Printer Friendly
The Free Library
14,709,344 articles and books
Member login
User name  
Password 
 
Join us Forgot password?

`PRIVATE RYAN' POUNDS AWAY LIKE GERMAN BLITZKRIEG.


Byline: Bob Strauss Daily News Film Critic

If you don't want to see the horrible things that combat can do to the human body, then don't go to ``Saving Private Ryan.'' But, if you don't mind seeing it as part of watching a great story unfold, then by all means go.

Simple as that. But the answer to this dubiously overdebated aspect of Steven Spielberg's latest and finest movie is the only thing about it that's simple.

Marshaling all the cinematic skill and storytelling instincts at his formidable command, Spielberg hasn't just made a picture that looks as artfully awful as war can be. He's made an unflinching - and because of that, truly respectful - examination of what it can do to men's behavior as well as their bodies.

More than any war movie I can remember, ``Saving Private Ryan'' shows us how soldiers think, from moment to moment and (though much less often) about the wider, murkier reasons why they're risking their lives and taking others.

And how those thoughts are put into action, running the gamut from noble to appalling, with all the contradiction and ambiguity these tired, terrified ter·ri·fy  
tr.v. ter·ri·fied, ter·ri·fy·ing, ter·ri·fies
1. To fill with terror; make deeply afraid. See Synonyms at frighten.

2. To menace or threaten; intimidate.
 and bitterly conflicted infantrymen can muster.

``Ryan'' is significantly set in World War II - the one we fought for all the right reasons - and at the point of our most significant victory. It was also a bloody fiasco: the D-Day landing at Omaha Beach

Omaha Beach was the code name for one of the principal landing points of the Allied invasion of German-occupied France in the Normandy landings on June 6 1944, during World War II.
. The symbolic tensions these events represent, between decency and brutality and winning while taking insane punishment, inform every step the movie goes on to make.

First, however, Normandy. In an allied landing craft, men are tense, vomiting, whispering to God (when things really get bad a few minutes later, they'll cry for the more certain comfort of their mothers). A competent-looking captain, John Miller (Tom Hanks Noun 1. Tom Hanks - United States film actor (born in 1956)
Hanks, Thomas J. Hanks
), realizes his hand is shaking. It's the first of many conditions he's not going to have much control over.

The landing ramp opens, the front ranks instantly disintegrate, it gets worse from there. Guys drown in the too-deep, reddening water. Those who make the beach lose limbs, guts, minds. The graphic butchery is devastatingly enhanced by trembling, handheld camerawork and desperate, rat-trap cutting (Spielberg's usual brilliant collaborators, cinematographer Janusz Kaminski and editor Michael Kahn Michael Kahn is the name of:
  • Michael Kahn (film editor) (born 1935)
  • Michael Kahn (theatre director), Washington D.C. based Artistic Director of the Shakespeare Theatre Company
, do career-best work here).

Just as shocking, though, the cold calculus of war begins to establish terrible order on the blasting chaos. Mental cruelty A course of conduct on the part of one spouse toward the other spouse that can endanger the mental and physical health and efficiency of the other spouse to such an extent as to render Continuance of the marital relation intolerable.  takes the beach, stoking the agony.

What's a GI to think, crouched behind the iron obstacle that is his only protection from withering German fire, when told the tank trap must be cleared by one of his side's engineers?

And what are we to think when, against ferocious resistance, Miller and his squad's remnants finally force a German surrender, and they - the true champions of freedom, the men who saved the world from darkness, our dads - murder their captives?

Of course, things like this happened. Intellectually, we know the war was won by slaughter. But we're simply not conditioned to think that our GIs, so thoroughly on the side of good in this one, behaved as soldiers under fire, always have and always will. Spielberg isn't out to make ``Private Ryan'' a Vietnam movie in '40s drag, though. These are not symbols of a powerful nation's underlying pathology, They're still courageous, honorable, well-meaning, heroic men - but only men.

The great insight that Spielberg lavishes on every frame, in a kaleidoscope of different ways, is that, right or wrong, all wars place their soldiers on the same ethical frontline. And never with adequate defense.

A few days after the landing, it's discovered that three boys from an Iowa family named Ryan have been killed within days of each other. A fourth son, a paratrooper, is somewhere in Normandy, maybe still alive. Miller's squad is sent into the contested countryside to find the possibly remaining Ryan so he can be shipped back home.

Eight men risked to save one. Is that right? Should Ryan's mother, the kind of thing we're theoretically fighting for over there, suffer more if it can possibly be prevented?

No and, of course, no. Caught in that vice grip of conflicting moral imperatives, what can Miller and company do? Gripe gripe
v.
To have sharp pains in the bowels.

n.
1. gripes Sharp, spasmodic pains in the bowels.

2. A firm hold; a grasp.
, argue, wonder what the hell they've gotten themselves into, sure. But mostly, they just try to stay alive, do their duty and, if possible, preserve their souls.

Dozens of other unanswerable questions arise before the squad reaches its last stand, a blasted French town where, with a few straggling strag·gle  
intr.v. strag·gled, strag·gling, strag·gles
1. To stray or fall behind.

2. To proceed or spread out in a scattered or irregular group.

n.
 paratroops, they defend a strategic bridge from overwhelmingly superior, counterattacking Panzers. Even more impressive than the D-Day sequence, this battle, unfolding in close to real time, is a sounding, furious symphony of - more contradictions - confusion and tactical ingenuity, cowardice Cowardice
See also Boastfulness, Timidity.

Acres, Bob

a swaggerer lacking in courage. [Br. Lit.: The Rivals]

Bobadill, Captain

vainglorious braggart, vaunts achievements while rationalizing faintheartedness. [Br. Lit.
 and bravery, surreal surprise and the grinding advance of military inevitability.

I've never been in war, and I know Spielberg hasn't either, so I'll reserve judgment on whether he approximates it better than a soldier-director like Oliver Stone Noun 1. Oliver Stone - United States filmmaker (born in 1946)
Stone
 has. I can say, however, that ``Private Ryan's'' climactic battle left me with a pounding headache, my neck in knots, and emotionally drained like nothing I've seen before. All of that in a good way, of course. But it's the closest I ever want to get to the real thing.

Quibbles can be made about Robert Rodat's script. The men in Miller's squad are types stamped out of numerous war movies past: the gruff, dependable sergeant (Tom Sizemore), the problematic New Yorker (Edward Burns
This article is about the actor-director born in 1968; for the co-star of 77 Sunset Strip, see Edward Byrnes. For other people named Burns, see Burns (disambiguation).
Edward Burns Jr.
), the Scripture-quoting Tennessee sharpshooter (Barry Pepper Barry Robert Pepper (born April 4, 1970 in Campbell River, British Columbia) is a Canadian-born actor. Biography
Early Life
Barry Pepper spent much of his early life traveling the world in a homemade ship. At five years of age, the family set sail.
), the Italian street tough with a heart too golden for his own good (Vin Diesel).

Only the Jewish Pvt. Mellish (Adam Goldberg

For other people named Adam Goldberg, see Adam Goldberg (disambiguation).


Adam Charles Goldberg (born October 25, 1970) is an American actor, director, and producer.
), who gets an understandable charge out of taunting German prisoners, and Cpl. Upham (Jeremy Davies Jeremy Davies may refer to:
  • Jeremy Davies (actor)
  • Jeremy Davies (exorcist)
), a meek translator who's dragooned into the mission and generally represents the civilian's point of view, suffer transcendentally interesting moments.

Matt Damon plays the elusive Pvt. Ryan as a more idealized i·de·al·ize  
v. i·de·al·ized, i·de·al·iz·ing, i·de·al·iz·es

v.tr.
1. To regard as ideal.

2. To make or envision as ideal.

v.intr.
1.
 citizen soldier than the men we spend more time with. There have been some complaints that this character's final scene cheapens the movie with simplistic sim·plism  
n.
The tendency to oversimplify an issue or a problem by ignoring complexities or complications.



[French simplisme, from simple, simple, from Old French; see simple
 sentimentality.

Arguable, but hogwash hog·wash  
n.
1. Worthless, false, or ridiculous speech or writing; nonsense.

2. Garbage fed to hogs; swill.


hogwash
Noun

Informal nonsense

Noun 1.
. Pvt. Ryan's last words Last words are a person's final words before death. For a list of well known last words, see or use the link at right.

Last words may refer to:
  • Last Words, an Australian punk band (late 1970s - early 1980s)
 give voice to what every man we've seen in the movie, and what most men who fought the good fight for the good cause, had to think at those moments when goodness had nothing to do with it. It's a perfect coda to this difficult masterpiece, posing as it does the ultimate question that has no easy answer.

THE FACTS

The film: ``Saving Private Ryan'' (R; violence, language).

The stars: Tom Hanks, Tom Sizemore, Edward Burns, Matt Damon, Jeremy Davies.

Behind the scenes: Directed by Steven Spielberg. Written by Robert Rodat. Produced by Spielberg, Ian Bryce, Mark Gordon and Gary Levinsohn. Released by DreamWorks Pictures.

Running time: Two hours, 40 minutes.

Playing: Citywide.

Our rating: Four Stars.
COPYRIGHT 1998 Daily News
No portion of this article can be reproduced without the express written permission from the copyright holder.
Copyright 1998, Gale Group. All rights reserved. Gale Group is a Thomson Corporation Company.

 Reader Opinion

Title:

Comment:



 

Article Details
Printer friendly Cite/link Email Feedback
Title Annotation:L.A. LIFE
Publication:Daily News (Los Angeles, CA)
Article Type:Movie Review
Date:Jul 24, 1998
Words:1134
Previous Article:SPIELBERG'S BATTLE OF INDEPENDENCE.(L.A. LIFE)
Next Article:LOW-BUDGET `PI' MAKES FOR EDGY MATHEMATICAL MOVIE.(L.A. LIFE)
Topics:



Related Articles
Saving Private Ryan.
Saving Private Ryan.
A brutal masterpiece. (Steven Spielberg's movie 'Saving Private Ryan')
Five pins give Tigers edge over Pleasant Hill.(Sports)
TIGERS, EAGLES AND DOLPHINS, OH MY!(News)
GRACE BRETHREN WINS THRILLER : G. BRETHREN 32, F. BAPTIST 26.(Sports)
AN L.A. STORY TURNS `WINGS' INTO `ANGELS'.(L.A. LIFE)
Pirates overpower Springfield in dual.(Sports)
Casablanca.(Movie Review)(Brief Article)
Henry Probert. Bomber Harris: His Life and Times.(Book review)

Terms of use | Copyright © 2009 Farlex, Inc. | Feedback | For webmasters | Submit articles