Printer Friendly
The Free Library
4,659,343 articles and books
Member login
User name  
Password 
 
Join us Forgot password?

A break-in for peace. (It Seems to Me).


In the film Ocean's 11, eleven skillful skill·ful  
adj.
1. Possessing or exercising skill; expert. See Synonyms at proficient.

2. Characterized by, exhibiting, or requiring skill.
 crooks embark on an ingenious plan, meticulously worked out, to break into an impossibly secure vault and make off with more than $100 million in Las Vegas Las Vegas (läs vā`gəs), city (1990 pop. 258,295), seat of Clark co., S Nev.; inc. 1911. It is the largest city in Nevada and the center of one of the fastest-growing urban areas in the United States.  casino loot. Hardly a crime of passion, despite the faint electrical charge surrounding Julia Roberts and George Clooney George Timothy Clooney (May 6, 1961) is an American actor, director, producer and screenwriter who gained fame as the lead doctor in the long-running television drama, ER . No, money was the motive, with as little moral fervor attending the crime as went into the making of the movie, which had the same motive.

I was reminded of this recently when I sat in a courtroom in Camden, New Jersey The City of Camden is the county seat of Camden County, New Jersey in the United States. It is located just across the Delaware River from Philadelphia, Pennsylvania. As of the United States 2000 Census, the city had a total population of 79,904. , and participated in the recollection of another break-in, carried out by the Camden 28, where the motive was to protest the war in Vietnam.

It was the summer of 1971 when a group of men and women, ranging from young to middle-aged, including a few Catholic priests This is an annotated list of men primarily known for their work as Catholic priests. Catholic priests who are mostly known for their non-priestly work should be placed on other lists. , carefully worked out a plan (going over building diagrams and armed with walkie-talkies, just like the Ocean's 11) to break into the draft board offices on the fifth floor of the federal building in Camden and make off with thousands of draft records. It was an act of symbolic sabotage, designed to dramatize dram·a·tize  
v. dram·a·tized, dram·a·tiz·ing, dram·a·tiz·es

v.tr.
1. To adapt (a literary work) for dramatic presentation, as in a theater or on television or radio.

2.
 the anguish felt by these people over the death and suffering taking place in Vietnam.

Yes, a crime of passion, not the sort Hollywood is likely to make a movie of. But a young documentary filmmaker named Anthony Giacchino has decided to tell the story. It happens that his family in Camden attends the Church of the Sacred Heart Church of the Sacred Heart is a name shared by several churches of the Roman Catholic Church, referring to the Sacred Heart of Jesus Christ.
  • Church of the Sacred Heart, Dublin
  • Church of the Sacred Heart, Minnesota
, whose priest is Father Michael Doyle
''This is an article about the university professor. For the politician from Pennsylvania, see Michael F. Doyle


Michael W. Doyle (born 1948) is an international relations scholar whose most influential work is Empires, an analysis of imperialism.
, one of the Camden 28.

This spring, I received a phone call from Anthony, who asked if I could show up in Camden on May 4 for a retrospective of the event. I had been a witness in the 1973 trial. He told me most of the twenty-eight defendants would be there, as well as David Kairys and Martin Stolar, who had helped them in acting as their own attorneys in the trial. The judge who presided in the 1971 trial, Clarkson Fisher, was dead. So was John Barry John Barry may refer to:
  • Sir John Barry around 1529 rector of Chew Stoke
  • John Barry (naval officer) (1745–1803), officer in the Continental Navy
  • John S.
, who prosecuted the case. But a representative of the FBI would be present, and one member of the jury.

We would all be meeting in the same courtroom where the trial took place, two floors below where the Camden 28 made their way into the draft board office and stuffed draft records into mail bags. This surprising arrangement was possible because the Historical Society of the Federal District Court for New Jersey had decided to do video histories of the important trials that had taken place in that courthouse. And it would start with the most famous of those trials, that of the Camden 28.

On August 22, 1971, "eight figures in dark clothes scaled a ladder to the top of the U.S. Post Office U.S. Post Office can refer to the United States Postal Service system.

There are many interesting and historic buildings among the large number of facilities.
 Building in Camden, the home of the federal court and the local draft board," the Philadelphia Inquirer Philadelphia Inquirer

Morning newspaper, long one of the most influential dailies in the eastern U.S. Founded in 1847 as the Pennsylvania Inquirer, it took its present name c. 1860. It was a strong supporter of the Union in the American Civil War.
 reported. "They carried burglar tools and a strong belief that the war in Vietnam was wrong."

It was about 2:30 in the morning, and they had decided to do it then so there would be no encounter with people working there, no chance of violence. But they encountered 100 FBI agents, tipped off by Robert Hardy, who had been a friend of some of the defendants. Hardy was an informant and agent provocateur a·gent pro·vo·ca·teur  
n. pl. a·gents pro·vo·ca·teurs
A person employed to associate with suspected individuals or groups with the purpose of inciting them to commit acts that will make them liable to punishment.
, supplying the group with the necessary equipment for the break-in. In the midst Adv. 1. in the midst - the middle or central part or point; "in the midst of the forest"; "could he walk out in the midst of his piece?"
midmost
 of the trial, Hardy's daughter was killed in an accident. He asked Father Doyle to perform the funeral service funeral service nmisa de cuerpo presente

funeral service nservice m funèbre

funeral service funeral n
. It was, in some sense, a turning point in Hardy's role. Finally, he decided to testify for the defendants that he had acted for the FBI to entrap them into their action.

What was unusual about the trial was that the defendants were able to do what had not been possible in the previous trials of draft board raiders (the Baltimore 4, the Catonsville 9, the Milwaukee 14, and many others). In those trials, the judges had insisted that the war could not be an issue, that the jury must consider what was done as ordinary crimes--breaking and entering, arson (where draft records were burned, as in Catonsville), destruction of government property.

In Camden, Judge Fisher did not forbid discussion of the war. The defendants were allowed to fully present the reasons for their action--that is, their passionate opposition to the war in Vietnam. And they made the most of this.

Father Doyle, at the time a newly arrived immigrant from Ireland, persuaded Judge Fisher to allow the jury to see film clips. Some showed Vietnam villages bombed, in flames In Flames is a melodic death metal band from Gothenburg, Sweden founded in 1990. Along with Dark Tranquillity and At the Gates, they pioneered what is now known as melodic death metal. ; others showed sections of Camden looking like a bombed out city. He talked about Camden, a city of poverty and violence, where thirty-one of its young men were killed in Vietnam. "The sons of the rich never went there," he said.

Called as a witness, Daniel Berrigan Daniel Berrigan, S.J. (born May 9, 1921) is a poet, American peace activist, and Roman Catholic priest. Daniel and his brother Philip performed non-violent protests against war and were for a time on the FBI Ten Most Wanted Fugitives list.  read a poem he had written while in Vietnam, "Children in the Shelter," which ends with these lines:
   I picked up the littlest
   a boy, his face
   breaded with rice (His sister calmly
   feeding him
   as we climbed down)

   In my arms, fathered
   in a moment's grace, the messiah
   of all my tears. I bore, reborn

   a Hiroshima child from hell.


Another defense witness, surprisingly, was Major Clement St. Martin St. Martin

in midwinter, gave his cloak to a freezing beggar. [Christian Hagiog.: Brewer Dictionary]

See : Kindness
, who had been in charge of the state induction center in Newark, New Jersey, from 1968 to 1971. He described in detail how the draft system discriminated systematically against the poor, the black, and the uneducated, and how it regularly gave medical exemptions to the sons of the wealthy.

Major St. Martin said he thought all draft files should be destroyed. Asked, under cross-examination, if he thought private citizens had a right to break into buildings to destroy draft files, he replied: "Probably today, if they plan another raid, I might join them."

A Vietnamese woman named Tran Khanh Tuyet testified for the defendants, describing her life in South Vietnam South Vietnam: see Vietnam. , and told a hushed courtroom: "In the name of liberty you have destroyed my country."

One of the defendants, Cookie Ridolfi, at that time a working class young woman from Philadelphia, now a law professor in California, put it bluntly: "We are not here because of a crime committed in Camden, but because of a war waged in Indochina."

It was Ridolfi who had phoned me one day in 1971 to ask if I would appear in the Camden trial as her witness. I had just returned from Los Angeles Los Angeles (lôs ăn`jələs, lŏs, ăn`jəlēz'), city (1990 pop. 3,485,398), seat of Los Angeles co., S Calif.; inc. 1850. , where I testified in the Pentagon Papers Pentagon Papers, government study of U.S. involvement in Southeast Asia. Commissioned by Secretary of Defense Robert S. McNamara in June, 1967, the 47-volume, top secret study covered the period from World War II to May, 1968.  trial of Daniel Ellsberg Daniel Ellsberg (born April 7, 1931) is a former American military analyst employed by the RAND Corporation who precipitated a national uproar in 1971 when he released the Pentagon Papers,  and Anthony Russo.

To my surprise, Judge Fisher allowed me to testify for several hours. I recounted what the Pentagon Papers told us about the history of the Vietnam War Vietnam War, conflict in Southeast Asia, primarily fought in South Vietnam between government forces aided by the United States and guerrilla forces aided by North Vietnam. , and discussed in detail the theory and history of civil disobedience civil disobedience, refusal to obey a law or follow a policy believed to be unjust. Practitioners of civil disobediance basing their actions on moral right and usually employ the nonviolent technique of passive resistance in order to bring wider attention to the  in the United States. I said that the war was not being fought for freedom and democracy; the internal memoranda of the government spoke instead, again and again, of "tin, rubber, oil."

In my previous appearances as a witness for defendants in draft board cases, judges had strictly forbidden testimony relating to the war or to civil disobedience. In fact, when I testified for the Milwaukee 14 the year before, and began to talk about Henry David Thoreau's ideas on civil disobedience, the judge stopped me cold, with words I have not been able to forget: "You can't talk about that. That's getting to the heart of the matter."

The day after my testimony in Camden, one of the defendants, Bob Good, called his mother, Mary Good, to the stand.

Mrs. Good was a conservative woman, a devout Catholic. She considered herself a patriot. One of her sons, Paul, had been killed in Vietnam.

On the witness stand, she told the jury, "I'm proud of my son because he didn't know. To take that lovely boy and to tell him, `You are fighting for your country'--How stupid can you get? Can anybody stand here and tell me how he was fighting for his country? I can't understand what we're doing over there. We should get out of this. But not one of us, not a one of us, raised our hands to do anything about it. We left it up to these people, for them to do it. And now we are prosecuting them for it. God!"

Michael Giocondo, who had been a Franciscan priest in Costa Rica before he joined the Camden group, asked the jury: "What is more important, the pieces of paper that were the draft records, or the children of Vietnam Children of Vietnam - humanitarian organization helping poor and homeless children of Da Nang area in Vietnam. Established in 1998 and based in the United States. ?"

The jurors reacted in remarkable ways. Samuel Braithwaite, a fifty-three-year-old black taxi driver, a veteran of eleven years in the Army, sent questions up to the bench (a right that jurors have but almost never exercise) to be put to the witnesses. One of his questions, which he said was directed to "all men of the clergy," was: "Didn't God make the Vietnamese? Was God prejudiced and only made American people?" Another of Braithwaite's questions: "If, when a citizen violates the law, he is punished by the government, who does the punishing when the government violates the law?"

At the reunion in Camden, Peter Fordi, once a Jesuit priest, told how he and the other defendants stood in the courtroom, linking arms as the jury filed in, after two days of deliberation. His voice broke as he recalled the verdict, "Not Guilty" on all charges, and how then there was pandemonium Pandemonium

Milton’s capital of the devils. [Br. Lit.: Paradise Lost]

See : Confusion


Pandemonium

chief city of Hell. [Br. Lit.: Paradise Lost]

See : Hell
 in the courtroom, cheering and weeping and people hugging one another. And how then everyone stood, including the court marshals and the members of the jury, and sang "Amazing Grace." And how the word spread out of the courtroom into the street where a crowd had gathered and now cheered the verdict.

Mary Good also came again to Camden, and reenacted her earlier appearance as her son's witness. When she finished, the entire courtroom, including the FBI man, stood and applauded.

The acquittal of the Camden 28 was a historic event. Supreme Court Justice William Brennan referred to it later as "one of the great trials of the twentieth century." It was the first time, in the many trials of anti-war activists who had broken into draft boards, that a jury had voted to acquit To set free, release or discharge as from an obligation, burden or accusation. To absolve one from an

obligation or a liability; or to legally certify the innocence of one charged with a crime.


acquit v.
.

Why? No doubt because it was the first of these trials in which the jury had been permitted to listen to the heartfelt stories of fellow citizens as they described their growing anguish for the victims, American and Vietnamese, of a brutal war. And the jury was led to understand how the defendants could decide to break the law in order to dramatize their protest.

Most importantly, the year of the trial was 1973. By now the majority of the American people had turned against the war. They had seen the images of the burning villages, the napalmed children, and had begun to see through the deceptions of the nation's political leaders.

As today we watch with some alarm a nation mobilized for war, the politicians of both parties in cowardly acquiescence, the media going timorously along, it is good to keep in mind that things do change. People learn, little by little. Lies are exposed. Wars once popular gradually come under suspicion. That happens when enough people speak and act in accord with their conscience, appealing to the American jury with the power of truth.

When the Camden trial was over, the black taxi driver on the jury, Samuel Braithwaite (now dead), left a letter for the defendants: "I say, well done...."

Howard Zinn is the author of "A People's History of the United States."
COPYRIGHT 2002 The Progressive, Inc.
No portion of this article can be reproduced without the express written permission from the copyright holder.
Copyright 2002, Gale Group. All rights reserved. Gale Group is a Thomson Corporation Company.

 Reader Opinion

Title:

Comment:



 

Article Details
Printer friendly Cite/link Email Feedback
Author:Zinn, Howard
Publication:The Progressive
Date:Jul 1, 2002
Words:1953
Previous Article:Minnesota wild card. (The Word from Washington).
Next Article:Raising a ruckus in Madrid. (On the Line).



Related Articles
THE BOYS in the bands.(boys are also fans of all-boy pop music groups)(Brief Article)
A Hope for Peace in Ireland.
ISRAEL - Nov. 15 - Beilin For Military Attacks.(Yossi Beilin)(Brief Article)
PALESTINE - April 23 - Arafat & Abbas Reach Accord On Cabinet.(Brief Article)
Righteous hip-hop: in an excerpt from his forthcoming book, an old-school conscious rapper critiques the direction of a cultural expression he loves....
Poet's corner.(On Board)
Is peace really possible? The Brahma Kumaris perspective.(peace & spirituality)
RULE NO. 1: PLEASE TRY TO BE FUNNIER.(U)(Review)
South grads rise again on stage, screen.(Entertainment)

Terms of use | Copyright © 2008 Farlex, Inc. | Feedback | For webmasters | Submit articles