Picture ArChiving System) A storage and management system for high-resolution images. Typically pertaining to the medical field, images such as X-rays, MRIs and CAT scans require a greater amount of storage than other industries. and individual candidates (Center for Responsive Politics "The Center for Responsive Politics is a non-partisan, non-profit research group based in Washington, D.C. that tracks money in politics, and the effect of money on elections and public policy. , 2006). While Microsoft tends to work alone, other technology companies have formed lobbying groups such as TechNet and the United States United States, officially United States of America, republic (2005 est. pop. 295,734,000), 3,539,227 sq mi (9,166,598 sq km), North America. The United States is the world's third largest country in population and the fourth largest country in area. Service Providers Association. Other groups have worked to ensure that the Department of Defense can purchase technology outside normal channels (Lemos and Yamamoto, 2004). In 2005 the communication/technology companies gave a total of $308.5 million to PACS and candidates up from $285.1 million in 2004 (Political Money Line, 2006).
Companies that provide high-speed internet See broadband. access have extensively lobbied for subsidies using concepts from New Growth Theory to provide moral cover for their rent seeking (Atkinson, et al., 2002; Crandall and Jackson, 2004; Crandall et al., 2001). Their argument is that broadband Internet access Broadband Internet access, often shortened to just "broadband", is high speed Internet access—typically contrasted with dial-up access over modem.
Dial-up modems are generally only capable of a maximum bitrate of 56 kbit/s (kilobits per second) and require the full use of a provides people with a better way to learn about and utilize new technology. People who cannot utilize new technology will be left behind economically and will be unable to spur the creation of further technology. Future economic growth will be hurt because individuals, particularly those in rural areas where Internet access See how to access the Internet. is expensive, will under-invest in broadband. Hence, the potential externalities from rural broadband will never occur (USDA USDA,
n.pr See United States Department of Agriculture. , 2000).
Another area where government technology grants are supposed to infuse in·fuse
1. To steep or soak without boiling in order to extract soluble elements or active principles.
2. To introduce a solution into the body through a vein for therapeutic purposes. new growth into an economy is stem cell research. Proposition 71 was a California voter initiative that creates a California Institute for Regenerative Medicine The California Institute for Regenerative Medicine (CIRM) was created by California's Proposition 71 (2004), which authorized it to issue $3 billion in grants, funded by bonds, over ten years for embryonic stem cell and other biomedical research. spending three billion dollars over the next ten years. The proposition was strongly favored by venture capital companies and biotech companies (Knowledge@Wharton, 2004). These companies argued that there is too much uncertainty and too many technology externalities for private firms to do stem cell research on their own. Proposition 71 passed easily in part because voters were led to believe that California would receive health care savings, royalties, and tremendous economic growth. The economic growth supposedly comes from the way that technology creates a self sustaining spiral Unfortunately for the semi-informed voters of California, this is not the case.
Rent Extraction (2)
McChesney (1997) defines rent extraction as when legislators threaten to pass costly legislation to coerce interest groups to cough up campaign contributions. This adds to the funds that interest groups spend on lobbying and exacerbates the rent seeking cycle. Rent-extracting legislation must have the veneer of acceptability, however. A legislator looks greedy to voters if he simply says, "Give me money, or I'll tax and regulate you to death." But a legislator's greed goes over semi-informed voters' heads if he says, "I hope I don't have to tax you and force you to provide free access to your technology so that poor rural localities can experience economic growth." The veneer does not matter to the completely uninformed, but to the semi-informed voter New Growth Theory seems very reasonable. Consider Microsoft's large lobbying budget. Microsoft was not always a lobbying giant, however; in 1995 it had only one lobbyist, Jack Krumholtz. Bill Gates (person) Bill Gates - William Henry Gates III, Chief Executive Officer of Microsoft, which he co-founded in 1975 with Paul Allen. In 1994 Gates is a billionaire, worth $9.35b and Microsoft is worth about $27b. disdained lobbying and thought that corporations should not do it. When the Justice Department's Anti-Trust division filed its antitrust suit in 1998, Microsoft had to change tactics. Much of the early debate concerned the idea that Microsoft was squashing innovation in technology, which would harm the economy's growth. The suit had almost nothing to do with economic growth, but it and anti-trust provided a veneer of respectability (Liebowitz and Margolis, 1999).
Public Attempts at Solving the Public Goods Problem of Technology
Since technology is endogenous, entrepreneurs must invest in research and development. The best argument for government intervention in the technology sector is that technology does not transfer freely. Public goods aspects of technology certainly exist, but they are often embedded within organizational structures and affected by social capabilities. In particular, spillover technologies are often geographically localized; people do not realize that someone in another setting has a technical solution to their problem.
This might seem like a perfect opportunity for government to step in and with its "infinite wisdom" see which technologies were being underused. Government could subsidize research and development that would have large positive externalities while leaving alone R&D projects with no externalities. It could tax those industries that did not embrace technology, or that embraced technology with negative externalities. Government could, in short, do all of the things that Pigou envisioned it doing. This is certainly the policy favored by budget-maximizing bureaucrats and companies that wish to collude col·lude
intr.v. col·lud·ed, col·lud·ing, col·ludes
To act together secretly to achieve a fraudulent, illegal, or deceitful purpose; conspire. with government approval.
Government is not infinitely wise. Governments do not have a particularly good track record of utilizing technology before private industry does. Instead, government has a track record of massive waste and cost overruns. It is unclear how government would choose the R&D that will have significant spillover effects when the innovators themselves cannot make that prediction. The Pigovian idea that government can implement efficient taxes on negative externalities and efficient subsidies on positive externalities is criticized throughout the Austrian and environmental economics literature (Cordato, 1995).
New Growth Theory also posits that the greatest growth occurs when large parts of society are able to utilize new technology. Private R&D companies (3) have every incentive to help people learn about and utilize their technology. The public may equate salesmen with unethical used car dealers, but the sales professional's job is actually to find people with problems and help them. He gets paid to do that, and as a result does a better job than any incentiveless bureaucrat could.
Companies and industries that are competing poorly like to use the government for protection. They lobby for tariff or non-tariff barriers to protect themselves from foreign competition, use government mandates to cartelize car·tel·ize
tr. & intr.v. car·tel·ized, car·tel·iz·ing, car·tel·iz·es
To form as or become a cartel.
car , and use imposed standards to impair new competitors in to bringing innovation to market. Moreover, government often subsidizes losers; companies that have failed to innovate receive tax breaks and bailouts to protect worker jobs. The relevant economic literature shows that governments are poor decision-makers when it comes to industrial policy (Zinsmeister, 1993).
Empirical evidence for New Growth Theory is mixed at best, but policy makers are using it. In particular, the Bush administration has used New Growth to allocate foreign aid dollars. Many states are funding stem cell research because they are afraid that other states will outpace them economically if they do not get involved. Second, catchphrase theories that resonate with voters are always popular with elected officials. The average voter thinks he understands the "infant industries" or "unfair labor practices Conduct prohibited by federal law regulating relations between employers, employees, and labor organizations.
Before 1935 U.S. labor unions received little protection from the law. " arguments. He does not know much economics and is not statistically literate, so he is fooled by good rhetoric.
New Growth Theory, while powerful, provides certain rent seeking groups just enough ammunition to distract voters from a job that they are already woefully woe·ful also wo·ful
1. Affected by or full of woe; mournful.
2. Causing or involving woe.
3. Deplorably bad or wretched: bad at: monitoring politicians. It also allows politicians to redistribute wealth under the guise of technology enhancement. As the U.S. economy increasingly relies on the technology sector for growth, politicians will experience increasing pressure to institute wealth redistribution programs toward the technology sector. These programs have been given the veneer of respectability by New Growth Theory but actually have all of the same old government failings.
Aghion, Phillippe, and Peter Howitt. 1992. "A Model of Growth through Creative Destruction." Econometrica. 60:2, March, 323-51.
Alesina, Alberto and Nichola Fuchs Scheundeln. 2005. "Good bye Lenin (or not?): The Effect of Communism on People's Preferences." NBER NBER National Bureau of Economic Research (Cambridge, MA)
NBER Nittany and Bald Eagle Railroad Company Working Paper No. 11700, Cambridge, MA: NBER.
Analysis Group. 2004. "Economic Impact Analysis: Proposition 71, California Stem Cell Research and Cures Initiative." September 14. Available online:
Atkinson, Robert D., Shane Ham, and Brian Newkirk. 2002. "Unleashing the Potential of the High-Speed Internet: strategies to boost broadband demand." Online December 22, 2002. www.ppionlme.org/documents/Broadband_0902.pdf
Arrow, Kenneth Arrow, Kenneth (Joseph) (1921– ) economist; born in New York City. He was recognized early in his career for his "impossibility theorem," a study of collective choice that employs the notational system of logic to illustrate that more than two . 1963. Social Choice and Individual Values Kenneth Arrow's monograph Social Choice and Individual Values (1951, 2nd ed., 1963) and a theorem within it created modern social choice theory, a rigorous melding of social ethics and voting theory with an economic flavor. . New York New York, state, United States
New York, Middle Atlantic state of the United States. It is bordered by Vermont, Massachusetts, Connecticut, and the Atlantic Ocean (E), New Jersey and Pennsylvania (S), Lakes Erie and Ontario and the Canadian province of : John Wiley John Wiley may refer to:
Becker, Gary Becker, Gary, 1930–, American economist. A professor at the Univ. of Chicago, he was awarded the 1992 Nobel Memorial Prize in Economic Sciences for extending the scope of microeconomic analysis. . 1983. "A Theory of Competition Among Pressure Groups for Political Influence." Quarterly Journal of Economics The Quarterly Journal of Economics, or QJE, is an economics journal published by the Massachusetts Institute of Technology and edited at Harvard University's Department of Economics. Its current editors are Robert J. Barro, Edward L. Glaeser and Lawrence F. Katz. , August, 371-400.
Black, Duncan. 1969. "On Arrow's Impossibility Theorem In voting systems, Arrow’s impossibility theorem, or Arrow’s paradox, demonstrates that no voting system can convert the ranked preferences of individuals into a community-wide ranking while also meeting a certain set of reasonable criteria when there are three ." Journal of Law and Economics, 12:2 October, 227-48.
Brennan, Geoffrey, and Loren Lomasky Loren Lomasky is an American philosopher, currently a Professor of Political philosophy, Policy and Law at the University of Virginia. Lomasky earned his PhD from the University of Connecticut, and has previously taught at Bowling Green State University in Ohio, the University of . 1993. Democracy and Decision. New York: Cambridge University Press Cambridge University Press (known colloquially as CUP) is a publisher given a Royal Charter by Henry VIII in 1534, and one of the two privileged presses (the other being Oxford University Press). .
Boone, Peter. 1996. "Politics and Effectiveness of Foreign Aid," European Economic Review, 40:2, February, 289-329.
Buchanan, James Buchanan, James, 1791–1868, 15th President of the United States (1857–61), b. near Mercersburg, Pa., grad. Dickinson College, 1809. Early Career
Buchanan studied law at Lancaster, Pa. M. 1969. Cost and Choice. Chicago: Chicago University Press.
Caplan, Bryan D. 2001a. "Rational Irrationality and the Microfoundations of Political Failure." Public Choice, 107:3/4, June, 311-331.
--. 2001b. "Libertarianism Against Economism economism
a theory or doctrine that attaches principal importance to economic goals. — economist, n.
See also: Economics : How Economists Misunderstand Voters and Why Libertarians Should Care." Independent Review 5:4, Spring, pp. 539-563.
--. 2003. "The Idea Trap: The Political Economy of Growth Divergence," European Journal European Journal is a weekly Deutsche Welle (DW) news program produced in English. It is broadcast from Brussels, Belgium and primarily covers political and economic developments across the European Union and the rest of Europe, as well as issues of particular concern to of Political Economy. 19:2, June, 183-203. Center for Responsive Politics. "Your Guide to the Money in U.S. Elections." Available online: http://www.opensecrets.org/
Coase, Ronald Coase, Ronald (Harry)
(born Dec. 29, 1910, Willesden, Middlesex, Eng.) British-U.S. economist. He received his doctorate from the London School of Economics and taught principally there and the University of Chicago. . 1960. "The Problem of Social Cost." Journal of Law and Economics. 3, 1-44.
Cordato, Roy. 1995. "Pollution Taxes and the Pretense of Efficiency," Journal of Private Enterprise. 10:2, Spring, 105-118.
Cowen, Tyler, and Eric Crampton (eds). 2003. Market Failure or Success: The New Debate. New York: Edward Elgar Sir Edward William Elgar, 1st Baronet, OM, GCVO (2 June 1857 – 23 February 1934) was an English Romantic composer. Several of his first major orchestral works, including the Enigma Variations and the Pomp and Circumstance Marches, were greeted with acclaim. .
Crandall, Robert W., Robert Hahn, Robert Litan, and Scott Wallsten. 2004. "Bandwidth for the People." Policy Review, 127, October & November, 67-7.
Crandall Robert W., and Charles L. Jackson. 2001. "The $500 Billion Opportunity: The Potential Economic Benefit of Widespread Diffusion of Broadband Internet Access," Criterion Economics. http://www.sbc.com/public_affairs/broadband_policy/BrookingsSt udy.pdf
Delong, Bradford J., and Lawrence H. Summers. 1991. "Equipment Investment and Economic Growth." Quarterly Journal of Economics, May, 106: 445-502.
Dixit, Avinash, and John Londregan. 1996. "Redistributive politics and economic efficiency." American Political Science Review The American Political Science Review (APSR) is the flagship publication of the American Political Science Association and the most prestigious journal in political science. , 89:4, 856-866.
Dougan, William, and Michael Munger. 1989. "The Rationality of Ideology." Journal of Law and Economics, 1989, 119-42.
Downs, Anthony. 1957 An Economic Theory of Democracy. New York: Harper.
Easterly, William. 2002. The Elusive Quest for Verb 1. quest for - go in search of or hunt for; "pursue a hobby"
quest after, go after, pursue
look for, search, seek - try to locate or discover, or try to establish the existence of; "The police are searching for clues"; "They are searching for the Growth. Cambridge, MA: MIT MIT - Massachusetts Institute of Technology Press.
--. 2003. "Can Foreign Aid Buy Growth?" Journal of Economic Perspectives, 17:3, Summer, 23-48.
Greif, Avner. 2006. Institutions and the Path to the Modern Economy: Lessons from Medieval Trade. New York, NY: Cambridge University Press.
Grossman, Gene, and Elhanan Helpman Elhanan Helpman (born March 30, 1946 in Jalal-Abad in the Fergana Valley, former Soviet Union) is an Israeli economist who works in the field of international trade, political economy and economic growth. . 1994. "Endogenous Innovation in the Theory of Growth," Journal of Economic Perspectives. 8:1, Winter, 23-44.
Hall, Robert E., and Charles I Charles I, duke of Lower Lorraine
Charles I, 953–992?, duke of Lower Lorraine (977–91); younger son of King Louis IV of France. He claimed the French throne when his nephew, Louis V of France, died (987) without issue, but he was set aside in . Jones. 1997. "What Have we Learned from Recent Empirical Growth Research? Levels of Economic Activity Across Countries." The American Economic Review, 87:2, May, 173-177.
Kahneman, Daniel Kahneman, Daniel
(born March 5, 1934, Tel Aviv, Israel) Israeli-born psychologist. He attended Hebrew University (B.A., 1954) in Jerusalem and the University of California, Berkeley (Ph.D., 1961). , and Amos Tversky Amos Tversky (March 16, 1937 - June 2, 1996) was a cognitive and mathematical psychologist, and a pioneer of cognitive science, a longtime collaborator of Daniel Kahneman, and a key figure in the discovery of systematic human cognitive bias and handling of risk. . 1984. "Choices, Values, and Frames." American Psychologist The American Psychologist is the official journal of the American Psychological Association. It contains archival documents and articles covering current issues in psychology, the science and practice of psychology, and psychology's contribution to public policy. 4, April: 341-50.
Knowledge@Wharton 2004. "Will Proposition 71 Make California the Mecca of Stem-Cell Research Noun 1. stem-cell research - research on stem cells and their use in medicine
biological research - scientific research conducted by biologists
embryonic stem-cell research - biological research on stem cells derived from embryos and on their use in medicine ?" November 3rd. Available online at: http://knowledge.wharton.upenn.edu/article.cfm?articleid=1061#
Krueger, Anne. 1974. "The Political Economy of the Rent-Seeking Society." American Economic Review, 64, 291-303.
Lemos, Robert, and Mike Yamamoto. 2004. "Throwing Money at Technology," C|Net New.com October 18. http://news.com.com/2009-1009_3-5395361.html?tag=nl
Liebowitz, Stanley, and Stephen E. Margolis. 1999. Winners, Losers & Microsoft. Oakland: The Independent Institute.
Loney, Matt. 2002. "Microsoft's lobbying efforts eclipse Enron." ZDnet.com. February 12, zdnet.com.com/2100-1104-835267.html
Mises, Ludwig von Mises, Ludwig (Edler) von
(born Sept. 29, 1881, Lemberg, Austria-Hungary—died Oct. 10, 1973, New York, N.Y., U.S.) Austrian-U.S. economist whose theories followed those of the Austrian school of economics. . 1998. (Scholars Edition) Human Action: A Treatise on Economics. Auburn, AL: Mises Institute.
--. 1977. A Critique of Interventionism. New Rochelle New Rochelle (rōshĕl`), city (1990 pop. 67,625), Westchester co., SE N.Y., on Long Island Sound; settled by Huguenots 1688, inc. as a village 1858, as a city 1899. , NY: Arlington House Arlington House may refer to the following:
Murphy, Kevin M., Andrei Shleifer Andrei Shleifer (born February 20, 1961) is a prominent academic economist. He was born in Russia and emigrated to Rochester, NY as a teenager. He then studied economics, obtaining his Ph.D. at MIT in 1986. , and Robert W. Vishny Robert Ward Vishny is an American economist and was the Eric J. Gleacher Distinguished Service Professor of Finance at the University of Chicago Graduate School of Business.
He received his A.B. . 1993. "Why Is Rent-Seeking So Costly to Growth?" In New Developments in Development. The American Economic Review, 83:2, May, 409-414.
Niskanen, William. 1971. Bureaucracy and Representative Government. Chicago: Aldine Press Aldine Press was the printing office started by Aldus Manutius in 1494 in Venice, from which were issued the celebrated Aldine editions of the classics of that time. The Aldine Press is famous in the history of typography, among other things, for the introduction of italics. .
Olson, Mancur. 1996. "Big Bills Left on the Sidewalk: Why Some Nations are Rich and Others Poor." The Journal of Economic Perspectives, 10:2, Spring, 3-24.
--. 1984. The Rise and Decline of Nations: Economic Growth, 'Stagflation, and Social Rigidities. New Haven New Haven, city (1990 pop. 130,474), New Haven co., S Conn., a port of entry where the Quinnipiac and other small rivers enter Long Island Sound; inc. 1784. Firearms and ammunition, clocks and watches, tools, rubber and paper products, and textiles are among the many : Yale University Press.
--. 1971. The Logic of Collective Action: Public Goods and the Theory of Groups. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press The Harvard University Press is a publishing house, a division of Harvard University, that is highly respected in academic publishing. It was established on January 13, 1913. In 2005, it published 220 new titles. .
Pack, Howard. 1994. "Endogenous Growth Theory: Intellectual Appeal and Empirical Shortcomings." Journal of Economic Perspectives 8:1, Winter, 55-72.
Pigou, Arthur Cecil Pigou, Arthur Cecil (pĭ`g), 1877–1959, British economist, grad. King's College, Cambridge. He was a lecturer at University College, London, and at Cambridge. . 1920. The Economics of Welfare. Macmillan: London.
Political Money Line. 2006. "Money in Politics Database." Available online: http://tray.com/cgi-win/x_sic.exe?DoFn=. 1994. "Regulate Us, Please." The Economist. 3330:7844,January 8, 69-71.
Romer, Paul M. 1986. "Increasing Returns Long-Run Growth." Journal of Political Economy. 94:5, October, 1002-37.
--. 1990. "Endogenous Technological Change." Journal of Political Economy. 98:5, October, S71-S102.
Roth, Alvin E. 1995. "Bargaining Experiments," in The Handbook of Experimental Economics, edited by J. H. Kagel and A. E. Roth, Princeton: Princeton University Press, 253-348
Sala-I-Martin, Xavier X. 1997. "What Have we Learned from Recent Empirical Growth Research? I Just Ran Two Million Regressions." The American Economic Review 87:2, May, 178-183.
Schumpeter, Joseph A Schumpeter, Joseph A(lois)
(born Feb. 8, 1883, Triesch, Moravia—died Jan. 8, 1950, Taconic, Conn., U.S.) Moravian-U.S. economist and sociologist. Educated in Austria, he taught at several European universities before joining the faculty of Harvard University . 1975 [original 1942]. Capitalism, Socialism, and Democrat. New York: Harper.
Smith, Adam. 1982 [original 1776]. An Inquiry into the Nature and Causes of the Wealth of Nations. Indianapolis, IN: Liberty Fund.
Solow, Robert M Solow, Robert M(erton)
(born Aug. 23, 1924, Brooklyn, N.Y., U.S.) U.S. economist. He received his Ph.D. from Harvard University and began teaching at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology in 1949. . 1956. "A Contribution to the Theory of Economic Growth," Quarterly Journal of Economics. 70:1, February: 65-94.
--.1970. Growth Theory: An Exposition. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
--.1994. "Perspectives on Growth Theory." Journal of Economic Perspectives, 8:1, 45-54.
Thierer, Adam, Clyde Wayne Crews, Jr., and Thomas Pearson. 2002. "Birth of Digital New Deal: An Inventory of High-Tech Pork-Barrel Spending." Policy Analysis, 457, October. Washington, DC: Cato Institute.
Tollison, Robert, and Richard Wagner. 1991. "Romance, Realism, and Economic Reform." Kyklos. 44:1, 57-70.
Tullock, Gordon. 1967. "The Welfare Cost of Tariffs, Monopolies, and Theft," Western Economic Journal. 5, June, 224-232.
USDA. 2000. "Advanced Telecommunications in Rural America." January 5, 2005. http://www.ntia.doc.gov/reports/ruralbb42600.pdf
Yandle, Bruce. 1989. The Political Limits of Environmental Regulation: Tracking the Unicorn. Westport, CT: Quorum Books.
David T. Mitchell (1)
Saint Mary's College of California The college's official literature states that Saint Mary's mission is guided by three traditions: Liberal Arts, Catholic and Lasallian. History
St. Mary's College began in 1863 as a diocesan college for boys established by Most Rev.
(1) I would like to thank Carl Close, Eric Crampton, and Peter Boettke for their help and support. The usual caveat applies.
(2) I am grateful to an anonymous referee who suggested that I add this section.
(3) The careful reader will note that I am assuming that R&D does not occur in a perfectly competitive environment where goods are priced at marginal cost. That makes sense to me intuitively and empirically. See also, Romer, 1990.