Printer Friendly
The Free Library
14,695,195 articles and books
Member login
User name  
Password 
 
Join us Forgot password?

`MICHAEL COLLINS' GIVES US REVELATIONS ABOUT REVOLUTION.


Byline: Bob Strauss Daily News Film Critic

When Woodrow Wilson saw D.W. Griffith's 1915 epic ``The Birth of a Nation'' - not too long before Irish revolutionaries fired the first shots to establish their own nation - the president declared that the groundbreaking movie was ``like writing history with lightning.''

Eight decades later, lightning's struck again. ``Michael Collins Michael Collins is the name of:
  • Michael Collins (actor), an English actor
  • Michael Collins (astronaut) (born 1930), an American astronaut who flew on Apollo 11 and Gemini 10
  • Michael Collins (author) (1924–2005), pseudonym of author Dennis Lynds
,'' Neil Jordan's picture about the legendary, still-controversial Irish freedom fighter, makes history electric. Intimate and exciting, complicated and mad, as beautiful as it is intelligent, this film's ultimate, overriding virtue is the way it breathes. It's a vital, visceral, spinning-top-on-the-edge-of-chaos experience, the polar opposite that which is conspicuously different in most important respects.

See also: Opposite
 of the stultifying stateliness that mummifies most political bio films.

Jordan drops us right into the heart of roiling, revolutionary Ireland of the teens and '20s, and - like the British and Irish factions that struggled for power in those troubled times - he never allows us a moment's peace. Of course, the director had a little help from reality. Not only were the events depicted here extraordinarily dramatic, but in Michael Collins, he has a central figure as made for Hollywood in his way as Griffith was in his.

Played at full-throttle by Liam Neeson, the Big Fella, as Collins was called, comes off as a man of many humors: affable, ruthless, regretful re·gret·ful  
adj.
Full of regret; sorrowful or sorry.



re·gretful·ly adv.

re·gret
 and, in the end, a power player who was tragically too thoughtful for his own good. That many at the time (and there are some still) considered Collins a criminal terrorist, an unforgivable traitor or the lost best hope for saving Ireland from its ongoing misery only enhances his movie mystique.

Beyond that, it's impossible not to make Collins appear heroic. Apart from a few effective flashes of the guerrilla genius in doubt, in guilt or in over his looming, usually brilliant head, writer-director Jordan does not waste time trying to undermine Collins' mythic stature.

He did jaunt brazenly about Dublin, undisguised and unrecognized, with a huge British bounty on his head. His best friend and fellow rebel, Harry Boland Harry Boland (1887–1922) was an Irish nationalist of the early Twentieth Century.

Born in Dublin in 1887, Boland was active in GAA circles in early life, and ultimately joined the Irish Republican Brotherhood.
 (a superbly conflicted Aidan Quinn Aidan Quinn (Irish: Aodhán Ó Cuinn) (born March 81959 in Rockford, Illinois,) is an Irish American actor also known as the Quinnster.

Aidan Quinn was born in Rockford, Illinois.
), actually did love the same woman, Kitty Kiernan Catherine Brigid (Kitty) Kiernan (1892 – 1945) was an Irish woman best known as the fiancée of assassinated Irish revolutionary leader and Chairman of the Provisional Government Michael Collins.  (Julia Roberts, fine except when she tries to approximate Maureen O'Hara feistiness under siege conditions). When Collins' assassins took out a dozen-odd British agents in separate hits one Bloody Sunday Bloody Sunday

(1905) Massacre of peaceful demonstrators in Saint Petersburg, marking the beginning of the Russian Revolution of 1905. The priest Georgy Gapon (1870–1906), hoping to present workers' request for reforms directly to Nicholas II, arranged a peaceful march
, England's Black and Tan Black and Tan

Member of a British auxiliary force employed in Ireland against the republicans (1920–21). When Irish nationalist agitation intensified after World War I, many Irish police resigned and were replaced by these temporary English recruits, who dressed in a
 bully squad retaliated by machine-gunning the crowd at a soccer game.

Jordan shows us all this and infinitely more mostly in quick, expertly staged scenes; cinematographer Chris Menges, production designer Anthony Pratt Anthony Pratt may be:
  • Anthony Pratt (Visy Board), executive
  • Anthony D. G. Pratt, art director
  • Anthony E. Pratt, inventor of the board game Clue
 and editors J. Patrick Duffner and Tony Lawson all perform at the highest levels of their crafts. Especially impressive - for this is a film without a single weak shot - is the ``Godfather''-style Bloody Sunday montage, in which Collins lovingly unloads his hopes and fears on Kiernan while his boys, all good Catholics well aware of their sins, kill their enemies up close and devastatingly personal.

This section, the best of its kind since Coppola, is so good that Jordan echoes it at the end, as Collins approaches his own fate. But as deft as he is at drawing human faces on what history shrouds as a murky terrorist war, Jordan is even better at making sense of complicated political chicanery. The rough-and-tumble of nation-building sprawls along in all its glorious mess.

And at the center of it all is the intriguing gamesmanship games·man·ship  
n.
1. The art or practice of using tactical maneuvers to further one's aims or better one's position:
 between Collins and his mentor-turned-enemy Eamon De Valera (Alan Rickman, expertly mixing cunning, egotism Egotism
See also Arrogance, Conceit, Individualism.

Baxter, Ted

TV anchorman who sees himself as most important news topic. [TV: “The Mary Tyler Moore Show” in Terrace, II, 70]

cat
 and surprising dry humor). Indeed, whenever Neeson's passionate, straightforward Collins is contrasted with Rickman's calculating master strategist, the whole of Irish politics - of most all politics - feels like it has been distilled into their rivalry.

Unavoidably, ``Michael Collins'' takes a few liberties with the record. The director freely admits, for example, that the double agent Ned Broy (played by the star of Jordan's ``The Crying Game,'' Stephen Rea) combines the real historical figure with several others like him. And to be sure, the complexity of events and sympathies that occurred back then have been necessarily simplified. Trying to explain it all, it can be assumed, would have led down a path to madness.

But quite marvelously, ``Michael Collins'' gets so much across, with more impact, about the whys and wherefores of this fascinating story, it's like being struck by history's lightning bolt Lightning bolt may refer to
  • Lightning discharge, electrical discharge within clouds or between clouds and the ground
  • Thunderbolt, a traditional expression for a discharge of lightning or a symbolic representation thereof
. Though its heart beats to the one in Michael Collins' larger-than-life breast, this is one political movie that, after insistently asking which side you are on, acknowledges that the answer to that is never simple or easy.

THE FACTS

The film: ``Michael Collins'' (R; violence, language).

The stars: Liam Neeson, Aidan Quinn, Stephen Rea, Alan Rickman, Julia Roberts.

Behind the scenes: Written and directed by Neil Jordan. Produced by Stephen Woolley. Released by Warner Bros BROS Brothers
BROS Benefits and Retirement Operations Section (King County, Washington)
BROS Barnes and Richmond Operatic Society (London, UK) 
.

Playing: Century 14, Century City; Criterion, Santa Monica.

Our rating: Four Stars.

CAPTION(S):

Photo

Photo: Liam Neeson as the title character and Aidan Quinn a s Harry Boland, both at right, surrender to British troops in ``Michael Collins.''
COPYRIGHT 1996 Daily News
No portion of this article can be reproduced without the express written permission from the copyright holder.
Copyright 1996, Gale Group. All rights reserved. Gale Group is a Thomson Corporation Company.

 Reader Opinion

Title:

Comment:



 

Article Details
Printer friendly Cite/link Email Feedback
Title Annotation:L.A. LIFE
Publication:Daily News (Los Angeles, CA)
Article Type:Movie Review
Date:Oct 11, 1996
Words:824
Previous Article:THE WORLD ACCORDING TO `COLLINS' : PUTTING IRISH HERO'S LIFE IN PERSPECTIVE.(L.A. LIFE)
Next Article:THEY OWN UP TO AUTHORING `WIVES' SONG.(L.A. LIFE)
Topics:



Related Articles
Revelation and Revolution: Basic Writings of Thomas Muntzer.
Michael Collins.
Secrets and Lies.
Michael Collins.
The Closet (Le Placard).(Review)
DOES `DEATH' NEED A MOVIE?(L.A. Life)
STILL SHOOTING HIS MOUTH OFF 'BOWLING FOR COLUMBINE' DIRECTOR MICHAEL MOORE HAS PLENTY TO SAY FOR THOSE WHO WOULD ATTACK HIS MOTIVES.(U)
NAME DOESN'T SAY IT ALL.(News)
Salvation Redefined: Catholic Parents and Religious Education in Post-Vatican II Canada. (Book Review).(Book Review)
CELEBS LEND A HAND FOR L.A. TOURISM.(Business)

Terms of use | Copyright © 2009 Farlex, Inc. | Feedback | For webmasters | Submit articles